A knowledge transfer model for COVID-19 predicting and non-pharmaceutical intervention simulation

Jingyuan Wang, Xin Lin, Yuxi Liu, Qilegeri, Kai Feng, Hui LinarXiv 2020 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

Since December 2019, a novel coronavirus (2019-nCoV) has broken out globally, causing significant respiratory disease and severe pneumonia. Mathematical and empirical models for forecasting disease outbreaks have received increasing attention for their role in public health planning. We propose a Susceptible-Undiagnosed-Infected-Removed (SUIR) model to offer effective prediction, prevention, and control of infectious diseases. Our model is a modified susceptible-infected-recovered (SIR) model that incorporates an undiagnosed state and utilizes pre-trained effective reproduction numbers. By combining domain knowledge of the epidemic with environmental factors, we estimate the effective reproduction number to better approximate the initial susceptible population. Our findings demonstrate that the SUIR model is more precise than the traditional SIR model, providing critical implications for forecasting COVID-19 trends and estimating the impact of non-pharmaceutical interventions.

Addressing the "Undiagnosed" Gap

Early in the COVID-19 pandemic, standard mathematical models like SIR struggled to provide accurate forecasts due to two major hurdles:

  1. The "Undiagnosed" Gap: Traditional models assume the infectious population is known. In reality, a large portion of infectious individuals remains undiagnosed, silently driving the spread.
  2. The Initialization Problem: Starting a model requires estimating the "initial susceptible population" ($S_0$). Using a country's total population often leads to massive overestimations, as not everyone is exposed simultaneously.

The SUIR Model Architecture

The core of this research is the SUIR Model, which divides the population into five distinct compartments to better reflect the reality of clinical diagnosis and quarantine measures.

The SUIR model architecture, illustrating the transitions between susceptible, undiagnosed, confirmed, isolated, and removed states.
  • S (Susceptible): Healthy individuals at risk.
  • U (Undiagnosed): Infected individuals who are not yet confirmed but are infectious.
  • I (Infected): Confirmed cases that are not yet quarantined (still infectious).
  • IS (Infected & Isolated): Confirmed cases that are quarantined (no longer infectious).
  • R (Removed): Individuals who have recovered or died.

By adding the U (Undiagnosed) state, the model acknowledges that confirmed cases are just the tip of the iceberg. This structural change significantly reduces the error in predicting the peak of the outbreak.

The "Knowledge Transfer" Twist

To solve the initialization problem, the authors employed a knowledge transfer method. Instead of guessing $S_0$, they used a fixed-effects panel regression on data from 100 Chinese cities to model the relationship between the effective reproduction number ($R(t)$) and environmental variables.

3D surface plot showing the relationship between the reproduction number (R), temperature, and relative humidity.

As shown in the environmental analysis, lower temperatures and lower humidity correlate with higher transmission rates ($R$). This domain knowledge allowed the researchers to "transfer" the learned dynamics of the virus from early-hit regions in China to other countries by using local meteorological data to estimate a more realistic initial susceptible population. Finally, the Nelder-Mead simplex algorithm was used to fit the model's parameters (such as infection rate $\beta$ and diagnosis rate $\epsilon$) to historical incidence data from the JHU CSSE database.

Key Results and Policy Simulation

The SUIR model demonstrated superior performance across multiple metrics:

  • Higher Accuracy: The model achieved a 38.4% lower prediction error on average compared to the traditional SIR model across several countries.
  • Validation: The model successfully tracked the "flattening of the curve" in Italy and Germany, correctly identifying the mid-April peaks in active cases.
  • Intervention Simulation: The model serves as a "digital twin" for policy. By adjusting the parameter $\rho$ (the ratio of close contacts isolated), researchers simulated various lockdown scenarios. Simulations showed that if the isolation ratio of close contacts dropped by just 45%, the peak number of patients requiring treatment would more than double.

Conclusion

The SUIR model provides a more nuanced and accurate framework for epidemic forecasting by accounting for the "invisible" undiagnosed population and leveraging environmental domain knowledge. While the current model assumes a closed system and does not yet account for imported cases or waning immunity, it represents a significant step forward in using knowledge transfer to calibrate predictive models for global health crises.

Summary updated

Abstract

Since December 2019, A novel coronavirus (2019-nCoV) has been breaking out in China, which can cause respiratory diseases and severe pneumonia. Mathematical and empirical models relying on the epidemic situation scale for forecasting disease outbreaks have received increasing attention. Given its successful application in the evaluation of infectious diseases scale, we propose a Susceptible-Undiagnosed-Infected-Removed (SUIR) model to offer the effective prediction, prevention, and control of infectious diseases. Our model is a modified susceptible-infected-recovered (SIR) model that injects undiagnosed state and offers pre-training effective reproduction number. Our SUIR model is more precise than the traditional SIR model. Moreover, we combine domain knowledge of the epidemic to estimate effective reproduction number, which addresses the initial susceptible population of the infectious disease model approach to the ground truth. These findings have implications for the forecasting of epidemic trends in COVID-19 as these could help the growth of estimating epidemic situation.
BibTeX
@misc{wang2020knowledge,
  author = {Jingyuan Wang and Xin Lin and Yuxi Liu and Qilegeri and Kai Feng and Hui Lin},
  title = {{A knowledge transfer model for COVID-19 predicting and non-pharmaceutical intervention simulation}},
  year = {2020},
  eprint = {2004.12433},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2004.12433},
}
Figure