A Gender-Informed Smoking Cessation App for Women: Protocol for an Acceptability and Feasibility Study

Osnat C. Melamed, Kamna Mehra, Roshni Panda, Nadia Minian, Scott Veldhuizen, Laurie Zawertailo, Leslie Buckley, Marta M. Maslej, Lorraine Greaves, Andreea C. Brabete, Jonathan Rose, Matt Ratto, Peter Selby

TL;DR

This paper introduces "My Change Plan-Women" (MCP-W), a novel smartphone app designed to support women in quitting smoking by incorporating gender-specific content and behavioral change techniques. The study assesses the app's acceptability and feasibility among 30 women smokers, aiming to address the unique challenges women face in cessation.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Despite smoking being a leading cause of preventable death and disease, women experience lower success rates in quitting compared to men. This disparity is attributed to sex- and gender-related factors, including less effective smoking cessation medications for women and unique motives and barriers to quitting. Current smoking cessation apps are largely gender-neutral, failing to address these specific needs. This research aims to bridge this gap by developing and testing a gender-informed app tailored for women.

Methods

The study employs a prospective, single-group, mixed-methods design. The core of the intervention is the "My Change Plan-Women" (MCP-W) app, co-developed with patient partners and experts. MCP-W builds on an existing gender-neutral app (MCP) by incorporating its evidence-based behavioral change techniques (goal setting, trigger identification, coping strategies, tracking, financial savings) and adding gender-informed content. This new content includes testimonials and animated videos addressing specific barriers women face, such as stress, social influences, and managing emotions.

Thirty women smokers will trial the app for 28 days. Participants will complete baseline and follow-up surveys. Acceptability is measured using the Theoretical Framework of Acceptability (TFA), focusing on whether participants perceive the app as helpful for smoking cessation. Feasibility is assessed by the proportion of participants who use the app for at least 7 days. Additionally, semistructured interviews will gather qualitative feedback on user experience and suggestions for improvement.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Gender-Specific Needs in Cessation: The paper highlights that a one-size-fits-all approach to smoking cessation is insufficient, particularly for women, due to unique biological, social, and psychological factors influencing their smoking behavior and quit attempts.
  • Co-design for Relevance: The co-development of the MCP-W app with women who have lived experience of smoking is a crucial insight, ensuring the app's content and design are relevant and resonate with the target audience.
  • Leveraging Technology for Tailored Support: Smartphone apps offer a scalable and accessible platform to deliver personalized interventions, overcoming barriers like time and travel associated with traditional methods.
  • Beyond Nicotine: Addressing Sociocontextual Factors: The app's focus on addressing adverse social circumstances (e.g., stress, intimate partner violence) as motivators for smoking, rather than solely focusing on nicotine addiction, represents a more holistic approach.

Key Results

The paper is a protocol for a study, so the results of the acceptability and feasibility trial are not yet available. However, the development of the MCP-W app was completed in September 2023, and participant recruitment for the study commenced in February 2024 and was completed in July 2024. The authors expect to share the results of this acceptability trial in mid-2025.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Sample Size: The study's small sample size (30 participants) means it is underpowered to demonstrate the app's effectiveness in supporting smoking cessation.
  • Generalizability: The recruitment strategy, which includes individuals seeking treatment for smoking, might limit the generalizability of the app's acceptability to women with lower motivation to quit.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest that findings from this study will inform the development of additional gender-specific digital tools, such as conversational agents (chatbots), and may explore gamification components to enhance app acceptability and engagement.

Summary updated

Abstract

BACKGROUND: Tobacco smoking remains the leading preventable cause of death and disease among women. Quitting smoking offers numerous health benefits; however, women tend to have less success than men when attempting to quit. This discrepancy is partly due to sex- and gender-related factors, including the lower effectiveness of smoking cessation medication and the presence of unique motives for smoking and barriers to quitting among women. Despite the gendered nature of smoking, most smoking cessation apps are gender-neutral and fail to address women's specific needs. OBJECTIVE: This study aims to test the acceptability and feasibility of a smartphone app that delivers gender-informed content to support women in quitting smoking. METHODS: We co-developed a smoking cessation app specifically tailored for women, named My Change Plan-Women (MCP-W). This app builds upon our previous gender-neutral app, MCP, by retaining its content grounded in behavioral change techniques aimed at supporting tobacco reduction and cessation. This includes goal setting for quitting, identifying triggers to smoking, creating coping strategies, tracking cigarettes and cravings, and assessing financial savings from quitting smoking. The MCP-W app contains additional gender-informed content that acknowledges barriers to quitting, such as coping with stress, having smokers in one's social circle, and managing unpleasant emotions. This content is delivered through testimonials and animated videos. This study is a prospective, single-group, mixed methods investigation in which 30 women smokers will trial the app for a period of 28 days. Once participants provide informed consent, they will complete a baseline survey and download the app on their smartphones. After 28 days, participants will complete follow-up surveys. Acceptability will be assessed using the Theoretical Framework of Acceptability, which evaluates whether participants perceive the app as helpful in changing their smoking. The app will be deemed acceptable if the majority of participants rate it as such, and feasible if the majority of the participants use it for at least 7 days. Furthermore, after the 28-day trial period, participants will complete a semistructured interview regarding their experience with the app and suggestions for improvement. RESULTS: Development of the MCP-W app was completed in September 2023. Participant recruitment for testing of the app commenced in February 2024 and was completed in July 2024. We will analyze the data upon completion of data collection from all 30 participants. We expect to share the results of this acceptability trial in the middle of 2025. CONCLUSIONS: Offering smoking cessation support tailored specifically to address the unique needs of women through a smartphone app represents a novel approach. This study will test whether women who smoke perceive this approach to be acceptable and feasible in their journey toward smoking cessation. INTERNATIONAL REGISTERED REPORT IDENTIFIER (IRRID): DERR1-10.2196/60677.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{melamed2024gender,
  author = {Osnat C. Melamed and Kamna Mehra and Roshni Panda and Nadia Minian and Scott Veldhuizen and Laurie Zawertailo and Leslie Buckley and Marta M. Maslej and Lorraine Greaves and Andreea C. Brabete and Jonathan Rose and Matt Ratto and Peter Selby},
  title = {{A Gender-Informed Smoking Cessation App for Women: Protocol for an Acceptability and Feasibility Study}},
  booktitle = {JMIR Research Protocols},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.2196/60677},
}
Figure