411 Experimental Study on Optimized Guide Vanes of Vertical Axis Type of Cross Flow Wind Turbines

Jiro Taniguchi, koutarou Gotou, Kouki Kishinami, Norihei Kon, Himsar Anbarita, Jun SuzukiThe Proceedings of the Symposium on Environmental Engineering 2008 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper experimentally investigates how the number and geometry of guide vanes—stationary blades surrounding a wind turbine—affect the performance of vertical axis cross-flow wind turbines. The researchers demonstrate that while 3-vane configurations offer the highest peak efficiency, 4- and 5-vane setups with adjustable flaps provide much more stable power output across shifting wind directions, making them better suited for real-world environments.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Cross-flow wind turbines are valued for their high starting torque and ability to operate at low wind speeds. Unlike traditional propeller-style turbines, they don't necessarily need a tail fin to "track" the wind because they are vertical. However, their efficiency is heavily dependent on guide vanes, which direct airflow into the rotor.

The "holy grail" for these turbines is omnidirectionality: maintaining high efficiency regardless of which way the wind is blowing. Previous 3-vane designs achieved high peak power but suffered from "dead zones"—specific angles where performance plummeted. This paper explores whether increasing the vane count or adding secondary "flaps" and "sub-vanes" can smooth out these performance gaps.

Methods

The researchers conducted wind tunnel experiments using a sub-scale model. The setup included:

  • The Rotor: A 320mm diameter rotor with 30 curved aluminum blades.
  • Guide Vane Configurations: They tested 3, 4, and 5 symmetric guide vane arrangements.
  • Novel Attachments: To improve airflow, they added 100mm "flaps" to the ends of the vanes. They also experimented with:
  • Slit Flaps: Flaps with a small gap between them and the main vane.
  • Inner/Outer Sub-vanes: Smaller secondary vanes placed either closer to the rotor or further out.
  • Testing Parameters: They measured torque and rotation speed at wind velocities of 3.85 m/s and 5.05 m/s, varying the wind direction angle ($\theta$) from $+40^\circ$ to $-40^\circ$.

Datasets

As an experimental physics/engineering paper, it does not use digital datasets for training. Instead, the "dataset" is the primary experimental data generated by the authors, consisting of:

  • Power coefficients ($C_p$) and torque coefficients ($C_q$) plotted against tip speed ratios ($\lambda$).
  • Comparative performance curves for 3, 4, and 5 vanes across a $80^\circ$ arc of wind directions.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Stability-Efficiency Trade-off: There is a clear tension between maximum power and directional stability. The 3-vane setup is the "sprinter"—fast and powerful at its best angle, but weak elsewhere. The 5-vane setup is the "marathon runner"—consistent and reliable across almost all angles.
  • The 5-Vane Robustness: With a 5-vane setup and $20^\circ$ flaps, the difference between the best and worst wind angles was less than a factor of two. This makes it highly "wind-direction resistant."
  • Sub-vane Placement is Critical: Adding small "inner" sub-vanes near the rotor helped fill in the performance gaps of the 3-vane design (reducing the drop-off to about 50%). However, placing those same sub-vanes on the outside of the guide vanes actually made performance worse, causing an 85% drop at certain angles.
  • Symmetry Benefits: Because the 4-vane system is axially symmetric, it effectively provides 16 high-performance points across a full $360^\circ$ rotation (4 vanes $\times$ 4 optimal angles per vane).

Key Results

  • Power Boost: Adding guide vanes increased the power coefficient ($C_p$) by more than 2.3 times compared to a bare rotor.
  • Peak Performance:
    • The 3-vane setup reached the highest peak $C_p$ of 0.205 (at a $30^\circ$ wind angle), but crashed to a negligible 0.014 at $0^\circ$.
  • The 4-vane setup achieved a peak $C_p$ of 0.198, offering a 25% power increase over the 5-vane version while maintaining better stability than the 3-vane version.
  • The 5-vane setup peaked at 0.156. While lower, it was the most stable, with a minimum $C_p$ of 0.083 even at its worst angle.
  • Optimal Recommendation: For regions with highly variable wind directions (like Japan), the authors recommend the 4-vane configuration with $10^\circ$ flaps as the best balance of high output and stability.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Scale Effects: The study was performed on a sub-scale model in a controlled wind tunnel. Real-world, full-scale turbines may face different Reynolds number effects and structural stresses.
  • Turbulence: The wind tunnel provides relatively "clean" air. The impact of highly turbulent urban wind on these specific vane geometries remains a question.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest further optimization of the "inner sub-vane" concept, as it showed promise in fixing the directional weaknesses of high-efficiency 3-vane designs without requiring a total redesign.

Summary updated

Abstract

In this paper, aerodynamic characteristics of the cross flow type of wind turbine were studied experimentally by using sub-scale model, considering the effect of guide vanes and its arrangement. The aerodynamics characteristics of the turbine for wind flow direction were discussed by reference to the power and the torque coefficients correlation of tip speed ratio for various combinations of approaching optimized guide vanes number and optimal configuration.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{taniguchi2008experimental,
  author = {Jiro Taniguchi and koutarou Gotou and Kouki Kishinami and Norihei Kon and Himsar Anbarita and Jun Suzuki},
  title = {{411 Experimental Study on Optimized Guide Vanes of Vertical Axis Type of Cross Flow Wind Turbines}},
  booktitle = {The Proceedings of the Symposium on Environmental Engineering},
  year = {2008},
  doi = {10.1299/jsmeenv.2008.18.346},
}
Figure