A Game-Theoretic Approach for Fair Coexistence Between LTE-U and Wi-Fi Systems

Anupam Kumar Bairagi, Nguyen Hoang Tran, Walid Saad, Zhu Han, Choong Seon Hong

Abstract

As mobile data demands surge, cellular operators are increasingly utilizing the unlicensed 5GHz spectrum via LTE-Unlicensed (LTE-U). However, the coexistence of LTE's scheduled protocol with Wi-Fi's contention-based protocol often leads to significant interference. This paper proposes a dual-game theoretic framework to manage this "noisy neighbor" problem. By combining a cooperative Nash Bargaining Game for time-sharing with a one-sided matching game for resource allocation, the framework ensures a fair and efficient distribution of spectrum. Results indicate that the proposed method boosts cellular capacity while protecting Wi-Fi performance more effectively than standard Listen-Before-Talk (LBT) protocols.

Introduction: The Coexistence Challenge

The explosion of mobile data traffic has pushed cellular network operators (CNOs) toward the unlicensed 5GHz spectrum, traditionally dominated by Wi-Fi. This integration, known as LTE-U, faces a fundamental protocol clash: LTE is designed for exclusive, scheduled access, whereas Wi-Fi relies on "polite" contention-based access. Without coordination, aggressive LTE-U deployments can "drown out" Wi-Fi, causing severe performance degradation.

Figure 1: System model illustrating the complex interference environment between multiple Small-cell Base Stations (SBSs), Wi-Fi Access Points (WAPs), and their respective users.

The problem is further complicated in multi-operator scenarios where multiple CNOs compete for the same unlicensed space, creating a three-way interference dynamic between different LTE operators and existing Wi-Fi networks.

Methodology: A Dual-Game Framework

To address this, the authors formulate a Mixed Integer Non-Linear Programming (MINLP) problem to maximize the LTE-U sum-rate while respecting Quality-of-Service (QoS) and Wi-Fi protection constraints. Given the NP-hard nature of MINLP, the problem is decomposed into two iterative sub-problems:

  1. Time-Sharing via Nash Bargaining Game (NBG): A cooperative game determines the fraction of time the unlicensed channel is shared between LTE and Wi-Fi. The NBG ensures a "win-win" by guaranteeing Wi-Fi a minimum throughput (disagreement point) and maximizing mutual utility for the remaining time.
  2. Resource Allocation via One-Sided Matching: Once the time-slice is set, a "House Allocation Model" from matching theory assigns unlicensed subchannels to users. Subchannels act as agents with preferences based on potential data rates, leading to a Pareto-optimal allocation.
Figure 2: Flowchart of the proposed iterative algorithm, decomposing the main optimization problem into Resource Allocation (RA) and Time-Sharing sub-problems.

A centralized arbitrator coordinates these games until the system converges to a stable local optimum.

Key Insights

  • Cooperation over Sensing: Explicit game-theoretic cooperation provides more stable fairness in dense environments than simple carrier sensing (LBT).
  • Wi-Fi as a Partner: By treating Wi-Fi as a bargaining partner with guaranteed performance floors, the system achieves better protection for Wi-Fi users than non-cooperative "polite" protocols.
  • Efficient Decomposition: Splitting the problem into time-sharing and matching makes the complex optimization computationally feasible for real-world network controllers.

Results and Performance

Simulation results in a 150-meter radius environment with varied QoS profiles (HD video, VoIP, etc.) highlight the framework's efficacy:

  • Throughput Gains: The proposed method achieved per-user rates approximately 2.7% to 24.5% higher than baseline LTE-U and LTE-A methods.
  • QoS Satisfaction: In single-channel scenarios, the percentage of "unsatisfied" users (those not meeting QoS) dropped significantly from 60% (LTE-A) to 39%.
  • Fairness and Protection: The approach maintained high Jain’s Fairness Index scores and shielded Wi-Fi users more effectively than conventional LBT schemes, providing higher normalized throughput for WAPs.

Conclusion and Future Directions

While the proposed framework offers significant gains, it currently relies on a centralized arbitrator and requires information exchange between operators, which may pose implementation and privacy challenges. Future research will explore decentralized mechanisms and the integration of machine learning to dynamically predict traffic and interference patterns.

Summary updated

Abstract

LTE over unlicensed band (LTE-U) has emerged as an effective technique to overcome the challenge of spectrum scarcity. Using LTE-U along with advanced techniques such as carrier aggregation, one can boost the performance of existing cellular networks. However, if not properly managed, the use of LTE-U can potentially degrade the performance of co-existing Wi-Fi access points, which operate over the unlicensed frequency bands. Moreover, most of the existing works consider single operator in their proposals. In this paper, an effective coexistence mechanism between LTE-U and Wi-Fi systems is studied. The goal is to enable the cellular network to use LTE-U with CA to meet the quality-of-service (QoS) needs of its users while protecting Wi-Fi access points (WAPs) for a network with multiple operators. In particular, the problem of LTE-U sum-rate maximization is addressed under user QoS and WAP-LTE-U coexistence constraints. To solve this problem, a cooperative Nash bargaining game (NBG) and a one-sided matching game are proposed. Here, the NBG solves the coexistence issue between LTE-U and Wi-Fi system, while the matching game solves the resources allocation problem in the LTE-U system. These two games repeat until convergence. Simulation results show the quality of the proposed approach over other comparing methods in terms of the per-user achieved rate, percentage of unsatisfied users, and fairness. The result also shows that the proposed approach can better protect the performance of Wi-Fi users, compared to the conventional listen-before-talk scheme.
BibTeX
@article{bairagi2019game,
  author = {Anupam Kumar Bairagi and Nguyen Hoang Tran and Walid Saad and Zhu Han and Choong Seon Hong},
  title = {{A Game-Theoretic Approach for Fair Coexistence Between LTE-U and Wi-Fi Systems}},
  journal = {IEEE Trans. Vehicular Technology},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1109/tvt.2018.2880789},
}
Figure