Constrained Supersymmetry after the Higgs Boson Discovery: A global analysis with Fittino

P. Bechtle, K. Desch, Herbert K. Dreiner, M. Hamer, Michael Krämer, Ben O’Leary, W. Porod, X. Prudent, Björn Sarrazin, Tim Stefaniak, M. Uhlenbrock, Peter Wienemann

Abstract

We present preliminary results from the latest global fit analysis of the constrained minimal supersymmetric standard model (CMSSM) performed within the Fittino framework. The fit includes low-energy and astrophysical observables as well as collider constraints from the non-observation of new physics in supersymmetric searches at the LHC. Furthermore, the Higgs boson mass and signal rate measurements from both the LHC and Tevatron experiments are included via the program HiggsSignals. Although the LHC exclusion limits and the Higgs mass measurements put tight constraints on the viable parameter space, we find an acceptable fit quality once the Higgs signal rates are included.

Introduction

For decades, Supersymmetry (SUSY) has been the leading candidate to solve the "fine-tuning" problem of the Standard Model (SM). However, the landmark discovery of the Higgs boson at ~125 GeV and the lack of direct evidence for "sparticles" (supersymmetric partners) at the LHC have put simple SUSY models under immense pressure. This paper utilizes the Fittino framework to perform a comprehensive global fit of the Constrained Minimal Supersymmetric Standard Model (CMSSM), identifying the specific regions of parameter space that remain viable given current experimental data.

Methods and Framework

The researchers performed a global analysis using a frequentist statistical approach. The core of their work involves the Fittino framework, which utilizes an auto-adaptive Markov Chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) algorithm to sample a multi-dimensional parameter space efficiently. To ensure accuracy, they integrated several specialized theoretical tools, including SPHENO and FEYNHIGGS for particle spectra, and HIGGSBOUNDS and HIGGSSIGNALS for comparing predictions against LHC and Tevatron data.

A key methodological contribution was the refined treatment of ATLAS SUSY exclusion limits. The authors accounted for how the trilinear coupling ($A_0$) affects the mass of the light stop quark ($\tilde{t}_1$), which in turn impacts signal yields and exclusion boundaries.

LHC chi-squared contribution in the M0–M1/2 plane, comparing the Fittino implementation with ATLAS expected and observed limits.

Experimental Datasets

The analysis incorporates a wide array of experimental inputs:

  • Higgs Physics: 47 distinct signal rate measurements and four mass measurements from the LHC and Tevatron.
  • Direct Searches: Search results from 20.3 fb⁻¹ of ATLAS data at $\sqrt{s} = 8$ TeV.
  • Flavor Physics: Precision measurements of rare B-decays ($B_s \to \mu\mu$ and $B \to \tau\nu$) from LHCb and Belle.
  • Astrophysics: Measurements of Cold Dark Matter (CDM) relic density from the Planck Collaboration and direct detection limits from XENON100.

Key Insights and Theoretical Implications

The global fit reveals several critical characteristics of the remaining CMSSM parameter space:

  1. Stau Co-annihilation: The fit strongly prefers the "stau co-annihilation" region. In this scenario, the lightest neutralino (a dark matter candidate) and the stau (the partner of the tau lepton) are nearly degenerate in mass, allowing them to interact in the early universe to produce the observed dark matter density.
  2. Trilinear Coupling ($A_0$): To achieve a Higgs mass of 125 GeV, the model requires significant mixing in the top-squark sector, driving the fit toward large negative values of $A_0$.
  3. The $(g-2)_\mu$ Tension: While SUSY could theoretically resolve the discrepancy in the muon's anomalous magnetic moment, the high mass scales required by LHC data push the model into a regime where it can no longer easily explain this tension.
  4. SM-like Higgs: The allowed regions feature a decoupled heavy Higgs spectrum, meaning the lightest SUSY Higgs is phenomenologically almost identical to the Standard Model Higgs.

Key Results

The authors identified a best-fit point for the CMSSM parameters that provides an acceptable fit to the data ($\chi^2/\text{ndf} = 49.6/59$):

  • $M_0$ (Scalar mass): 504 GeV
  • $M_{1/2}$ (Gaugino mass): 1016 GeV
  • $A_0$ (Trilinear coupling): -2870 GeV
  • $\tan\beta$: 18

In this scenario, squarks are heavy (~2 TeV), while the lightest stop quark ($\tilde{t}_1$) could be as light as ~750 GeV. The lightest neutralino and stau are nearly degenerate at approximately 350–600 GeV.

Allowed parameter regions in the M0–M1/2 plane showing the 68% and 95% confidence levels and the best-fit point (star).

Conclusion and Future Outlook

While the CMSSM remains a viable extension of the Standard Model, its parameter space is increasingly constrained. The model is being pushed into regions where it becomes difficult to distinguish from the Standard Model at current energies. Future work will involve exploring more general SUSY models that might better address the $(g-2)_\mu$ tension and incorporating more inclusive Higgs data as it becomes available from the LHC.

Summary updated

Abstract

We present preliminary results from the latest global fit analysis of the constrained minimal supersymmetric standard model (CMSSM) performed within the Fittino framework. The fit includes low-energy and astrophysical observables as well as collider constraints from the non-observation of new physics in supersymmetric searches at the LHC. Furthermore, the Higgs boson mass and signal rate measurements from both the LHC and Tevatron experiments are included via the program HiggsSignals. Although the LHC exclusion limits and the Higgs mass measurements put tight constraints on the viable parameter space, we find an acceptable fit quality once the Higgs signal rates are included.
BibTeX
@misc{bechtle2013constrained,
  author = {P. Bechtle and K. Desch and Herbert K. Dreiner and M. Hamer and Michael Krämer and Ben O’Leary and W. Porod and X. Prudent and Björn Sarrazin and Tim Stefaniak and M. Uhlenbrock and Peter Wienemann},
  title = {{Constrained Supersymmetry after the Higgs Boson Discovery: A global analysis with Fittino}},
  year = {2013},
  eprint = {1310.3045},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1310.3045},
}
Figure