A case report of agoraphobia following right parietal lobe surgery: changes in functional and structural connectivities of the multimodal vestibular network

Iole Indovina, Alberto Cacciola, Sergio Delle Monache, Demetrio Milardi, Francesco Lacquaniti, Nicola Toschi, Jérôme Cochereau, Gianfranco BoscoFrontiers in Neurology 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This case report details a patient who developed agoraphobia following the surgical removal of a brain tumor in the right parietal lobe. By comparing brain scans from before and after surgery, researchers demonstrated that the disorder was driven by a physical "disconnection" in the brain’s vestibular network, followed by a functional reorganization that likely triggered the patient's intense fear of open spaces.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Agoraphobia is traditionally categorized as a psychiatric anxiety disorder characterized by a fear of situations where escape might be difficult. However, a growing body of research suggests it may actually be a visuo-vestibular-spatial disorder. This means the root cause might lie in how the brain integrates balance (vestibular), visual, and spatial information.

While previous studies have linked vestibular dysfunction to anxiety, it is rare to observe the transition into agoraphobia in real-time due to a specific brain lesion. This paper addresses the gap in understanding how physical damage to the "vestibular network"—specifically the parietal lobe—reconfigures the brain's connectivity to produce the complex behavioral symptoms of agoraphobia.

Methods

The researchers conducted a longitudinal study of a 41-year-old female patient undergoing surgery for a high-grade glioma in her right supramarginal gyrus (part of the parietal lobe).

They employed a combination of advanced neuroimaging and mathematical modeling:

  • Imaging: They used structural MRI, Diffusion-Weighted Imaging (DWI) for tractography (mapping physical "wiring"), and resting-state functional MRI (fMRI) to monitor brain activity patterns.
  • Timepoints: Data was collected before surgery (pre-op) and at 5 and 7 months post-surgery.
  • Graph Theory: This is the study's core novelty. Instead of just looking at isolated brain regions, they treated the vestibular network as a mathematical graph of 142 nodes. They measured nodal strength (how well-connected a region is), clustering coefficients (how much neighbors talk to each other), and local efficiency (how well information flows).
  • The Network: They focused specifically on a network of 142 spherical regions of interest (ROIs) known to be associated with the multimodal vestibular cortex.

Datasets

As a Case Report, the primary dataset is the longitudinal imaging and clinical data from a single patient. To define the brain regions for their graph analysis, the authors utilized established neuroanatomical templates, specifically the Eickhoff and Fan atlases, to identify the 142 nodes of the vestibular network.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Structural Disconnection: Surgery didn't just remove the tumor; it caused a widespread "thinning" of structural connections. The researchers found a decrease in clustering and efficiency across the limbic system, insular cortex, and parietal/frontal areas. This indicates a general breakdown in the physical infrastructure of the vestibular network.
  • Functional Compensation vs. Maladaptation: While structural connectivity decreased, the functional network showed a different pattern. Seven months post-surgery, there was a significant increase in functional clustering and efficiency in the anterior insula and cingulate cortex.
  • The "Aha" Moment: The authors suggest that this functional increase in the insula (a region tied to internal emotional feelings) and the cingulate cortex (tied to avoidance behavior) represents a "predominant role" for these areas. Essentially, the brain became hyper-aware of internal fear signals to compensate for the loss of spatial processing in the parietal lobe, leading to agoraphobic avoidance.
  • Vestibular-Anxiety Link: The study reinforces the idea that the vestibular system and the emotional/anxiety systems are deeply intertwined at a hardware level in the brain.

Key Results

  • Structural: 54 regions showed a significant decrease in the clustering coefficient post-surgery, particularly in the limbic and insular cortices.
  • Functional (Pre-op vs. 5 months post-op): Significant decreases in connectivity strength were found in the right middle temporal gyrus (area 37dl) and the supramarginal gyrus (PFcm).
  • Functional (Pre-op vs. 7 months post-op): While the parietal decreases persisted, there was a notable increase in connectivity metrics in the precuneus, parietal/frontal opercula, and the limbic/insular cortex.
  • Clinical Outcome: The patient reported symptoms of agoraphobia and avoidance behavior shortly after returning home post-surgery, coinciding with these neural changes.

Limitations and Future Work

The most obvious limitation is the sample size (N=1). As a case report, these findings cannot be immediately generalized to all agoraphobia patients. Additionally, the patient was left-handed, which can sometimes result in atypical brain lateralization (how functions are divided between the left and right hemispheres), potentially influencing the results.

The authors suggest that future research should involve larger cohorts of patients with parietal lesions to determine if this specific pattern of "vestibular network reorganization" can serve as a predictable biomarker for developing spatial anxiety disorders. This could eventually lead to targeted rehabilitation or neuromodulation therapies for agoraphobia.

Summary updated

Abstract

Agoraphobia is a visuo-vestibular-spatial disorder that may involve dysfunction of the vestibular network, which includes the insular and limbic cortex. We sought to study the neural correlates of this disorder in an individual who developed agoraphobia after surgical removal of a high-grade glioma located in the right parietal lobe, by assessing pre- and post-surgery connectivities in the vestibular network. The patient underwent surgical resection of the glioma located within the right supramarginal gyrus. The resection interested also portions of the superior and inferior parietal lobe. Structural and functional connectivities were assessed through magnetic resonance imaging before and 5 and 7 months after surgery. Connectivity analyses focused on a network comprising 142 spherical regions of interest (4 mm radius) associated with the vestibular cortex: 77 in the left and 65 in the right hemisphere (excluding lesioned regions). Tractography for diffusion-weighted structural data and correlation between time series for functional resting-state data were calculated for each pair of regions in order to build weighted connectivity matrices. Graph theory was applied to assess post-surgery changes in network measures, such as strength, clustering coefficient, and local efficiency. Structural connectomes after surgery showed a decrease of strength in the preserved ventral portion of the supramarginal gyrus (PFcm) and in a high order visual motion area in the right middle temporal gyrus (37dl), and decrease of the clustering coefficient and of the local efficiency in several areas of the limbic, insular cortex, parietal and frontal cortex, indicating general disconnection of the vestibular network. Functional connectivity analysis showed both a decrease in connectivity metrics, mainly in high-order visual areas and in the parietal cortex, and an increase in connectivity metrics, mainly in the precuneus, parietal and frontal opercula, limbic, and insular cortex. This post-surgery reorganization of the vestibular network is compatible with altered processing of visuo-vestibular-spatial information, yielding agoraphobia symptoms. Specifically, post-surgical functional increases of clustering coefficient and local efficiency in the anterior insula and in the cingulate cortex might indicate a more predominant role of these areas within the vestibular network, which could be predictive of the fear and avoiding behavior characterizing agoraphobia.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{indovina2023case,
  author = {Iole Indovina and Alberto Cacciola and Sergio Delle Monache and Demetrio Milardi and Francesco Lacquaniti and Nicola Toschi and Jérôme Cochereau and Gianfranco Bosco},
  title = {{A case report of agoraphobia following right parietal lobe surgery: changes in functional and structural connectivities of the multimodal vestibular network}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Neurology},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3389/fneur.2023.1163005},
}
Figure