A Data-driven Understanding of Left-Wing Extremists on Social Media

Utkucan Balci, Michael Sirivianos, Jeremy Blackburn

Abstract

Social media's role in the spread and evolution of extremism is a focus of intense study. Online extremists have been involved in the spread of online hate, mis/disinformation, and real-world violence. However, the overwhelming majority of existing work has focused on right-wing extremism. In this paper, we perform a first-of-its-kind large-scale, data-driven study exploring left-wing extremism. We focus on "tankies," a left-wing community that first arose in the 1950s in support of hardline actions of the USSR and has evolved to support what they call "actually existing socialist countries," e.g., CCP-run China, the USSR, former Soviet countries, and North Korea. We collect 1.3M posts from 53K authors from tankie subreddits and explore the position of tankies within the broader far-left community on Reddit. Among other things, we find that tankies are clearly on the periphery of the larger far-left community. When examining the contents of posts, we find misalignments and conceptual homomorphisms that confirm the description of tankies in theoretical work. We also discover that tankies focus more on state-level political events rather than social issues in comparison to other far-left communities. Finally, we show that tankies exhibit some of the same worrying behaviors as right-wing extremists, e.g., relatively high toxicity and an organized response to deplatforming events.

Introduction

While computational social science has extensively documented the rise and mechanics of right-wing extremism, the far-left remains largely a "black box." Political rhetoric often conflates mainstream liberalism with far-left extremism, but empirical data on actual extremist behavior on the left is scarce. This study addresses this gap by focusing on "tankies"—a subculture that supports "Actually Existing Socialist" (AES) regimes and often adopts pro-authoritarian, anti-Western stances. The research aims to determine if these groups are a marginal niche or a substantial, growing presence, and how their discourse differs from traditional social-justice-oriented leftist communities.

Methodology

The researchers employed a multi-stage computational pipeline to analyze the tankie ecosystem on Reddit. The process began with community identification using manual snowball sampling from known hubs like r/InformedTankie. To determine ideological positioning, the team constructed a reference network where nodes represent subreddits and edges represent user co-membership, normalized via Bonacich’s method.

For discourse analysis, the study utilized BERTopic for large-scale topic modeling and Word2Vec with MultiCCA to identify "misalignments"—instances where the same word carries different meanings across communities. Finally, toxicity was measured using Google’s Perspective API, and domain analysis was conducted to identify reliance on state-sponsored media outlets.

The primary dataset consists of 1.3 million posts from 53,000 authors across six core tankie subreddits, spanning July 2019 to March 2022. For comparison, 21.1 million posts were collected from 43 other ideological subreddits, including feminists, capitalists, and other far-left groups like r/Anarchism and r/socialism.

Monthly active users across various leftist subreddits, showing the rapid growth of r/GenZedong compared to more stable or declining mainstream leftist communities.

A key finding is the "siphon effect": tankie communities are not just growing through new users but are actively siphoning members from established leftist groups. As shown in the user analysis, r/GenZedong saw its monthly active users double between late 2021 and early 2022, eventually surpassing r/communism in activity. Notably, while activity in most far-left subreddits dipped following the 2022 invasion of Ukraine, tankie communities continued to grow, likely due to their alignment with pro-Russian narratives.

Key Insights: Ideology and Discourse

The study reveals several distinct characteristics that separate tankies from the broader far-left. While mainstream leftist groups focus on labor, healthcare, and housing, tankies prioritize state-level geopolitics and the defense of authoritarian regimes.

A summary of the key differences between Tankies and other far-left communities across scale, thematic focus, and linguistic characteristics.

Linguistically, tankies exhibit high "intraconnectivity" but remain on the extreme periphery of the broader leftist ecosystem, suggesting an echo-chamber effect. This isolation is reflected in their media consumption; tankies share links from "Revisionist World Powers" (Russia and China) 60% of the time, compared to just 6.3% for groups like r/DemocraticSocialism. Furthermore, the study found significant linguistic shifts: for instance, while the broader left discusses "internment camps" in Xinjiang, tankies adopt state-sponsored terminology like "boarding schools."

Toxicity and Behavior

Tankies exhibit significantly higher toxicity than average leftist subreddits, particularly in categories like "Identity Attack" and "Threat." This toxicity often targets religious and ethnic groups in the context of geopolitical conflicts. This behavioral pattern mirrors some of the more aggressive tactics observed in right-wing extremist groups, including organized responses to deplatforming events.

Conclusion and Limitations

This research provides the first large-scale quantitative evidence that tankies represent a distinct, growing, and ideologically isolated segment of the online far-left. However, the study is limited to Reddit and relies on the Perspective API, which has known biases. Future work should expand to platforms like Telegram and TikTok to better understand the post-quarantine evolution of these communities and perform direct comparisons with right-wing extremist behaviors.

Summary updated

Abstract

Social media's role in the spread and evolution of extremism is a focus of intense study. Online extremists have been involved in the spread of online hate, mis/disinformation, and real-world violence. However, the overwhelming majority of existing work has focused on right-wing extremism. In this paper, we perform a first of its kind large-scale, data-driven study exploring left-wing extremism. We focus on "tankies," a left-wing community that first arose in the 1950s in support of hardline actions of the USSR and has evolved to support what they call "actually existing socialist countries," e.g., CCP run China, the USSR, former soviet countries, and North Korea. We collect 1.3M posts from 53K authors from tankies subreddits, and explore the position of tankies within the broader far-left community on Reddit. Among other things, we find that tankies are clearly on the periphery of the larger far-left community. When examining the contents of posts, we find misalignments and conceptual homomorphisms that confirm the description of tankies in the theoretical work. We also discover that tankies focus more on state-level political events rather than social issues in comparison to other far-left communities. Finally, we show that tankies exhibit some of the same worrying behaviors as right-wing extremists, e.g., relatively high toxicity and an organized response to deplatforming events.
BibTeX
@misc{balci2023data,
  author = {Utkucan Balci and Michael Sirivianos and Jeremy Blackburn},
  title = {{A Data-driven Understanding of Left-Wing Extremists on Social Media}},
  year = {2023},
  eprint = {2307.06981},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2307.06981},
}
Figure