A Framework for Multisensory Foresight for Embodied Agents

Xiaohui Chen, Ramtin Hosseini, Karen Panetta, Jivko Sinapov

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel deep learning framework that predicts future sensory states for embodied agents by integrating multiple modalities (vision, haptic, audio, tactile) beyond just vision. By training the model to predict future frames across all these senses, they achieve more accurate visual predictions and enable richer understanding of object interactions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Robots and other embodied agents need to predict future sensory states to effectively interact with their environment. This is crucial for tasks like planning actions, detecting anomalies, and learning sensorimotor skills. While previous work has focused heavily on predicting future visual frames, this approach often relies on single-modality data or large, manually annotated datasets. The authors argue that many real-world tasks require a richer understanding that can only be achieved by integrating multiple sensory inputs, especially non-visual ones like haptics and audio, which can provide crucial information when vision alone is ambiguous.

Methods

The core of the proposed framework is a modular deep neural network architecture designed for multisensory foresight. It consists of three main components:

  • Feature Encoders: Separate neural networks (including ConvLSTMs) process each sensory modality (vision, haptic, audio, vibrotactile) to extract high-level spatio-temporal features. For audio and vibrotactile data, Fast Fourier Transforms are used to create spectrograms before feature extraction.
  • Fusion Module: This module takes the extracted features from all modalities and merges them into a single, unified latent representation. It uses convolutional layers and ConvLSTMs with concatenation to combine information, adapting to the number of input modalities.
  • Multi-modal Prediction Heads: This component uses the fused representation to predict future frames for each modality. The primary task is predicting future visual frames, but the framework also includes "auxiliary tasks" to predict future haptic, audio, and vibrotactile frames. The authors hypothesize that learning these auxiliary tasks helps the model learn stronger, more generalized representations that benefit the main visual prediction task. For visual prediction, they adapt a pixel transformation approach (CDNA) that captures object motion.

Datasets

The framework is evaluated on a publicly available dataset described in [37]. This dataset was collected using a humanoid robot performing 9 different exploratory behaviors (e.g., push, poke, press, shake, lift, drop, grasp, tap, hold) on 100 objects multiple times. The data includes recordings from four sensory modalities: vision, haptic, audio, and vibrotactile.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Multisensory Fusion is Key: Integrating non-visual sensory modalities (haptic, audio, tactile) significantly improves the accuracy of future visual frame prediction compared to vision-only approaches.
  • Auxiliary Tasks Boost Performance: Training the model to predict future frames for auxiliary modalities (haptic, audio, vibrotactile) not only allows for prediction in those senses but also demonstrably improves the primary visual prediction task.
  • Behavior Matters: Explicitly providing the robot's behavior type as an input feature to the model leads to better prediction performance.
  • Modality Contributions Vary: While haptic, audio, and behavior inputs generally contribute positively, the vibrotactile modality's contribution is less consistent and can sometimes degrade performance. Haptic feedback is particularly important for contact-based behaviors.

Key Results

  • The proposed multisensory framework achieves significantly higher visual prediction quality (measured by SSIM) compared to a state-of-the-art vision-only baseline. For example, integrating all modalities resulted in an average SSIM of 0.798, compared to 0.771 for vision-only.
  • Qualitative results show that predicted frames from the multisensory model are less blurry and capture object motion and localization with greater precision, especially for predictions further into the future.
  • Training behavior-specific models (one model per behavior) generally outperforms a single model trained on all behaviors simultaneously, suggesting that specialized models can capture nuances better.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Robot Specificity: The learned knowledge is currently tied to the specific robot used for data collection. The authors suggest future work should focus on transfer learning methodologies to enable knowledge transfer to different robots with varying morphologies and sensor suites.
  • Reinforcement Learning Integration: The authors propose integrating their multisensory foresight methodology with reinforcement learning for object manipulation tasks.
  • Auxiliary Modality Influence: While auxiliary training generally helps, the paper notes that the influence of audio and vibrotactile auxiliary tasks on visual prediction is not always positive, and the vibrotactile modality has little influence on predicting haptic and audio. Further investigation into these relationships could be beneficial.

Summary updated

Abstract

Predicting future sensory states is crucial for learning agents such as robots, drones, and autonomous vehicles. In this paper, we couple multiple sensory modalities with exploratory actions and propose a predictive neural network architecture to address this problem. Most existing approaches rely on large, manually annotated datasets, or only use visual data as a single modality. In contrast, the unsupervised method presented here uses multi-modal perceptions for predicting future visual frames. As a result, the proposed model is more comprehensive and can better capture the spatio-temporal dynamics of the environment, leading to more accurate visual frame prediction. The other novelty of our framework is the use of sub-networks dedicated to anticipating future haptic, audio, and tactile signals. The framework was tested and validated with a dataset containing 4 sensory modalities (vision, haptic, audio, and tactile) on a humanoid robot performing 9 behaviors multiple times on a large set of objects. While the visual information is the dominant modality, utilizing the additional non-visual modalities improves the accuracy of predictions.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{chen2021framework,
  author = {Xiaohui Chen and Ramtin Hosseini and Karen Panetta and Jivko Sinapov},
  title = {{A Framework for Multisensory Foresight for Embodied Agents}},
  booktitle = {IEEE International Conference on Robotics and Automation},
  year = {2021},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=eWjySQRpEsl},
}
Figure