A Comparative Study on the Construction of Oriental Female Music Images in Chinese and Western Opera——Take Madame Butterfly and Canal Ballads as examples

Beibei Li2020 · DOI

Abstract

The national opera Canal Ballad tells a touching love story set against the backdrop of the Beijing-Hangzhou Grand Canal, a monument created by the working people of ancient China. In contrast, Giacomo Puccini's Madame Butterfly depicts the tragic fate of a humiliated Oriental woman who loves a fickle Western man without regret, only to be abandoned and driven to suicide. By analyzing the basic musical materials of these two works, this paper explores the creative ideas behind their construction of female leads. Through a comparative lens, we examine the use of oriental elements, the combination of drama and lyricism, and the unique cultural charms that define these operatic masterpieces.

Introduction

The "Oriental female" has long been a subject of fascination and construction in global opera. However, the lens through which this image is built varies significantly between Western and Eastern traditions. This paper addresses the cross-cultural construction of identity by comparing Puccini’s Madame Butterfly—a work rooted in late 19th-century Western exoticism—with Yin Qing’s Canal Ballad, a contemporary Chinese national opera. The core of this study lies in identifying how specific musical choices, such as scales, rhythms, and vocal styles, translate into distinct cultural archetypes: the submissive "exotic" and the heroic "national spirit."

Methodology

This study employs a comparative musicological approach, focusing on three primary analytical dimensions:

  1. Musical Material Analysis: Examining the integration of pentatonic scales, specific modes (such as the "G feather mode"), and folk melodies (e.g., Japanese tunes like "Cherry Blossom" versus Chinese canal folk songs).
  2. Characterological Comparison: Analyzing librettos and dramatic structures to compare the characterization of Cio-Cio-San (Qiaoqiao sang) in Madame Butterfly and Shui Honglian in Canal Ballad.
  3. Structural Analysis: Contrasting Western operatic forms (aria and recitative) with traditional Chinese vocal techniques, including the "board cavity" (banqiang) style.

The Construction of the "Exotic" in Madame Butterfly

Puccini’s portrayal of the East is a deliberate hybrid. To achieve an "authentic" atmosphere, Puccini integrated real Japanese melodies, such as "Edo Japan Bridge," into a Western harmonic framework. This "Orientalism" served Western expectations of a mysterious and "coldly beautiful" East.

Musically, the character of Cio-Cio-San is defined by a transition from delicate pentatonic melodies to sweeping, tragic Western arias. This shift mirrors her narrative arc from a shy, hopeful girl to a woman abandoned by Western masculinity. In Puccini's work, the Oriental woman is often a subject of fascination that ultimately serves to define Western dominance through her submissiveness and eventual tragedy.

The "National Spirit" and Reclamation in Canal Ballad

In contrast to the submissive archetype, the heroine of Canal Ballad, Shui Honglian, represents the "female man" (nü hanzi) archetype—witty, strong-willed, and heroic. Her musical identity is designed to evoke the internal values and resilience of the Chinese people rather than satisfying an external exotic gaze.

Canal Ballad represents a significant shift in Chinese opera, moving toward a "liberation from the shackles of the past." While it utilizes Bel Canto vocal skills, it does so to serve the shaping of a national identity. The melodies are described as "simple, smooth, and refined," effectively reflecting the lives of ordinary people and the historical significance of the "Thousand Miles Canal."

Technical Signifiers of Emotion

The emotional depth of these characters is supported by specific technical musical tools:

  • Modes and Climaxes: In Canal Ballad, the transition to the G feather mode in the 42nd section is a pivotal moment used to push the emotional climax and highlight the heroine’s sacrifice.
  • Rhythmic Tension: The use of triplets in both the accompaniment and melody of Canal Ballad serves as a primary tool for conveying the inner anxiety and tension of the characters.
  • Harmonic Contrast: While Puccini relies on complex contrasts between aria and recitative to build drama, Canal Ballad finds power in melodic simplicity that resonates with traditional folk roots.

Conclusion and Limitations

This comparative analysis reveals that while both operas use "Oriental" elements, they serve vastly different narrative and cultural purposes. Puccini’s hybridity created a lasting "Chinese temperament" (as perceived by the West) that has allowed Madame Butterfly to flourish for over a century. Conversely, Canal Ballad reclaims the Oriental female image, transforming it from a figure of submissiveness into a symbol of national strength.

As a preliminary study, this research is limited by its qualitative focus and the subjective nature of interpreting "national spirit." Future work should involve deeper music-theoretical breakdowns, including specific harmonic progressions and spectral analysis, to further bridge the cultural barriers in understanding these musical images in a globalized context.

Summary updated

Abstract

The national opera Canal Ballad tells a touching love story with the Beijing-Hangzhou Grand Canal created by the working people in ancient China as the background. Puccini's opera Madame Butterfly describes a humiliated oriental woman who fell in love with a fickle western man without complaint or regret, waited for him faithfully for three years, and finally was ruthlessly abandoned and committed suicide in despair. Through the basic music materials expressed in the operas Madame Butterfly and Canal Ballad, this paper has a preliminary understanding of the author's creative ideas. With women as the leading role, strong exotic sentiment, strong love, perfect combination of drama and lyricism, this paper compares and analyzes the use of oriental elements in these two works from the perspective of music, and discusses the unique charm of opera.
BibTeX
@misc{li2020comparative,
  author = {Beibei Li},
  title = {{A Comparative Study on the Construction of Oriental Female Music Images in Chinese and Western Opera——Take Madame Butterfly and Canal Ballads as examples}},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.23977/eeim2020004},
}
Figure