Abstract
This paper aims to build a new multi-centrality model based on the Borda count method for the identification of important ports in maritime networks. The study finds that the Asia-Europe routes of the Maersk shipping line are not homogeneous, indicating that a few hubs occupy major shipping lines. The proposed analysis framework contributes to generating valuable managerial implications for stakeholders, such as shipping lines, ports, and port states, to ensure the robustness of investigated maritime supply chains.
Introduction: The Challenge of Port Vulnerability
Maritime networks form the backbone of global trade, yet they are highly susceptible to "cascading breakdowns." A failure at a single critical node can ripple through the entire system, causing significant economic disruption. Identifying which ports are most "important" is a complex task because importance can be defined in multiple ways: connectivity (Degree), role as a bridge (Betweenness), or accessibility (Closeness).
Previous attempts to combine these metrics often relied on subjective weighting, which introduces human bias. This research proposes a non-parametric, objective way to aggregate these different perspectives to find the true "linchpins" of the network using the Borda Count method.
Methodology: Objective Aggregation via Borda Count
The researchers modeled the maritime network using Space L topology, where links exist only between consecutive stops on a specific ship route. To rank the ports, they employed a two-step process:
- Individual Centrality Analysis: Four primary metrics were calculated for each port: Degree Centrality, Node Strength (number of shipping lines), Betweenness Centrality, and Closeness Centrality.
- Borda Count Aggregation: Instead of arbitrarily weighting these metrics, each metric acts as a "voter." In a network of 54 ports, the top-ranked port for a specific metric receives 54 points, the second 53, and so on. The final importance score is the sum of points across all metrics, identifying ports that are consistently high-performing across all definitions of centrality.
The Asia-Europe Maritime Network
The study utilizes real-world data from the Maersk shipping line (July 2016), focusing specifically on the Asia-Europe routes. This network includes 19 distinct shipping lines, 54 call ports, and 132 directed edges.
Visual analysis of the network reveals a highly centralized structure. The Suez Canal Container Terminal (SCCT) emerged as the structural heart of the Asia-Europe trade route, ranking first across nearly all individual metrics and the final aggregated score.
Key Results and the Power-Law Discovery
A significant finding of this research is that both port degree and port strength follow a power-law distribution. This indicates that the maritime network is "scale-free"—it is robust against random failures but extremely vulnerable to targeted disruptions of its major hubs.
The power-law fitting for the all-degree distribution was calculated as $p(k) = 1.404 \times k^{-1.838}$ ($R^2 = 0.9586$). The final Borda Count ranking identified the top five most critical ports as:
- SCCT (Suez Canal, Egypt)
- Tanjung Pelepas (Malaysia)
- Yantian (China)
- Rotterdam (Netherlands)
- Port Said (Egypt)
Conclusion and Future Directions
While the Borda Count model provides a robust, objective ranking, the study acknowledges certain limitations. The data represents a static snapshot from 2016 and is limited to a single carrier. Future research should incorporate dynamic network changes and actual cargo volume (TEUs) to provide a more comprehensive view of global maritime vulnerability. Nevertheless, this framework offers a vital tool for stakeholders to identify and protect the most vulnerable nodes in global supply chains.
Summary updated