A convergent Reinforcement Learning algorithm in the continuous case based on a Finite Difference method

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel reinforcement learning (RL) algorithm, Finite Difference Reinforcement Learning (FDRL), that guarantees convergence for optimal control problems in continuous state and time spaces. By leveraging a finite difference approximation of the Hamilton-Jacobi-Bellman equation, FDRL overcomes the notorious divergence issues encountered by classical RL methods when dealing with continuous environments.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Reinforcement learning aims to find optimal control strategies for dynamic systems by learning from interactions. A cornerstone of RL is approximating the "value function," which quantifies the expected future reward from a given state. However, when dealing with systems where both the state and time are continuous (e.g., robotics, autonomous driving), approximating this value function becomes incredibly challenging. Traditional methods often discretize the state space, but this can break the crucial Markov property, leading to algorithms like Q-learning failing to converge, even for deterministic systems. Furthermore, using general function approximators like neural networks with RL can also result in unstable or divergent behavior. This paper tackles the fundamental problem of achieving guaranteed convergence for RL in continuous state-action spaces.

Methods

The authors propose a two-pronged approach:

  1. Finite Difference Approximation of the HJB Equation: They start by discretizing the continuous Hamilton-Jacobi-Bellman (HJB) equation using a finite difference (FD) method. This transforms the continuous problem into a discrete dynamic programming (DP) equation for a finite Markov Decision Process (MDP). The solution to this discrete DP equation, denoted $V^\delta$, serves as a convergent approximation to the true value function of the continuous problem as the discretization step $\delta$ approaches zero.
  2. Finite Difference Reinforcement Learning (FDRL) Algorithm: Building on the FD scheme, they develop a model-free RL algorithm. Instead of directly learning the value function from sampled trajectories, FDRL iteratively updates an approximation of the value function ($Q(X, u)$ for discrete states $X$ and controls $u$) by simulating transitions based on the discretized HJB equation. Crucially, the update rule (Equation 5) averages the values of successive states according to the discretized dynamics, not just their occurrence in sampled trajectories. This approach is designed to mimic the convergent FD scheme and is proven to converge to the true value function under specific exploration conditions.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical convergence guarantees and proposes an algorithm that learns from simulated or real-world system dynamics, rather than relying on pre-defined datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Discretization Breaks Markov Property: A key insight is that simply discretizing a continuous state space, even for deterministic systems, can violate the Markov property. This means the future state depends not only on the current state but also on how the system arrived at that state, which is problematic for standard RL algorithms.
  • FD Scheme as a Bridge: The finite difference approximation of the HJB equation provides a principled way to create a discrete MDP that does converge to the continuous problem's solution. This FD scheme acts as a theoretical stepping stone for the RL algorithm.
  • FDRL Mimics FD, Not Q-Learning: The FDRL algorithm's update rule is designed to approximate the FD scheme's DP equation. This is a departure from Q-learning, which averages values based on observed transitions. FDRL's averaging is driven by the dynamics of the discretized system, which is why it can converge where Q-learning fails in this context.
  • Guaranteed Convergence: The paper provides a theoretical proof of convergence for FDRL, a significant achievement for RL in continuous spaces, which is often plagued by divergence issues.

Key Results

The paper presents theoretical results, not empirical ones on specific datasets. The main findings are:

  • Theorem 3: Guarantees that the finite difference approximation $V^\delta$ converges to the true value function $V$ as the discretization step $\delta$ goes to zero.
  • Theorem 4: Proves that the proposed FDRL algorithm converges to the value function of the continuous problem, provided that all possible state-control transitions are explored sufficiently.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Computational Complexity: The paper acknowledges the "combinatorial explosion" of states and values to be estimated in practical applications, a common challenge in high-dimensional continuous control.
  • Exploration Strategy: Theorem 4 relies on an "exploring-every-possible-transition" hypothesis, which might be difficult to guarantee in practice.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest exploring adaptive multi-resolution techniques (like multigrid methods) to handle the curse of dimensionality. They also propose extending the FDRL algorithm to the stochastic case, potentially by developing a Q-learning version.

Summary updated

Abstract

In this paper, we propose a convergent Reinforcement Learning algorithm for solving optimal control problems for which the state space and the time are continuous variables. The problem of computing a good approximation of the value function, which is essential because this provides the optimal control, is a difficult task in the continuous case. Indeed, as it has been pointed out by several authors, the use of parameterized functions such as neural networks for approximating the value function may produce very bad results and even diverge. In fact, we show that classical algorithms, like Q-learning, used with a simple look-up table built on a regular grid, may fail to converge. The main reason is that the discretization of the state space implies a lost of the Markov property even for deterministic continuous processes. We propose to approximate the value function with a convergent numerical scheme based on a Finite Difference approximation of the Hamilton-Jacobi-Bellman equation. Then we present a model-free reinforcement learning algorithrn, called Finite Difference Reinforcement Learning, and prove its convergence to the value function of the continuous problem.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{1997convergent,
  title = {{A convergent Reinforcement Learning algorithm in the continuous case based on a Finite Difference method}},
  booktitle = {International Joint Conference on Artificial Intelligence},
  year = {1997},
}
Figure