TL;DR
This paper revisits the performance of various priority queue implementations, from classic to recent theoretical variants, using a straightforward, "back-to-basics" approach. The study reveals that conventional wisdom about which priority queues are fastest is often mistaken, and that cache performance, particularly at the L1 level, is a critical factor often overlooked in theoretical analyses.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
The field of priority queues has seen a surge of new theoretical heap variants in recent years, promising improved performance guarantees. However, many of these advancements have remained largely untested experimentally, with existing empirical studies being outdated or narrow in scope. This paper aims to bridge this gap by providing a comprehensive, empirical reevaluation of both classic and novel priority queue structures. The authors argue that a lack of straightforward, "naïve" implementations in the literature might be obscuring the true practical performance of these data structures, and that a deeper understanding of their behavior under realistic workloads, especially concerning cache performance, is crucial.
Methods
The authors implemented a variety of priority queue structures, including traditional ones like binary heaps (implicit and explicit d-ary heaps) and newer variants such as pairing heaps, Fibonacci heaps, binomial queues, and several Fibonacci heap relaxations. Their key methodological choice was to implement these structures in a "straightforward" manner, directly from their original descriptions, avoiding extensive algorithm engineering or "tweaking." This approach aims to reflect how a practitioner might initially implement and compare these structures. Performance was evaluated using a variety of workloads, and metrics collected included not only wallclock time but also dynamic instruction counts, L1/L2 cache reads/writes/misses, and branch prediction statistics.
Datasets
The paper uses a variety of workloads for evaluation:
- Artificial randomized workloads:
- Sorting sequences of uniformly random integers (n insertions followed by n deletions).
- Degenerate insertion-deletion sequences (n insertions, then c repetitions of one insertion followed by one deletion).
- Key-decrease workloads, which intersperse insertions, deletions, and key decreases.
- More realistic workloads:
- Dijkstra's algorithm for shortest paths, run on various graph structures (including those designed to stress DECREASEKEY operations) and real road networks.
- The Nagamochi-Ibaraki algorithm for minimum cut.
- Workloads generated by the
htsimpacket-level network simulator, modeling network protocols like TCP and MPTCP, including traces from real network traffic.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Cache performance is king: The study strongly suggests that L1 cache miss rate is the most significant predictor of wallclock time for priority queue operations, often more so than theoretical complexity.
- Conventional wisdom is often wrong: Many theoretical advantages of complex heaps do not translate to practical speedups, and sometimes simpler structures outperform them. For example, Fibonacci heaps are often slower than expected, and implicit d-ary heaps can be surprisingly competitive.
- Workload matters immensely: The relative performance of different priority queue implementations is highly dependent on the specific workload. Degenerate workloads, where the distribution of keys becomes skewed, can lead to misleading results if not carefully considered.
- "Naïve" implementations can be competitive: The authors' straightforward implementations, without aggressive optimization, often perform well, suggesting that complex theoretical structures don't always justify their implementation complexity in practice.
- Write-first vs. Read-first access patterns: Implicit heaps tend to exhibit a "read-first" access pattern, while pairing heaps can be "write-first," leading to different cache behaviors (read misses vs. write misses).
Key Results
- Implicit d-ary heaps often perform very well: Especially implicit-4 heaps, which frequently achieve the best or near-best performance on sorting and Dijkstra workloads.
- Fibonacci heaps are often slow: The classic Fibonacci heap is consistently outperformed by simpler structures, echoing long-standing complaints about its practical performance.
- Pairing heaps can be surprisingly slow on certain workloads: Despite their theoretical appeal, pairing heaps can be significantly slower than implicit heaps on some insertion-deletion workloads, particularly when cache performance is critical.
- Degenerate workloads are problematic: A common insertion-deletion workload was shown to be degenerate, where the heap contents become skewed, leading to predictable but potentially misleading performance results.
- Cache effects are pronounced: Tweaking node sizes to influence cache behavior directly impacted performance, with wallclock time often correlating with cache miss rates.
Limitations and Future Work
- Not a final word: The authors explicitly state that this is not a definitive study and that the push for better-performing heaps may still yield practical benefits.
- Cache-oblivious structures might not be optimal: The study suggests that complicated, cache-oblivious structures are unlikely to outperform simpler, cache-aware ones, a hypothesis that could be explored further.
- Need for more diverse workloads: The authors suggest exploring other classes of workloads to gain a more complete understanding of priority queue performance.
- Experimental verification of theoretical claims: Future work could involve more rigorous experimental verification of theoretical performance bounds and the impact of specific optimizations.
- Simple implementations as a resource: The authors hope their straightforward implementations will serve as a useful resource for future research.
Summary updated