A low-dissipation shock-capturing framework with flexible nonlinear dissipation control

Yue Li, Lin Fu, Nikolaus A. Adams

Abstract

High-fidelity fluid simulations require a delicate balance between capturing sharp discontinuities and resolving fine-scale turbulence. Traditional methods often suffer from excessive numerical dissipation or instability near shocks. This paper presents the TENO-M framework, a novel approach that integrates nonlinear limiters into the Targeted ENO (TENO) paradigm. By filtering nonsmooth candidate stencils rather than discarding them, TENO-M provides flexible dissipation control, enabling robust shock-capturing and high-resolution turbulence modeling.

Introduction

In Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD), researchers face a fundamental trade-off. Simulating shock waves, such as those from supersonic aircraft, requires numerical dissipation to prevent non-physical oscillations. Conversely, simulating fine-scale turbulence requires low dissipation to preserve small-scale eddies. Existing methods like Weighted Essentially Non-Oscillatory (WENO) schemes often introduce too much dissipation, blurring fine details. While Targeted ENO (TENO) schemes improved upon this by using optimal linear weights in smooth regions, they traditionally discard "nonsmooth" candidate stencils entirely. This binary selection can lead to numerical artifacts or insufficient stability near extreme discontinuities. The TENO-M framework addresses this by introducing flexible nonlinear dissipation control.

Methods

The TENO-M framework innovates on the standard TENO approach through a three-step process:

Stencil Selection

The algorithm first measures the smoothness of several candidate stencils. As shown in Figure 1, these stencils ($S_0$ to $S_5$) represent local groups of data points used to calculate the numerical flux at cell interfaces.

Candidate stencil configurations for the TENO-M framework.

The Filtering Step

Unlike traditional TENO, which discards stencils flagged as nonsmooth, TENO-M passes these stencils through a nonlinear limiter. This allows the framework to retain useful information while suppressing oscillations. Three types of limiters were evaluated:

  • Monotonicity-Preserving (MP): Optimized for maintaining local extrema in turbulent flows.
  • Total Variation Diminishing (TVD): Provides robust oscillation suppression for strong shocks.
  • Van Albada (VA): A standard second-order limiter for general stability.

Linear Assembly

Because the candidate stencils are pre-filtered to be oscillation-free, the final numerical flux can be assembled using optimal linear weights. This eliminates the complex weight renormalization required in original TENO schemes. The coefficients for these linear combinations are detailed in the table below.

Linear coefficients for the numerical flux calculation across different candidate stencils.

Results and Discussion

The TENO-M framework was validated against a suite of rigorous mathematical benchmarks:

  • Accuracy Preservation: The schemes successfully maintained theoretical 6th- and 8th-order accuracy in smooth regions.
  • Turbulence Resolution: In the Taylor-Green Vortex benchmark, the TENO8A-M-MP variant faithfully reproduced the Kolmogorov $-5/3$ energy spectrum, demonstrating its effectiveness for Implicit Large Eddy Simulation (ILES).
  • Robustness in Extremes: The framework successfully handled extreme cases like the Noh problem (infinitely strong shock) and the Le Blanc problem (pressure ratio of $10^9$), where standard TENO8A often fails or produces non-physical density overshoots.
  • Computational Efficiency: Despite the additional filtering step, TENO-M is computationally efficient. In 2D Double Mach reflection tests, TENO8A-M-TVD5 was approximately 1.5% faster than standard TENO8A due to the simplified assembly logic.

Conclusion

TENO-M provides a versatile framework for CFD, allowing users to tune numerical dissipation as a "knob" by selecting appropriate limiters. This hybridization occurs seamlessly within the stencil selection process, avoiding the need for separate "troubled cell" indicators. Future work will explore applications in Magnetohydrodynamics (MHD) and multi-phase flows, as well as adaptation for unstructured meshes in industrial settings.

Summary updated

Abstract

In this work, a framework to construct arbitrarily high-order low-dissipation shock-capturing schemes with flexible and controllable nonlinear dissipation for convection-dominated problems is proposed. While a set of candidate stencils of incremental width is constructed, each one is indicated as smooth or nonsmooth by the ENO-like stencil selection procedure proposed in the targeted essentially non-oscillatory (TENO) scheme [Fu et al., Journal of Computational Physics 305 (2016): 333-359]. Rather than being discarded directly as with TENO schemes, the nonsmooth candidates are filtered by an extra nonlinear limiter, such as a monotonicity-preserving (MP) limiter or a total variation diminishing (TVD) limiter. Consequently, high-order reconstruction is achieved by assembling candidate fluxes with optimal linear weights since they are either smooth reconstructions or filtered ones which feature good non-oscillation property. A weight renormalization procedure as with the standard TENO paradigm is not necessary. This new framework concatenates the concepts of TENO, WENO and other nonlinear limiters for shock-capturing, and provides a new insight to designing low-dissipation nonlinear schemes. Through the adaptation of nonlinear limiters, nonlinear dissipation in the newly proposed framework can be controlled separately without affecting the performance in smooth regions. Based on the proposed framework, a family of new six- and eight-point nonlinear schemes with controllable dissipation is proposed. A set of critical benchmark cases involving strong discontinuities and broadband fluctuations is simulated. Numerical results reveal that the proposed new schemes capture discontinuities sharply and resolve the high-wavenumber fluctuations with low dissipation, while maintaining the desired accuracy order in smooth regions.
BibTeX
@article{li2020low,
  author = {Yue Li and Lin Fu and Nikolaus A. Adams},
  title = {{A low-dissipation shock-capturing framework with flexible nonlinear dissipation control}},
  journal = {Journal of Computational Physics},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1016/j.jcp.2020.109960},
}
Figure