A molecular portrait of maternal sepsis from Byzantine Troy

Alison Devault, Tatum D. Mortimer, Andrew Kitchen, Henrike Kiesewetter, Jacob Enk, G. Brian Golding, John Southon, Melanie Kuch, Ana T. Duggan, William Aylward, Shea N. Gardner, Jonathan Allen, Andrew King, Gerard D. Wright, Makoto Kuroda, Kengo Kato, Derek E. G. Briggs, Gino Fornaciari, Edward C. Holmes, Hendrik N. Poinar, Caitlin S. PepperelleLife 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reconstructs the genomes of ancient bacteria from calcified abscesses found in a Byzantine woman's remains, revealing a severe infection likely caused by Gardnerella vaginalis and Staphylococcus saprophyticus. The findings offer a unique molecular glimpse into ancient maternal infections and suggest that S. saprophyticus may have had a different ecological niche in the past, potentially involving closer interactions with livestock.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Pregnancy complications, particularly infections, have historically been a significant cause of maternal mortality, yet their molecular details in ancient populations are poorly understood due to the challenges of preserving and analyzing ancient DNA from soft tissues. This paper addresses this gap by investigating calcified abscesses found in an archaeological context, aiming to recover ancient microbial and host DNA to reconstruct the cause and nature of severe infections in pregnant women from the past.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-disciplinary approach:

  • Archaeological Excavation and Dating: The remains were excavated from a Byzantine cemetery in Troy, and radiocarbon dating was used to establish the age of the individual.
  • Microscopy (SEM and XRD): Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM) was used to visualize the microscopic structure of the calcified nodules, revealing "ghost cells" and potential bacterial structures. X-ray Diffraction (XRD) was used for mineralogical analysis of the concretions.
  • Ancient DNA Extraction and Sequencing: DNA was extracted from the calcified nodules and the individual's ulna bone using specialized protocols designed for ancient samples. Shotgun sequencing was performed on both UDG-treated and non-UDG-treated libraries.
  • Genome Reconstruction and Phylogenomics: Ancient bacterial genomes (Staphylococcus saprophyticus and Gardnerella vaginalis) and the human mitochondrial genome were reconstructed using de novo assembly and reference-guided approaches. Phylogenomic analyses were conducted to compare the ancient strains with historical and contemporary data.
  • Sex Estimation: Ancient DNA analysis, specifically looking for Y-chromosome reads, was used to determine the sex of the fetus, providing further evidence for the nature of the infection.

Datasets

  • Ancient Datasets:
    • DNA extracted from calcified nodules and the ulna bone of a Late Byzantine woman from Troy.
  • Ancient human mitochondrial genome.
  • Reconstructed genomes of ancient Staphylococcus saprophyticus and Gardnerella vaginalis.
  • Comparative Datasets:
    • Genomic data from modern and historical Gardnerella vaginalis strains.
  • Genomic data from modern and historical Staphylococcus saprophyticus strains, including human, bovine, and canine isolates.
  • Human Microbiome Project (HMP) vaginal samples.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Calcified abscesses as "time capsules": The study highlights how calcified pathological concretions can act as remarkable preservation sites for ancient DNA, including maternal, fetal, and bacterial DNA, offering a unique window into past infections.
  • Molecular diagnosis of ancient maternal sepsis: The researchers were able to identify the specific bacterial species responsible for the infection, providing a molecular diagnosis of a severe pregnancy complication (likely chorioamnionitis) from 800 years ago.
  • Divergent evolutionary paths of ancient bacteria: The phylogenomic analysis revealed that the ancient G. vaginalis strain was genetically similar to modern strains, suggesting its ecological role has remained relatively stable. In contrast, the ancient S. saprophyticus strain belonged to a lineage not commonly associated with human disease today, hinting at a different historical ecological niche.
  • Potential role of livestock in ancient infections: The distinct lineage of the ancient S. saprophyticus suggests a possible link to closer human-livestock interactions in the Byzantine era, which may have facilitated the transmission of bacteria that could cause human infections.

Key Results

  • Identification of causative agents: The calcified abscesses contained significant amounts of maternal, fetal, and bacterial DNA, with Gardnerella vaginalis and Staphylococcus saprophyticus being the dominant bacterial species.
  • Reconstruction of ancient genomes: Nearly complete genomes of S. saprophyticus Troy and a significant portion of G. vaginalis Troy were reconstructed.
  • Phylogenetic placement: G. vaginalis Troy fell within the contemporary genetic diversity of the species, while S. saprophyticus Troy belonged to a lineage distinct from modern human-associated strains, showing closer similarity to strains found in livestock.
  • Evidence of fetal DNA: The presence of Y-chromosome reads in the nodules, but not in the maternal ulna, strongly suggested the infection occurred during pregnancy with a male fetus, consistent with chorioamnionitis.
  • Mineralization as a preservation mechanism: The study demonstrated that the mineralization process within the abscesses provided exceptional protection against DNA degradation, preserving ancient microbial DNA with remarkable detail.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited temporal signal for S. saprophyticus: The study noted a lack of strong temporal signal in the S. saprophyticus phylogeny, making it difficult to reliably estimate evolutionary rates or dates.
  • Ecological niche of S. saprophyticus: While the study speculates on the ecological niche of S. saprophyticus in the Byzantine era, further research is needed to fully characterize its interactions with hosts and the environment.
  • Broader sampling: The authors suggest that more studies and wider sampling are needed to fully understand the niche of S. saprophyticus and the diversity of adaptive paths to bacterial virulence.
  • Understanding recombination: The study identified recombination in S. saprophyticus and G. vaginalis, highlighting the importance of mobile genetic elements in bacterial evolution and adaptation, which warrants further investigation.

Summary updated

Abstract

Pregnancy complications are poorly represented in the archeological record, despite their importance in contemporary and ancient societies. While excavating a Byzantine cemetery in Troy, we discovered calcified abscesses among a woman's remains. Scanning electron microscopy of the tissue revealed 'ghost cells', resulting from dystrophic calcification, which preserved ancient maternal, fetal and bacterial DNA of a severe infection, likely chorioamnionitis. <i>Gardnerella vaginalis</i> and <i>Staphylococcus saprophyticus</i> dominated the abscesses. Phylogenomic analyses of ancient, historical, and contemporary data showed that <i>G. vaginalis</i> Troy fell within contemporary genetic diversity, whereas <i>S. saprophyticus</i> Troy belongs to a lineage that does not appear to be commonly associated with human disease today. We speculate that the ecology of <i>S. saprophyticus</i> infection may have differed in the ancient world as a result of close contacts between humans and domesticated animals. These results highlight the complex and dynamic interactions with our microbial milieu that underlie severe maternal infections.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{devault2017molecular,
  author = {Alison Devault and Tatum D. Mortimer and Andrew Kitchen and Henrike Kiesewetter and Jacob Enk and G. Brian Golding and John Southon and Melanie Kuch and Ana T. Duggan and William Aylward and Shea N. Gardner and Jonathan Allen and Andrew King and Gerard D. Wright and Makoto Kuroda and Kengo Kato and Derek E. G. Briggs and Gino Fornaciari and Edward C. Holmes and Hendrik N. Poinar and Caitlin S. Pepperell},
  title = {{A molecular portrait of maternal sepsis from Byzantine Troy}},
  booktitle = {eLife},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.7554/elife.20983},
}
Figure