$4\times4$ unextendible product basis and genuinely entangled space

Kai Wang, Lin Chen, Li-Jun Zhao, Yu-Min GuoarXiv 2019 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

This paper identifies six inequivalent $4\times4$ unextendible product bases (UPBs) of size eight derived from 4-qubit product vectors. These results are applied to construct rank-nine Positive-Partial-Transpose (PPT) entangled states. Notably, one UPB is orthogonal to an "almost" genuinely entangled space, which lacks $4\times4$ product vectors across any bipartition. Furthermore, a structural theorem is established relating multipartite UPBs to $n \times n \times n$ tripartite systems, addressing an open problem in quantum information theory.

The Challenge of Bound Entanglement

In quantum information theory, Unextendible Product Bases (UPBs) are critical for understanding the boundary between separable and entangled states. A UPB is a set of orthogonal product vectors whose orthogonal complement contains no product vectors. This property makes them ideal for constructing Positive-Partial-Transpose (PPT) entangled states—states that are entangled but cannot be distilled into pure entanglement, often referred to as "bound entanglement."

Constructing Six Inequivalent UPBs

The researchers utilized the framework of Unextendible Orthogonal Matrices (UOMs) to represent product vectors. By analyzing the algebraic properties of these matrices, they identified six distinct $4 \times 4$ UPBs, labeled $F_1$ through $F_6$.

Table 1: Maximum number of independent variables for the six UOMs, demonstrating their inequivalence.

As shown in the table above, the "maximum number of independent variables" serves as a mathematical signature for each matrix. Because these signatures differ, the six bases cannot be transformed into one another through local unitaries or qubit permutations, proving they are mathematically distinct objects.

Orthogonality and "Almost" Genuinely Entangled Spaces

A key contribution of this work is the exploration of Genuinely Entangled (GE) spaces—subspaces where every state is entangled across every possible bipartition. While finding a UPB orthogonal to a true GE space remains an open challenge, the authors discovered that the basis $F_6$ is orthogonal to an "almost" GE space.

Figure 1: Orthogonality graph illustrating the relationships between a central product vector $|v\rangle$ and its neighbors $|v_i\rangle$.

The orthogonality structure depicted in Figure 1 highlights how these vectors are constrained. The basis $F_6$ is unique because it acts as a bipartite UPB across all three major $4 \times 4$ partitions of a 4-qubit system (AB:CD, AC:BD, and AD:BC). This symmetry ensures that its orthogonal complement contains no $4 \times 4$ product vectors in any of these bipartitions, representing a significant step toward finding a UPB orthogonal to a true GE space.

Implications and the $n \times n \times n$ Theorem

Beyond the specific $4 \times 4$ constructions, the paper proves a significant structural theorem: a multipartite UPB orthogonal to a GE space exists if and only if a corresponding $n \times n \times n$ tripartite UPB exists. This reduction simplifies the search for GE-orthogonal UPBs by focusing on tripartite systems.

Furthermore, the construction of rank-nine PPT states from subsets of these UPBs challenges the traditional view that the entire range must be devoid of product states to ensure entanglement. These findings provide a new toolkit for investigating the complex landscape of multipartite entanglement and bound entangled states.

Summary updated

Abstract

We show that there are six inequivalent $4\times4$ unextendible product bases (UPBs) of size eight, when we consider only 4-qubit product vectors. We apply our results to construct Positive-Partial-Transpose entangled states of rank nine. They are at the same 4-qubit, $2\times2\times4$ and $4\times4$ states, and their ranges have product vectors. One of the six UPBs turns out to be orthogonal to an almost genuinely entangled space, in the sense that the latter does not contain $4\times4$ product vector in any bipartition of 4-qubit systems. We also show that the multipartite UPB orthogonal to a genuinely entangled space exists if and only if the $n\times n\times n$ UPB orthogonal to a genuinely entangled space exists for some $n$. These results help understand an open problem in [Phys. Rev. A 98, 012313, 2018].
BibTeX
@misc{wang2019times,
  author = {Kai Wang and Lin Chen and Li-Jun Zhao and Yu-Min Guo},
  title = {{$4\textbackslash\{\}times4$ unextendible product basis and genuinely entangled space}},
  year = {2019},
  eprint = {1901.06093},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1901.06093},
}

Loading related content...

Figure