A Delay-Flexible Stereo Acoustic Echo Cancellation for DFT-Based In-Car Communication (ICC) Systems

Jan Franzen, Tim Fingscheidt

Introduction

In-car communication (ICC) systems are designed to improve speech intelligibility within the vehicle cabin by amplifying the driver's voice for passengers in the rear. However, these systems inherently create a closed-loop acoustic feedback path. Without effective Acoustic Echo Cancellation (AEC), the amplified signal is picked up by the microphone, leading to distracting echoes or even instability.

A critical constraint for ICC systems is latency; to ensure a natural "mouth-to-ear" experience, the total algorithmic delay must typically remain below 12ms. While Frequency Domain Adaptive Filtering (FDAF) is the standard for AEC due to its computational efficiency, its block-based nature often introduces delays that exceed this threshold. Reducing the block size to lower delay usually results in a prohibitive increase in computational complexity. This paper proposes a "delay-flexible" Stereo AEC (SAEC) algorithm that decouples delay from filter adaptation to resolve this trade-off.

Proposed Methodology

The core innovation lies in a modified state-space frequency-domain SAEC architecture. Unlike traditional FDAF, which links the frame shift, window length, and update rate, the proposed system introduces three independent parameters:

  1. Frame Shift ($R$): Controls the actual algorithmic delay.
  2. Microphone Input Frame Length ($L$): Acts as a "look-back" buffer, allowing the system to analyze a longer window of audio than the current frame shift.
  3. Update Rate ($U$): Determines the frequency of filter coefficient recalculation.
Block diagram of the proposed SAEC system architecture showing the decoupling of parameters.

By decoupling these parameters, the system can output audio with a very low frame shift (small $R$) while performing the computationally intensive filter updates less frequently (larger $U$). To maintain performance despite infrequent updates, the "look-back" buffer ($L > R$) ensures the adaptive algorithm retains sufficient context to model the car's acoustic environment accurately.

Experimental Setup

The system was evaluated using simulated impulse responses typical of a car cabin (reverberation time $T_{60} = 50$ms). Test signals followed ITU-T Recommendation P.501, simulating challenging scenarios including single-talk, interruptions, and double-talk. The audio source consisted of 10 seconds of FM radio speech followed by 35 seconds of active double-talk.

Key Results and Discussion

The researchers compared the delay-flexible approach against a high-delay baseline ($L=R=U=256$). The results demonstrate that the proposed method can significantly reduce latency with minimal impact on echo suppression performance.

Performance comparison of different parameter configurations for delay, echo suppression (ERLE), and complexity.

As shown in the table above, the baseline system with a 32ms delay achieved an average Echo Return Loss Enhancement (ERLE) of 14.95 dB. By adjusting the parameters to $L=256, R=32, U=32$, the algorithmic delay was reduced to just 4ms. This configuration achieved an ERLE of 15.85 dB—actually outperforming the baseline in suppression while providing a massive improvement in latency. Furthermore, the system distance ($d_{sys}$), which measures how accurately the algorithm models room acoustics, remained stable across configurations.

Computationally, the proposed method is approximately 45% less expensive than a naive low-delay implementation ($L=R=U=32$), proving that decoupling the update rate is a viable strategy for resource-constrained automotive Digital Signal Processors (DSPs).

Conclusion

This paper presents a flexible SAEC framework that successfully breaks the traditional link between algorithmic delay and computational complexity in frequency-domain AEC. By utilizing a look-back buffer and independent update rates, the system achieves the sub-12ms latency required for high-quality ICC systems without sacrificing echo suppression performance. Future work will focus on extending this model to bidirectional ICC systems and testing on real-world automotive hardware.

Summary updated

Abstract

In-car communication (ICC) systems supporting speech communication in noise by reproducing amplified speech from the car cabin in the car cabin ask for low-delay acoustic echo cancellation (AEC). In this paper we propose a delay-flexible DFT-based stereo AEC capable of cancelling also the echoes stemming from the audio player or FM radio. For the price of a somewhat higher complexity we are able to reduce the 32 ms delay of the baseline down to 4 ms, loosing only 1 dB in ERLE while even preserving system distance properties.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{franzen2017delay,
  author = {Jan Franzen and Tim Fingscheidt},
  title = {{A Delay-Flexible Stereo Acoustic Echo Cancellation for DFT-Based In-Car Communication (ICC) Systems}},
  booktitle = {Interspeech},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.21437/interspeech.2017-1084},
}
Figure