A Comparison of Su and Lu Modelingof Hydro-Thermal Coupling Model UsingField Temperature Records

Jie Ren, Wenbing Zhang, Bo Chen, Lili Men, Chen Ma, Lei GanPolish 2020 · DOI

Abstract

The transport of materials and energy between rivers and riparian zones is driven by lateral hyporheic exchange and plays a vital role in regulating the ecological health of rivers. Owing to the limitations of models and methods, prior research has mainly focused on vertical hyporheic exchange in river systems. Combined with collected riparian zone temperature and water level data, a 2D hydrothermal coupling model of the riparian zone was developed using the thermal conductivity model, and the fitting effects of the Lu et al. (2007) and Su et al. (2016) models were compared. The calibrated model reasonably illustrated the variations in the riparian zone temperature, and sensitivity analysis revealed that hydraulic conductivity ($K_s$) is the most sensitive factor to temperature variations.

Introduction

The hyporheic zone—the saturated sediment layer where river water and groundwater mix—is a critical interface for ecological health, nutrient transport, and temperature regulation. While vertical exchange (upwelling and downwelling through the riverbed) has been extensively studied, lateral exchange into riparian zones remains less understood due to modeling complexities. Accurate modeling of this "hydro-thermal coupling" is essential, as temperature often serves as a natural tracer for water movement. However, calculating soil thermal conductivity is challenging because it varies significantly with soil texture, moisture, and composition. This study addresses these challenges by developing a 2D model to simulate lateral exchange and comparing two prominent thermal conductivity models against real-world field data.

Methods and Data

The research utilized a field dataset from the Fox irrigation channel in the Walker River Basin, Nevada, USA, spanning from March to November 2012. Instrumentation included water level and temperature sensors deployed at various depths and distances from the river center.

A 2D numerical model was constructed using COMSOL Multiphysics to simulate transient seepage (Richards equation) and heat transport. The study specifically compared two empirical thermal conductivity models:

  1. Lu et al. (2007): A standard model based on soil texture and saturation.
  2. Su et al. (2016): An improved model that incorporates organic matter content.
Figure 1: 2D model domain and boundary conditions for the riparian zone simulation, showing sensor locations T1 and T2.

To identify the most influential physical parameters, the Morris global sensitivity analysis method was applied, ranking factors such as porosity, heat capacity, and hydraulic conductivity.

Results and Discussion

The comparative analysis demonstrated that the Su et al. (2016) model significantly outperformed the Lu et al. (2007) model in predicting riparian temperatures. The Su model achieved an average Root Mean Square Error (RMSE) of 1.95°C, whereas the Lu model's average RMSE was 3.58°C.

Figure 6: Comparison of measured temperature data with simulated results from the Su and Lu models at various depths for sensors T1 and T2.

The Su model's superior performance is attributed to its inclusion of organic matter content, which is prevalent in riparian zones. In contrast, the Lu model showed poor predictive power at deeper monitoring locations, sometimes resulting in negative Nash-Sutcliffe efficiency (NSE) values.

Sensitivity analysis identified hydraulic conductivity ($K_s$) as the "master variable." Small variations in $K_s$ had a much larger impact on the temperature field than other parameters like soil heat capacity or porosity. Furthermore, the model confirmed that the river acted as a recharge source for the groundwater throughout the study period. While diurnal air temperature fluctuations affected the top 1 meter of soil, deeper temperatures were primarily driven by lateral water seepage from the river.

Conclusion

Incorporating organic matter into thermal conductivity models is crucial for accurately simulating the hydro-thermal dynamics of riparian zones. The Su et al. (2016) model provides a more robust framework for these environments compared to traditional models. While the 2D transect approach proved effective for this site, future research should explore 3D modeling for complex river geometries and test these models across diverse climatic zones to refine regional coefficients. This hydro-thermal coupling approach offers a valuable blueprint for researchers looking to quantify nutrient transport and ecological processes in river systems.

Summary updated

Abstract

The transport of materials and energy between rivers and riparian zones are driven by lateral hyporheic exchange and plays a vital role in regulating the ecological health of rivers. Owing to the limitations of models and methods, prior research has mainly focused on vertical hyporheic exchange in river systems. Combined with the collected riparian zone temperature and water level data, a 2D hydrothermal coupling model of the riparian zone was developed using the thermal conductivity model, and the fitting effects of the Lu et al. ( Then, the dynamic variation characteristics of the riparian zone temperature and the lateral hyporheic exchange recharge pattern were investigated by the constructed models. The calibrated model could reasonably illustrate the variations in the riparian zone temperature, and the sensitivity analysis revealed that the hydraulic conductivity (K s ) is the most sensitive factor to the temperature variations.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{ren2020comparison,
  author = {Jie Ren and Wenbing Zhang and Bo Chen and Lili Men and Chen Ma and Lei Gan},
  title = {{A Comparison of Su and Lu Modelingof Hydro-Thermal Coupling Model UsingField Temperature Records}},
  booktitle = {Polish},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.15244/pjoes/122690},
}
Figure