A Geographic Information System (GIS)-Based Investigation of Spatiotemporal Characteristics of Pirate Attacks in the Maritime Industry

Qiong Chen, Hongyu Zhang, Yui‐yip Lau, Kaiyuan Liu, Adolf K.y. Ng, Weijie Chen, Qingmei Liao, Maxim A. DulebenetsJournal of Marine Science and Engineering 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper uses Geographic Information System (GIS) analysis to map and understand the spatial and temporal patterns of global pirate attacks between 1994 and 2019. By identifying "hot spots" and "cold spots" of piracy, the research provides crucial insights for developing targeted strategies to combat this persistent threat to maritime trade.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Maritime transportation is the backbone of global trade, moving over 90% of international cargo. However, this vital industry is constantly threatened by piracy, which disrupts supply chains, incurs significant costs, and endangers seafarers. While piracy has been studied, a comprehensive understanding of its evolving spatial and temporal dynamics, especially across different vessel types, has been lacking. This paper aims to fill this gap by providing a detailed, GIS-based analysis of pirate attack patterns, moving beyond simple incident counts to reveal underlying geographical trends and temporal shifts.

Methods

The researchers employed a suite of GIS-based spatial analysis techniques:

  • Kernel Density Analysis: This method was used to identify areas with a high concentration of pirate attacks, effectively visualizing the "hot spots" where piracy is most prevalent. It works by creating a smooth, continuous surface representing the density of events, with higher values indicating more frequent occurrences.
  • Hot Spot Analysis (Getis-Ord Gi*): This statistical tool was applied to identify statistically significant clusters of pirate attacks, distinguishing between "hot spots" (areas with a high concentration of attacks) and "cold spots" (areas with a low concentration). This analysis helps pinpoint areas requiring focused attention.
  • Spatiotemporal Hot Spot Analysis: This advanced technique extends the hot spot analysis by examining how these patterns change over time. It categorizes trends into eight types (e.g., new hot spots, continuous cold spots) to understand the dynamic evolution of piracy risk.

Datasets

The study utilized data on pirate attacks collected by the International Maritime Bureau (IMB) from July 1994 to December 2019. Out of an initial 7280 identified attacks, 3685 records with complete temporal and spatial information, as well as vessel type, were used for the analysis. The analysis specifically focused on five major vessel types: tankers, dry bulk carriers, container vessels, general cargo vessels, and tugs, which accounted for 90.50% of the valid data.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Piracy is Clustered, Not Random: The analysis strongly suggests that pirate attacks are not uniformly distributed but rather exhibit significant spatial clustering, concentrated in specific geographical regions.
  • Socioeconomic Factors Matter: The study highlights a correlation between pirate attack hot spots and areas experiencing economic depression, high unemployment, and social unrest, suggesting that these factors contribute to the conditions that foster piracy.
  • Dynamic Hot and Cold Spots: Piracy is not static. The spatiotemporal analysis reveals that hot and cold spots evolve over time, indicating that areas previously considered safe might become riskier, and vice versa.
  • Vessel Type Similarities and Differences: While the general hot and cold spot locations for tankers, dry bulk carriers, and container vessels are similar, the trends of these spots can differ significantly within the same region, suggesting that specific vessel types might be more vulnerable or targeted in different ways over time.

Key Results

  • Major Hotspots Identified: The study consistently identified the waters off Somalia, the Strait of Malacca, the Philippines, the Bay of Bengal, the Gulf of Guinea, and the northwest of South America as common locations for pirate attacks. The Strait of Malacca and Somalia were particularly highlighted as core areas.
  • Tanker and Dry Bulk Carrier Patterns: For tankers and dry bulk carriers, the cold and hot spots were found to be largely similar, with the Bay of Bengal, Strait of Malacca, Philippines, Indonesia, and Malaysia being prominent hot spots.
  • Somalia as a Cold Spot (Despite High Attacks): Interestingly, despite being a well-known piracy hub, the waters off Somalia were identified as a "cold spot" for tankers, dry bulk carriers, and container vessels. This is attributed to the successful international naval escort operations and counter-piracy efforts that significantly reduced attacks in this region during certain periods.
  • Diverse Spatiotemporal Trends: The spatiotemporal analysis revealed various trends, including "new hot spots" (areas that recently became statistically significant hot spots), "continuous hot spots" (areas with persistent high attack rates), and "oscillating cold spots" (areas where attack frequency fluctuates).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Data Limitations: The study acknowledges that a significant portion of the initial data (3595 out of 7280 attacks) could not be analyzed due to missing temporal, spatial, or vessel type information.
  • Future Research Directions:
    • Comparative Studies: Future research could compare piracy patterns before and after major global events like the COVID-19 pandemic to understand shifts in sea freight transport networks.
  • Qualitative Insights: In-depth interviews with maritime stakeholders (ship operators, policymakers, etc.) could provide valuable qualitative data on organizational responses to piracy.
  • Global Maritime Piracy Risk Assessment: Developing a comprehensive model for assessing global maritime piracy risk could lead to more resilient supply chains.
  • Reinforcing Patrols: The study suggests reinforcing maritime patrols and escorts in identified hot spots.
  • Ship Owner Recommendations: Ship owners are advised to increase crew anti-piracy awareness, enhance equipment, and consider daytime navigation in high-risk areas.

Summary updated

Abstract

Maritime transportation is vital for the movement of cargo between different continents and distant locations but can be disrupted by the frequent occurrence of pirate attacks. Based on the pirate attacks from July 1994 to December 2019, a spatial analysis of pirate attacks using a Geographic Information System (GIS) was conducted in the present study using the data available for tankers, dry bulk carriers, container vessels, general cargo vessels, and tugs. The adoption of the kernel density analysis was intended to identify the spatial pattern of global pirate attacks. The research results demonstrated that the pirate attacks showed a clustering pattern and were mostly associated with areas experiencing economic depression, a high unemployment rate, and social unrest. Accordingly, spatiotemporal hot spot analysis was carried out to recognize the changing directions of cold spots and hot spots over a period of time. The waters off Somalia, the Strait of Malacca, the Philippines, the Bay of Bengal, the Gulf of Guinea, and the northwest of South America were found to be the common locations of pirate attacks. The cold and hot spots of pirate attacks on the three key vessel types, including tankers, dry bulk carriers, and container vessels, were found to be similar. When considering the same area, the trends of cold and hot spots of different vessel types being attacked were substantially different. This study can provide a useful guideline for the International Maritime Organization and other relevant organizations in the world to design and implement targeted strategies to combat and mitigate pirate attacks. Additionally, the introduction of a GIS may help to envision the spatial and temporal distribution of pirate attacks and to explore the characteristics of pirate behaviors at sea and the patterns of piracy.
BibTeX
@article{chen2023geographic,
  author = {Qiong Chen and Hongyu Zhang and Yui‐yip Lau and Kaiyuan Liu and Adolf K.Y. Ng and Weijie Chen and Qingmei Liao and Maxim A. Dulebenets},
  title = {{A Geographic Information System (GIS)-Based Investigation of Spatiotemporal Characteristics of Pirate Attacks in the Maritime Industry}},
  journal = {Journal of Marine Science and Engineering},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/jmse11122295},
}
Figure