A neural signature for the subjective experience of threat anticipation under uncertainty

Xiqin Liu, Guojuan Jiao, Feng Zhou, Keith M. Kendrick, Dezhong Yao, Shitong Xiang, Tianye Jia, Xiao‐Yong Zhang, Jie Zhang, Jianfeng Feng, Benjamin BeckerbioRxiv 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel brain-based "signature" (SUITAS) that can accurately predict subjective anxious arousal during uncertain threat anticipation. This signature is specific to anxiety, generalizable across different datasets and paradigms, and offers a promising biomarker for clinical translation in anxiety disorders.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Anxiety is a pervasive human experience, often characterized by the anticipation of future threats under conditions of uncertainty. While we know that uncertainty plays a key role in anxiety, the specific neural mechanisms underlying the subjective experience of this anxious anticipation remain unclear. Existing neuroimaging studies often struggle to isolate the neural correlates of subjective feelings from more general arousal or defensive responses. This paper aims to bridge this gap by developing a precise, data-driven neural signature that can specifically capture the subjective experience of anxious arousal during uncertain threat anticipation.

Methods

The researchers employed a combination of a novel experimental paradigm and advanced machine learning techniques.

  • Uncertainty-Variation Threat Anticipation (UVTA) Paradigm: This paradigm was designed to precisely modulate the level of anxious arousal by varying the uncertainty of impending electric shocks. Participants experienced different levels of uncertainty (certain safety, low, medium, high) signaled by distinct cues. Subjective ratings of anxious arousal were collected after each trial.
  • Multivariate Predictive Modeling (MVPA) with Support Vector Regression (SVR): This machine learning approach was used to train a "signature" (SUITAS) that predicts subjective anxious arousal from whole-brain fMRI activity patterns. The model was trained on data from one group of participants and then tested on independent datasets to assess its generalizability and specificity.
  • Cross-validation and Independent Datasets: To ensure robustness, the researchers used 10x10 cross-validation within the training dataset and evaluated the SUITAS on multiple independent datasets, including those with different cohorts, paradigms, MRI systems, and scanning parameters.
  • Specificity Testing: The SUITAS was tested against other related states like pain experience, general anticipation, and unspecific negative emotional/autonomic arousal to confirm its specificity for anxious anticipation.
  • Core System Identification: To understand the underlying neural architecture, the researchers identified consistent brain regions contributing to the predictive model by examining both model weights and encoding maps.

Datasets

The study utilized a combination of newly collected and publicly available fMRI datasets:

  • Newly Collected Data:
    • Study 1 (n=44): Used for training the SUITAS model.
  • Study 2 (n=30): Used for validating the SUITAS model with new individuals.
  • Study 3 (n=50): A prospective generalization dataset with a slightly modified UVTA paradigm.
  • Study 9 (n=65): Used for testing the SUITAS against autonomic arousal, with subsamples from Studies 2 and 3.
  • Publicly Available Datasets:
    • Study 4 (n=59): Visual threat conditioning paradigm.
  • Study 5 (n=68): Auditory threat conditioning paradigm.
  • Study 6 (n=33): Thermal pain stimulation dataset.
  • Study 7 (n=100): Monetary incentive delay (MID) task dataset for general anticipation.
  • Study 8 (n=48): Emotional picture viewing dataset for unspecific negative emotional arousal.
  • Study 10 (n=67): Fear-evoking pictures dataset for subjective fear.
  • Study 11 (n=121): Negative IAPS pictures dataset for general negative affect.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Subjective experience is decodable: The study demonstrates that subjective feelings of anxious arousal during uncertain threat anticipation can be reliably decoded from brain activity. This is a significant step towards understanding the neural basis of internal emotional states.
  • Specificity matters: The developed "signature" (SUITAS) is not just a general measure of arousal or negative affect; it specifically predicts anxious anticipation, distinguishing it from fear, pain, or general negative emotions. This specificity is crucial for developing targeted interventions.
  • Distributed neural representation: The findings strongly suggest that subjective emotional experiences, like anxious anticipation, are not localized to single brain regions but arise from the coordinated activity of distributed neural networks. This supports a constructionist view of emotion.
  • Uncertainty as a key driver: The study reinforces the idea that uncertainty is a critical component of anxiety, as evidenced by the correlation between intolerance of uncertainty and subjective anxious arousal.

Key Results

  • High prediction accuracy: The SUITAS model achieved significant prediction accuracy for subjective anxious arousal in training (r=0.59, EVS=24%), validation (r=0.61, EVS=28%), and generalization datasets (r=0.57, EVS=19%).
  • Robust generalization: The SUITAS generalized well across different cohorts, paradigms, MRI systems, and scanning parameters, indicating its broad applicability.
  • Specific to anxious arousal: The SUITAS was significantly more accurate in predicting anxious arousal (accuracy=94%) compared to fear (accuracy=79%) or negative affect (accuracy=77%). It also showed lower accuracy for pain prediction.
  • Distributed core system: A core system involving regions like the anterior insula (aINS), thalamus, and anterior midcingulate cortex (aMCC) was identified as consistently involved in subjective anxious arousal.
  • Within-individual prediction: The SUITAS could also track moment-to-moment variations in subjective anxious arousal at the individual level (r=0.50 for Study 1, r=0.41 for Study 2, r=0.37 for Study 3).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Aversive stimuli: The study primarily used electric shocks as aversive stimuli. Future research could explore the generalizability of the SUITAS to other types of uncertain threats.
  • Hyperparameter tuning: The SVR model's hyperparameters were based on previous studies. A grid search could be employed in future work to optimize these parameters.
  • Task design variations: Differences in task design (e.g., presence of ratings, stimulus type, durations) between datasets could influence results. Future studies with comparable designs would be beneficial.
  • Sample size: While the study used multiple datasets, researchers suggest that further research on a priori power and sample size estimations for multivariate neuroimaging models is needed.
  • Clinical translation: The authors highlight the potential of the SUITAS as a neuroimaging biomarker for anxiety and suggest that prospective testing in clinical settings and with different populations is warranted.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Uncertainty about potential future threats and the associated anxious anticipation represents a key feature of anxiety. However, the neural systems that underlie the subjective experience of threat anticipation under uncertainty remain unclear. Combining a novel uncertain shock anticipation paradigm that allows precise modulation of the level of momentary anxious arousal during functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) with multivariate predictive modeling, we trained a brain model that accurately predicted the intensity of subjective experience of anxious arousal on the population and individual level. In a series of analyses utilizing available fMRI datasets, we further demonstrate that the signature specifically predicted anxious anticipation and was not sensitive in predicting pain, general anticipation or unspecific arousal. The signature was functionally and spatially distinguishable from representations of subjective fear or negative affect. We developed a sensitive, generalizable, and specific neuromarker for subjective anxious arousal experienced during uncertain threat anticipation that can facilitate model development and clinical translation.
BibTeX
@misc{liu2023neural,
  author = {Xiqin Liu and Guojuan Jiao and Feng Zhou and Keith M. Kendrick and Dezhong Yao and Shitong Xiang and Tianye Jia and Xiao‐Yong Zhang and Jie Zhang and Jianfeng Feng and Benjamin Becker},
  title = {{A neural signature for the subjective experience of threat anticipation under uncertainty}},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1101/2023.09.20.558716},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure