Abstract
A group is known as 'large' if some finite index subgroup admits a surjective homomorphism onto a non-abelian free group. In this paper, we give a necessary and sufficient condition for a finitely presented group to be large, in terms of the existence of a normal series where successive quotients are finite abelian groups with sufficiently large rank and order. The proof of this result involves an analysis of the geometry and topology of finite Cayley graphs. Theorems of Baumslag and Pride, and their extensions by Gromov and Stohr, on groups with more generators than relations, follow immediately.
Introduction
In the study of infinite groups, "largeness" is a property that signifies significant structural complexity. A finitely presented group $G$ is considered large if it contains a finite-index subgroup that maps surjectively onto a non-abelian free group. Such groups are of immense interest in low-dimensional topology and geometric group theory, particularly due to their super-exponential subgroup growth and connections to the fundamental groups of hyperbolic 3-manifolds.
Historically, detecting largeness has been difficult. While specific conditions, like having a presentation with significantly more generators than relations, were known to imply largeness, a general necessary and sufficient condition remained elusive. Marc Lackenby's work provides this missing characterization by linking algebraic growth to the geometric properties of Cayley graphs.
Geometric Innovation: Graph Width
The core technical breakthrough in Lackenby's approach is the adaptation of "thin position"—a concept from knot theory—to define the width of a finite graph. For a Cayley graph of a group, the width is determined by finding an optimal linear ordering of its vertices.
As shown in Figure 2, by ordering the vertices and considering "planes" (cuts) between them, one can count the number of intersections (edges crossing the cut). The width of the graph under a specific ordering is the maximum number of such intersections. The overall width of the graph is the minimum width over all possible orderings. Lackenby uses this to identify "bottlenecks" in the group's finite quotients, relating the failure of a group to have Property ($τ$) to these geometric constraints.
Topological Decomposition and Proof Strategy
The proof of the main characterization involves a sophisticated interplay between the geometry of the 1-skeleton (the Cayley graph) and the topology of a 2-complex associated with the group presentation. Lackenby "slices" this complex into pieces based on the minimal width of its 1-skeleton.
By analyzing the Euler characteristic of these decomposed pieces, the paper demonstrates that if the pieces are sufficiently "large" (high rank) and the cuts are sufficiently "thin" (low width), the group must admit a surjection onto a free group. Figure 3 illustrates the process of collapsing certain structures within these complexes to simplify the analysis of the quotients $G/J_i$ and $H_i/J_i$.
Key Results
The central result, Theorem 1.1, establishes that a finitely presented group is large if and only if it possesses a sequence of subgroups with finite abelian quotients whose rank and order grow at a specific, rapid rate. Specifically, the rank must grow linearly and the logarithm of the order must grow super-exponentially relative to the subgroup index.
This theorem serves as a unifying framework for several classical results in group theory. For instance, it provides a direct proof of the Baumslag-Pride Theorem, which states that any group with a presentation having at least two more generators than relations is large. Furthermore, it connects these algebraic conditions to the virtual first Betti number, linking the existence of large quotients to the presence of infinite abelianizations in finite-index subgroups.
Conclusion
Lackenby’s characterization offers a powerful new yardstick for measuring the "size" of finitely presented groups. By importing geometric tools like graph width into the algebraic domain, the paper provides a definitive structural condition for largeness. While applying this condition to specific cases like hyperbolic 3-manifold groups remains a challenge, the theoretical framework established here bridges a significant gap between the geometry of graphs and the algebra of infinite groups.
Summary updated