A Corpus-Based Critical Discourse Analysis of ‘Chinese Model’ on Africa Mainstream Newspapers

Xin Liu, Wenyu LiuAdvances 2019 · DOI

Abstract

As China’s economic influence and international standing have grown, the "Chinese model"—representing China’s successful development experience—has become a focal point of global discourse. Given the deepening ties between China and Africa, understanding African perceptions of this model is crucial. This study systematically examines African attitudes by analyzing news reports from mainstream African newspapers between 2000 and 2017. Using corpus-assisted Critical Discourse Analysis (CDA), the research investigates word co-occurrence networks, keywords, and concordance lines. The findings suggest that African media primarily focuses on economic development, investment, and poverty alleviation, maintaining a largely affirmative stance toward the Chinese model while expressing minor concerns regarding its local replicability.

Introduction

The "Chinese Model," often contrasted with the "Washington Consensus," has sparked significant academic debate. However, much of the existing literature focuses on Western media portrayals. This research addresses the gap by centering African voices, utilizing a systematic, data-driven approach to avoid the "cherry-picking" often associated with traditional qualitative discourse analysis. By examining nearly two decades of reporting, the study provides an objective look at how the "Beijing Consensus" is perceived on the continent.

Methodology

The researchers employed Corpus-assisted Critical Discourse Analysis, a hybrid method combining qualitative linguistic depth with quantitative rigor. The dataset comprised 44 articles (43,805 words) sourced from AllAfrica.com, covering the period from 2000 to 2017.

Key analytical tools included:

  • KH Coder: Used for Co-occurrence Network Analysis to visualize thematic clusters.
  • AntConc: Used for Keyword Analysis to identify statistically significant terms relative to a standard reference corpus.
  • Concordance Analysis: Used to examine the semantic prosody (the emotional "aura") surrounding the term "model."

Key Findings

Thematic Clusters and Co-occurrence

The analysis identified six primary thematic clusters within the discourse. The largest, Cluster 1, centers on the relationship between China and African economic development. Other clusters highlight specific areas of cooperation, such as foreign aid, investment, and infrastructure projects like the TAZARA railway.

Co-occurrence network of words surrounding the 'Chinese model' discourse.

Keyword Significance

The statistical "keyness" of specific terms confirms that the African discourse is overwhelmingly pragmatic. The top keywords—China, Africa, economic, development, and model—underscore a narrative focused on growth and partnership rather than political ideology. This quantitative data supports the qualitative observation that the model is viewed as a toolkit for modernization.

Top 20 keywords ranked by frequency and statistical keyness.

Sentiment and Semantic Prosody

The study found a strong positive bias toward the Chinese model, with a 5:1 ratio of positive to negative concordance lines (101 positive vs. 21 negative). Positive reports often describe the model as "unique," "inspirational," or a "perfect example." Conversely, negative sentiment is largely confined to the "transplant dilemma"—the concern that a model successful in China may not be directly applicable to diverse African socio-economic realities. Interestingly, many of these doubts mirrored internal debates among Chinese scholars themselves.

Conclusion

African mainstream media views the "Chinese Model" not as an ideological export, but as a practical toolkit for economic transformation. While the overall sentiment is highly affirmative, the presence of minor anxieties regarding labor relations and model "transplantability" suggests that future engagement should focus on clearer communication and addressing the conduct of private enterprises. This data-driven analysis highlights a relationship built on economic pragmatism and a shared aspiration for development.

Summary updated

Abstract

In recent years, China’s economy and international influence grows increasingly, “Chinese model”, China’s successful development experience, has been extensively discussed around the world. As friendship and communications between China and Africa becomes more osculation, Africa’s attitudes towards “Chinese model” matters much and cannot be ignored. In order to objectively and systematically examine African cognition and attitudes towards “Chinese model”, this research collects most of the news reports on “Chinese model” in African mainstream newspapers from 2000 to 2017. Assisted by corpus software, this paper conducts an analysis on Co-occurrence Network of Words around Chinese model, keywords of the texts, and concordance lines of Chinese model. Furthermore, semantic prosody will be explored in concordances. The findings suggest that: (1) On the discussion of Chinese model, the focus of African media is primarily on their economic development, China’s investment, trade and cooperation, and expectation to draw upon Chinese development experience to relieve them from poverty. (2) Most of the reports on Chinese model are strongly associated with economy, and only a few reports involves with politics. (3) On the point of replicating Chinese model in facilitating African development, the majority of Africans are affirmative of this approach. There are only a few reports in which people show their uncertainty and worries about the prospect of applying Chinese model in Africa.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{liu2019corpus,
  author = {Xin Liu and Wenyu Liu},
  title = {{A Corpus-Based Critical Discourse Analysis of ‘Chinese Model’ on Africa Mainstream Newspapers}},
  booktitle = {Advances},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.14738/assrj.61.6105},
}
Figure