A Large Scale Comprehensive Evaluation of Single-Slice Ring Oscillator and PicoPUF Bit Cells on 28nm Xilinx FPGAs

Chongyan Gu, Chip-Hong Chang, Weiqiang Liu, Neil Hanley, Jack Miskelly, Máire O׳Neill2019 · DOI

Abstract

Many field programmable gate array (FPGA)-based security primitives have been developed, e.g., physical unclonable functions (PUFs) and true random number generator (TRNG). To accurately evaluate the performance of a PUF or other security designs, data from a large number of devices are required. A slice is the smallest reconfigurable logic block in an FPGA. The maximum or minimum entropy, exploitable from each slice of an FPGA, is an important factor for the design of a single-bit disorder-based security primitive. Previous research has shown that the locations of slices can impact the quality of delay-based PUF designs implemented on FPGAs. To investigate the effect of the placement of each single-bit PUF cell free from the routing resource constraint between slices, single-bit ring oscillator (RO) and identity-based PUF design (PicoPUF) cells that can each be fully fitted into a single slice are evaluated. 217 Xilinx Artix-7 FPGAs has been employed to provide a large-scale comprehensive analysis for the two designs. This is the first time two different single slice based security entities have been investigated and compared on 28nm Xilinx FPGA. Experimental results, including uniqueness, uniformity, correlation, reliability, bit-aliasing and min-entropy, based on 4 different floorplan locations are presented. The experimental results demonstrate that the lower the correlation between devices, the higher the min-entropy and uniqueness for both designs on the FPGAs. While the implementation location of both designs on the FPGA affects their performances, the overall min-entropy, correlation and uniqueness of PicoPUF are slightly higher than those of RO. All other metrics, including uniformity, bit-aliasing and reliability of the PicoPUF are slightly lower than those of the RO. The raw data for the PicoPUF design is made publicly available to enable the research community to use them for benchmarking and/or validation.

Introduction

In modern hardware security, Physical Unclonable Functions (PUFs) serve as "silicon fingerprints," leveraging the inherent, uncontrollable manufacturing variations of integrated circuits to generate unique identifiers or cryptographic keys. Similarly, True Random Number Generators (TRNGs) utilize this stochastic silicon noise to produce high-quality randomness. However, a significant challenge in FPGA-based security primitives is the influence of routing. Most PUF designs span multiple logic slices, meaning the delays introduced by the interconnecting wires often overshadow the manufacturing variations of the logic gates themselves.

To isolate the raw entropy of the silicon, this research evaluates "single-slice" primitives. By constraining the entire design within a single FPGA slice—the smallest reconfigurable unit—researchers can minimize the "noise" of inter-slice routing and determine the maximum exploitable entropy per unit of FPGA real estate.

Methodology: Single-Slice Primitives

The study compares two distinct single-slice architectures: the Ring Oscillator (RO) and the PicoPUF.

  1. Ring Oscillator (RO): A traditional 3-stage inverter loop. Its oscillation frequency is a direct function of the local silicon characteristics within that specific slice.
  2. PicoPUF: An identity-based PUF that utilizes a cross-coupled NAND gate structure. This configuration creates a "race condition" between two paths; the winner of this race determines whether the output bit is a logic 0 or 1.
The architecture of a single-slice PicoPUF cell, featuring cross-coupled NAND gates to generate a race condition.

Large-Scale Experimental Setup

To ensure statistical significance, the researchers developed a massive testbed. While the final analysis utilized 217 Xilinx Artix-7 FPGAs (28nm process), the physical infrastructure was designed to accommodate hundreds of boards simultaneously. This scale allowed for the collection of data from over 8,000 PicoPUF instances and 6,592 RO instances.

The experimental testbed used to collect data from over 200 FPGA boards simultaneously.

Beyond sheer numbers, the study performed a spatial analysis by testing four specific floorplan locations: Left-Upper, Left-Lower, Right-Upper, and Right-Lower. This allowed the team to observe how physical positioning on the chip—relative to resources like the clock distribution network—impacts primitive performance.

Comparative Analysis and Results

The evaluation employed standard hardware security metrics, with 0.5 representing the ideal value for uniqueness and uniformity.

Uniqueness and Entropy

Both designs demonstrated excellent uniqueness, effectively distinguishing between different chips. The PicoPUF achieved a uniqueness score of 0.4886, slightly outperforming the RO's 0.4805. More significantly, the PicoPUF showed higher min-entropy (0.8225 vs. 0.7825), suggesting it is more efficient at extracting "pure" randomness from the silicon.

Reliability and Uniformity

While the PicoPUF leads in entropy, the Ring Oscillator proved to be more stable. RO bit cells exhibited higher reliability, with a much smaller difference between stable 0s and 1s (1–3%) compared to the PicoPUF (~10%). This suggests that while PicoPUF is more unique, RO is more consistent over time.

Spatial Bias

The results confirmed that location matters. Ring Oscillators showed a higher bias when placed near the clock distribution network, indicating that global FPGA structures can introduce systematic (non-random) variations.

Conclusion

This comprehensive evaluation highlights the trade-offs between different single-slice security primitives. The PicoPUF offers a lightweight, high-entropy solution ideal for resource-constrained environments where uniqueness is paramount. Conversely, the Ring Oscillator provides superior reliability and uniformity. By providing the raw PicoPUF dataset to the public, the authors enable further benchmarking and validation within the hardware security community, paving the way for more robust FPGA-based cryptographic systems.

Summary updated

Abstract

Many field programmable gate array (FPGA)-based security primitives have been developed, e.g., physical unclonable functions (PUFs) and true random number generator (TRNG). To accurately evaluate the performance of a PUF or other security designs, data from a large number of devices are required. A slice is the smallest reconfigurable logic block in an FPGA. The maximum or minimum entropy, exploitable from each slice of an FPGA, is an important factor for the design of a single-bit disorder-based security primitive. Previous research has shown that the locations of slices can impact the quality of delay-based PUF designs implemented on FPGAs. To investigate the effect of the placement of each single-bit PUF cell free from the routing resource constraint between slices, single-bit ring oscillator (RO) and identity-based PUF design (PicoPUF) cells that can each be fully fitted into a single slice are evaluated. 217 Xilinx Artix-7 FPGAs has been employed to provide a large-scale comprehensive analysis for the two designs. This is the first time two different single slice based security entities have been investigated and compared on 28nm Xilinx FPGA. Experimental results, including uniqueness, uniformity, correlation, reliability, bit-aliasing and min-entropy, based on 4 different floorplan locations are presented. The experimental results demonstrate that the lower the correlation between devices, the higher the min-entropy and uniqueness for both designs on the FPGAs. While the implementation location of both designs on the FPGA affects their performances, the overall min-entropy, correlation and uniqueness of PicoPUF are slightly higher than those of RO. All other metrics, including uniformity, bit-aliasing and reliability of the PicoPUF are slightly lower than those of the RO. The raw data for the PicoPUF design is made publicly available to enable the research community to use them for benchmarking and/or validation.
BibTeX
@misc{gu2019large,
  author = {Chongyan Gu and Chip-Hong Chang and Weiqiang Liu and Neil Hanley and Jack Miskelly and Máire O׳Neill},
  title = {{A Large Scale Comprehensive Evaluation of Single-Slice Ring Oscillator and PicoPUF Bit Cells on 28nm Xilinx FPGAs}},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1145/3338508.3359570},
}
Figure