A federated capability-based access control mechanism for Internet of Things (IoTs)

Yu Chen, Ronghua Xu, Erik Blasch, Genshe Chen

TL;DR

This paper introduces FedCAC, a novel federated capability-based access control framework designed to address the scalability, heterogeneity, and dynamicity challenges of securing Internet of Things (IoT) environments. By distributing access control responsibilities across cloud, fog, and edge layers, FedCAC offers a lightweight, fine-grained, and efficient solution for managing access to IoT resources.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The proliferation of the Internet of Things (IoT) has led to an unprecedented number of interconnected devices, creating vast opportunities for intelligent services. However, this growth also introduces significant security and privacy concerns. Traditional access control models like Access Control Lists (ACLs), Role-Based Access Control (RBAC), and Attribute-Based Access Control (ABAC) struggle to cope with the sheer scale, diverse nature, and constantly changing dynamics of IoT systems. These limitations include:

  • Scalability: The massive number of devices overwhelms traditional centralized management.
  • Heterogeneity: IoT systems integrate devices with varying technologies and specific domain requirements, making uniform policy enforcement difficult.
  • Dynamicity: IoT interactions are often short-lived and spontaneous, requiring flexible and adaptive access control.
  • Lightweight Requirements: Many IoT devices are resource-constrained, unable to support heavy computational or storage demands for complex access control protocols.

This paper aims to bridge this gap by proposing a more suitable access control mechanism for IoTs.

Methods

The core of this paper is the Federated Capability-based Access Control (FedCAC) framework. FedCAC operates on a three-tiered hierarchical architecture:

  • Cloud Computing Layer: Handles global management tasks, including a global profile database and a Policy Decision Making Center (PDC) for identity and policy rule management.
  • Fog Computing Layer: Implemented on near-site nodes (e.g., laptops, smartphones) acting as "coordinators." These coordinators delegate domain-specific authorization policies and identity management tasks from the PDC.
  • Edge Computing Layer: On-site edge devices act as service providers, processing access control authorization requests.

Key mechanisms within FedCAC include:

  • Identity-Based Capability Management: Entities (subjects and objects) are assigned a globally unique Virtual Identity (VID), generated by hashing profile information and signed by the owner.
  • Capability Token Structure: Tokens are represented in JSON format for lightweight communication. They contain fields like issuer, subject, resource, access rights, and conditions.
  • Federated Delegation: The PDC delegates policy decision-making and authorization tasks to domain coordinators, distributing the workload and enhancing scalability.
  • Capability Propagation: When a subject requests access, it obtains a capability token from the coordinator or PDC, which is then presented to the service provider.
  • Authorization Validation: Service providers locally validate the capability token, checking its validity, signature, access rights, and conditions before granting access. This allows for fine-grained, context-aware decisions at the edge.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Decentralization is Key: The paper strongly advocates for distributing access control responsibilities from a centralized PDC to fog-level coordinators and edge-level service providers. This is crucial for handling the scale and dynamism of IoT.
  • Capability Tokens as Lightweight Credentials: Using JSON-formatted capability tokens offers a significant advantage for resource-constrained IoT devices compared to heavier formats like XML.
  • Delegation as a Scalability Enabler: The federated delegation mechanism is central to FedCAC's ability to manage a large number of devices and domains without overwhelming a single point of control.
  • Local Validation for Granularity and Responsiveness: Empowering edge devices to perform local access right validation enables fine-grained control based on real-time environmental conditions, improving responsiveness and security.
  • Trust through Identity and Signatures: The use of VIDs and digital signatures on capability tokens ensures identity verification and prevents token forgery.

Key Results

The paper presents experimental results demonstrating the feasibility and effectiveness of the FedCAC framework.

  • Network Latency: FedCAC introduces an average of 11 ms of extra latency compared to a benchmark without capability-based access control, which is considered acceptable (a ~4% increase over a 300 ms baseline for inter-domain communication).
  • Execution Time: The average execution time for the FedCAC operation of retrieving data was 42.57 ms. The authorization process itself (token verification, access right verification, and signature verification) took approximately 7.823 ms.
  • Signature Verification Dominance: Issuer signature verification was the most computationally intensive step, accounting for about 75% of the total authorization process time, highlighting the importance of optimizing this step.
  • Successful Authorization: Experimental results showed both successful and failed authorization scenarios, with the system correctly denying access when validation steps failed.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several areas for future research:

  • Intelligence on Edge Networks: While delegation brings some intelligence to the edge, the core policy decision-making and identity management remain centralized. Future work aims to further diffuse intelligence to edge devices, enabling them to control their own resources more autonomously.
  • Decentralized Authentication and Authorization: Investigating decentralized schemes, potentially leveraging blockchain technology, is proposed to address challenges in trustless networks and overcome the limitations of centralized authentication and authorization.
  • Data Heterogeneity: Integrating IoT data with other sources like text, multimedia, and social/cultural models is identified as a future research direction.

Summary updated

Abstract

The prevalence of Internet of Things (IoTs) allows heterogeneous embedded smart devices to collaboratively provide intelligent services with or without human intervention. While leveraging the large-scale IoT-based applications like Smart Gird and Smart Cities, IoT also incurs more concerns on privacy and security. Among the top security challenges that IoTs face is that access authorization is critical in resource and information protection over IoTs. Traditional access control approaches, like Access Control Lists (ACL), Role-based Access Control (RBAC) and Attribute-based Access Control (ABAC), are not able to provide a scalable, manageable and efficient mechanisms to meet requirement of IoT systems. The extraordinary large number of nodes, heterogeneity as well as dynamicity, necessitate more fine-grained, lightweight mechanisms for IoT devices. In this paper, a federated capability-based access control (FedCAC) framework is proposed to enable an effective access control processes to devices, services and information in large scale IoT systems. The federated capability delegation mechanism, based on a propagation tree, is illustrated for access permission propagation. An identity-based capability token management strategy is presented, which involves registering, propagation and revocation of the access authorization. Through delegating centralized authorization decision-making policy to local domain delegator, the access authorization process is locally conducted on the service provider that integrates situational awareness (SAW) and customized contextual conditions. Implemented and tested on both resources-constrained devices, like smart sensors and Raspberry PI, and non-resource-constrained devices, like laptops and smart phones, our experimental results demonstrate the feasibility of the proposed FedCAC approach to offer a scalable, lightweight and fine-grained access control solution to IoT systems connected to a system network.
BibTeX
@misc{chen2018federated,
  author = {Yu Chen and Ronghua Xu and Erik Blasch and Genshe Chen},
  title = {{A federated capability-based access control mechanism for Internet of Things (IoTs)}},
  year = {2018},
  eprint = {1805.00825},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1805.00825},
}

Loading related content...

Figure