A Comprehensive Evaluation Method for the Service Status of Groins in Waterways Based on an AHP-Improved CRITIC Combination Weighting Optimization Model

Fan Zhang, Pingyi Wang, Ping Mu, Meili Wang, Linfeng Han, Jianle SunSustainability 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel method for evaluating the service status of groins in waterways by combining subjective (AHP) and objective (CRITIC) weighting techniques. This approach aims to provide a more accurate and comprehensive assessment than traditional methods, offering a scientific basis for waterway maintenance and infrastructure management.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Waterway infrastructure, particularly groins (structures used to regulate water flow and scour), are crucial for navigation. However, these structures are susceptible to damage from complex water and sediment environments, leading to a degradation of their service status over time. Existing evaluation methods are often qualitative, relying on manual inspection, which can be subjective and yield rough results. There's a need for a more scientific, quantitative, and comprehensive approach to assess groin service status to inform effective maintenance decisions and ensure the sustainability of waterway infrastructure.

Methods

The core of this paper is the development of an "AHP-Improved CRITIC Combination Weighting Optimization Model."

  • Evaluation Index System: A hierarchical system (target, criterion, element) was created to assess the Waterway Groin Service Status (WGSS). This system includes four main criteria (Function Assurance Degree, Appearance Deformation Degree, Component Integrity Degree, Structural Stability Degree) broken down into 16 elemental indicators.
  • Subjective Weighting (AHP): The Analytical Hierarchy Process (AHP) was used to derive subjective weights based on expert opinions. This involves constructing judgment matrices and checking for consistency.
  • Objective Weighting (Improved CRITIC): The Criteria Importance Though Intercriteria Correlation (CRITIC) method, specifically an improved version, was employed to calculate objective weights. This method uses the inherent information within the data (variation and correlation between indicators) to assign weights, reducing the influence of subjective bias. The improvement involves using the coefficient of variation instead of standard deviation.
  • Combined Weighting Optimization: A least squares optimization model, solved using the Lagrange multiplier method, was developed to combine the subjective and objective weights. This aims to leverage the strengths of both approaches and mitigate their individual limitations.
  • Comprehensive Score Calculation: A linear weighting method is used to calculate a final composite score (Z) for the groin's service status based on the combined weights and indicator scores.

Datasets

The study utilized data from 13 representative groins in the upper Yangtze River channel collected in 2021 as an objective sample set. Additionally, the "Tiemenkan groin" was used as a specific validation sample. The data included actual measurement data for the 16 defined indicators.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Bridging Subjectivity and Objectivity: The most significant insight is the successful integration of subjective expert knowledge (AHP) with objective data-driven analysis (CRITIC). This combination is shown to be more robust than either method alone.
  • Comprehensive Index System: The development of a detailed, hierarchical index system (WGSS) provides a structured framework for evaluating groins, covering aspects from functional performance to structural integrity.
  • Quantitative Assessment: The model moves beyond qualitative assessments, providing a quantifiable score for groin service status, which is crucial for standardized management and decision-making.
  • Improved Accuracy: The combined weighting approach demonstrably leads to more accurate evaluations compared to traditional single-weighting methods, as validated by case studies.

Key Results

  • The developed AHP-Improved CRITIC model was applied to the Tiemenkan groin, resulting in a comprehensive service status score of 59, indicating a low service status and the need for repair.
  • This score was consistent with the actual situation and prior evaluations by local waterway management departments, validating the model's reliability and applicability.
  • Comparisons showed that the combined weights were more reasonable and credible than those derived from AHP or CRITIC alone.
  • The new model demonstrated higher accuracy than traditional AHP-based methods when compared against actual ratings, with fewer discrepancies.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Subjectivity in Index Formulation: Despite incorporating objective weights, the paper acknowledges that some subjectivity remains in the formulation of the index system, data collection, and scoring.
  • Data Collection Effort: The proposed system includes 16 indicators, which can make data collection time-consuming and expensive in practice.
  • Generalizability: The authors note that the characteristics of groins can vary significantly across different river basins and sections. Therefore, the index set and weight coefficients may need to be adjusted for application in different contexts.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest continued optimization of the evaluation method, potentially simplifying the data collection process and further refining the model for broader applicability. They also emphasize the need to adjust the index set and recalculate weights for different river environments.

Summary updated

Abstract

A comprehensive evaluation model that combines an analytical hierarchy process (AHP) method and the improved version of the Criteria Importance Through Inter-criteria Correlation (CRITIC) method is proposed to solve integrated assessment problems related to the service status of groins in waterways. In view of the influencing factors and functional characteristics of damaged groins for waterway regulation, a waterway groin service status (WGSS) evaluation index system with a hierarchical structure was constructed using target-criteria elements. Additionally, based on the multi-attribute characteristics of the indicators, standards for rating and assigning values to elemental indicators were developed. Considering that traditional empowerment methods are rather one-sided and limited, an AHP-improved CRITIC method combination assigning optimization model was established based on the least squares principle, and the optimal combination weights were solved by the Lagrange multiplier method. The reliability and applicability of the model were tested by successfully applying the evaluation model to the comprehensive evaluation of the service status of spur dikes in the upper reaches of the Yangtze River. The results showed that the combined weights that were calculated by the AHP and the improved CRITIC optimization model were able to reflect both subjective and objective information, which makes up for the shortcomings of a single assignment method, and the weights assigned to the service status evaluation indexes for groins were reasonable. The comprehensive evaluation method to determine the service status of groins proposed in this paper was more accurate than the traditional evaluation method with subjective assignment and provided a scientific basis for decision making to maintain the sustainability of groin function.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2022comprehensive,
  author = {Fan Zhang and Pingyi Wang and Ping Mu and Meili Wang and Linfeng Han and Jianle Sun},
  title = {{A Comprehensive Evaluation Method for the Service Status of Groins in Waterways Based on an AHP-Improved CRITIC Combination Weighting Optimization Model}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/su141710709},
}
Figure