A Comparison of the Characteristics of Informal Economy between Developing and Developed Countries and the Experience and Reference of China: A Case Study of Malaysia and Singapore

Xiaofan Lou, Hongyu An, Fengyu GuoJournal of Economics Finance and Accounting Studies 2024 · DOI

Abstract

As China continues to urbanise, the size of the informal economy in the country is also increasing, creating numerous governance issues. This thesis explores the differences between developing and developed countries by comparing the characteristics of the informal economy in Malaysia and Singapore. A literature study was used to analyze the size and characteristics of the informal economy in the two countries. It is found that despite the commonalities, there are significant differences between the two countries' informal economies in terms of development stages and policy implications. This study provides valuable experience and lessons for the governance of the informal economy in China, emphasising the impact of government policies and socio-cultural factors on the informal economy, and it also provides important insights into the effective governance of the informal economy in developing countries.

Introduction: The Governance Gap in Rapid Urbanization

As China undergoes rapid urbanization, its informal economy—comprising economic activities not captured by official statistics, such as street vending or unregulated gig work—has expanded significantly. This growth has created a "governance gap," where workers lack legal protections and social benefits, while the state faces challenges in tax revenue collection and regulatory oversight. The informal economy is not a monolith; it ranges from survival-based street hawking to sophisticated, tech-enabled tax avoidance. This paper seeks to understand how different stages of national development dictate the characteristics of the informal sector by comparing Malaysia (developing) and Singapore (developed), offering policy levers for China’s unique socio-economic landscape.

Methodology and Global Context

The research employs documentary analysis, systematically reviewing literature, government reports, and international databases from the ILO, IMF, and World Bank. The study benchmarks Malaysia and Singapore against China’s trajectory, focusing on employment scale, sectoral characteristics, and government intervention strategies. Globally, the informal economy remains a massive force, employing roughly 2 billion workers—60% of the global population over age 15.

The informal sector represents up to a third of economic activity in low- and middle-income countries.

Comparative Analysis: Malaysia vs. Singapore

The study identifies a key distinction between "gray" and "survival" informal activities. In developing nations like Malaysia, the informal economy often serves as a survival mechanism for low-skilled workers or illegal immigrants. Conversely, in developed nations like Singapore, it manifests more as "gray" activity—legal businesses engaging in illicit practices like tax dodging, or highly specialized tech-driven gig work.

In Malaysia, the size of the informal economy is inversely proportional to the formal economy; as the formal sector grows, workers typically transition to regulated jobs. Singapore, despite its developed status, maintains an informal economy encompassing roughly 10% of its employed population, showing a strong correlation with unemployment rates.

The Chinese Context: Scale and Evolution

Estimates suggest China’s informal economy accounts for 10% to 30% of its GDP as of 2017-2019. The evolution of this sector in China has been dramatic since the start of economic reforms. By 2010, informally employed persons in China reached approximately 219 million, representing over 60% of the urban workforce.

Historical growth of China's informal economy and urban employment (1978–2010).

Policy Recommendations and Conclusion

The digital age has introduced an "Internet informal economy," which creates employment but complicates tracking. The authors suggest a "Trinity" enforcement model, similar to Malaysia’s, involving urban management, police, and courts to reduce arbitrary enforcement. Furthermore, China could adapt Singapore’s Central Provident Fund (CPF) model to integrate informal workers into the formal social security system.

While the informal economy is inherently difficult to monitor, future governance must leverage technology—such as data analytics and digital infrastructure—to bridge the gap between "black market" transactions and official financial systems, ensuring worker protection without stifling economic dynamism.

Summary updated

Abstract

As China continues to urbanise, the size of the informal economy in the country is also increasing, creating numerous governance issues. This thesis explores the differences between developing and developed countries by comparing the characteristics of the informal economy in Malaysia and Singapore. A literature study was used to analyze the size and characteristics of the informal economy in the two countries. It is found that despite the commonalities, there are significant differences between the two countries' informal economies in terms of development stages and policy implications. This study provides valuable experience and lessons for the governance of the informal economy in China, emphasising the impact of government policies and socio-cultural factors on the informal economy, and it also provides important insights into the effective governance of the informal economy in developing countries.
BibTeX
@article{lou2024comparison,
  author = {Xiaofan Lou and Hongyu An and Fengyu Guo},
  title = {{A Comparison of the Characteristics of Informal Economy between Developing and Developed Countries and the Experience and Reference of China: A Case Study of Malaysia and Singapore}},
  journal = {Journal of Economics Finance and Accounting Studies},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.32996/jefas.2024.6.4.3},
}
Figure