3D shape of asteroid (6) Hebe from VLT/SPHERE imaging: Implications for the origin of ordinary H chondrites

Michaël Marsset, B. Carry, Christophe Dumas, J. Hanuš, M. Viikinkoski, Pierre Vernazza, T. G. Müller, Marco Delbó, Emmanuël Jehin, M. Gillon, J. Grice, Bin Yang, Thierry Fusco, J. Berthier, S. Sonnett, F. Kugel, J. Caron, R. BehrendSpringer Link (Chiba Institute of Technology) 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a high-resolution 3D shape model of asteroid (6) Hebe using VLT/SPHERE data, challenging the long-held hypothesis that Hebe is the parent body of ordinary H chondrite meteorites. The detailed topography reveals that the largest impact crater on Hebe is too small to account for the volume of H chondrite-like asteroid families, suggesting an alternative origin for these common meteorites.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

For decades, asteroid (6) Hebe has been a prime candidate for the origin of ordinary H chondrite meteorites, which constitute about 34% of all meteorites found on Earth. This hypothesis was based on Hebe's spectral properties and its location within orbital resonances that could transport material to Earth. However, previous studies lacked detailed information about Hebe's surface topography, particularly the size and volume of its largest impact features. This paper aims to address this gap by using advanced ground-based imaging to create a precise 3D shape model of Hebe, allowing for a more accurate assessment of its collisional history and its potential role as a meteorite parent body. The study also seeks to advance the field of asteroid shape modeling by demonstrating the capabilities of new-generation adaptive optics instruments for studying medium-sized asteroids from Earth.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-faceted approach to reconstruct Hebe's 3D shape and properties. The core of their method involved using the SPHERE instrument on the Very Large Telescope (VLT) for high-angular-resolution imaging. These new SPHERE images were combined with previously published adaptive-optics (AO) images from Keck/NIRC2 and VLT/NACO, as well as optical light curves.

A key technique used was the ADAM (Asteroid Deformation and Modeling) algorithm, which can simultaneously derive an asteroid's spin, 3D shape, and size by iteratively minimizing residuals between Fourier-transformed images and a projected polyhedral model. This method allows for direct use of AO images without needing to extract boundary contours. The algorithm was applied to both a dataset including all available AO images and a subset using only the higher-resolution SPHERE data.

To further validate their findings, the team also incorporated stellar occultation data and performed thermophysical modeling using mid-infrared measurements. This allowed them to independently estimate Hebe's size and surface thermal properties, providing a cross-check for the shape model.

Datasets

The study utilized the following datasets:

  • VLT/SPHERE imaging: Newly acquired data from the SPHERE instrument during its science verification phase.
  • Previous AO imaging: Data from Keck/NIRC2 and VLT/NACO instruments, collected at various epochs.
  • Optical light curves: A compilation of 38 light curves from 1953-1993 (from the DAMIT database) and 16 light curves from amateur astronomers, along with 84 light curves from the SuperWASP survey and 4 from the TRAPPIST telescope.
  • Stellar occultation data: Five events listed in the Planetary Data System (PDS), with two providing usable chords for shape constraint.
  • Mid-infrared thermal measurements: Data from IRAS, AKARI-IRC, ISO-ISOPHOT, and Herschel-PACS instruments.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • SPHERE's power for asteroid surface detail: The study highlights the transformative capability of VLT/SPHERE for resolving surface features on medium-sized asteroids from the ground, opening a new era of detailed asteroid exploration.
  • Hebe's shape is not crater-dominated: While Hebe exhibits an irregular, impact-molded shape, the volume of its largest depression (likely an impact crater) is significantly smaller than what would be expected if it were the sole source of H chondrites.
  • Density suggests an intact interior: Hebe's inferred density of 3.48 ± 0.64 g/cm³ is consistent with an intact interior, aligning with the composition of H chondrites and suggesting minimal internal porosity.
  • Challenging the H chondrite parent body hypothesis: The paper provides strong evidence against Hebe being the primary source of H chondrites, primarily due to the limited volume of its largest impact feature compared to known H chondrite-like asteroid families.
  • A new era of asteroid belt investigation: The research sets the stage for future studies using VLT/SPHERE to survey a larger sample of asteroids, providing an unprecedented dataset for understanding the origin and collisional evolution of the asteroid belt.

Key Results

  • 3D Shape Model: A precise 3D shape model of (6) Hebe was derived, fitting observational data with sub-pixel residuals for images and 0.02 mag for light curves.
  • Rotation Period: The rotation period was determined to be 7.27447 hours.
  • Spin Parameters: The spin vector was characterized by ECJ2000 coordinates (λ, β) of 343°, +47°.
  • Volume-Equivalent Diameter: The volume-equivalent diameter was found to be 193 ± 6 km.
  • Bulk Density: Hebe's bulk density was calculated as 3.48 ± 0.64 g/cm³.
  • Largest Depression Volume: The largest depression on Hebe accounts for approximately 10⁵ km³, corresponding to a body with an equivalent diameter of ~58 km. This volume is significantly smaller (5-6 times) than the total volume of known S-type families spectrally analogous to H chondrites.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Mass Uncertainty: The paper acknowledges that the uncertainty in Hebe's mass, while reduced by the study, still dominates the uncertainty in its bulk density. Future mass estimates, particularly from missions like Gaia, are expected to refine this.
  • Thermal Inertia Interpretation: The observed variation in thermal inertia with heliocentric distance is noted, but the authors caution that this result should be interpreted with extreme care due to potential overfitting of the data by the thermophysical model.
  • Future Surveys: The authors plan to use VLT/SPHERE to collect similar high-precision shape measurements for approximately 40 asteroids across different compositional classes. This comprehensive dataset will be crucial for investigating the origin and collisional evolution of the asteroid belt.
  • Alternative H Chondrite Sources: The study implies that a recent, yet-to-be-identified collision on another H-chondrite-like asteroid is a more likely source for the majority of H chondrites, given their cosmic ray exposure ages and the need for recent impact events.

Summary updated

Abstract

Context. The high-angular-resolution capability of the new-generation ground-based adaptive-optics camera SPHERE at ESO VLT allows us to assess, for the very first time, the cratering record of medium-sized (D ~ 100–200 km) asteroids from the ground, opening the prospect of a new era of investigation of the asteroid belt’s collisional history. Aims. We investigate here the collisional history of asteroid (6) Hebe and challenge the idea that Hebe may be the parent body of ordinary H chondrites, the most common type of meteorites found on Earth (~34% of the falls). Methods. We observed Hebe with SPHERE as part of the science verification of the instrument. Combined with earlier adaptive-optics images and optical light curves, we model the spin and three-dimensional (3D) shape of Hebe and check the consistency of the derived model against available stellar occultations and thermal measurements. Results. Our 3D shape model fits the images with sub-pixel residuals and the light curves to 0.02 mag. The rotation period (7.274 47 h), spin (ECJ2000 λ, β of 343°, +47°), and volume-equivalent diameter (193 ± 6 km) are consistent with previous determinations and thermophysical modeling. Hebe’s inferred density is 3.48 ± 0.64 g cm-3, in agreement with an intact interior based on its H-chondrite composition. Using the 3D shape model to derive the volume of the largest depression (likely impact crater), it appears that the latter is significantly smaller than the total volume of close-by S-type H-chondrite-like asteroid families. Conclusions. Our results imply that (6) Hebe is not the most likely source of H chondrites. Over the coming years, our team will collect similar high-precision shape measurements with VLT/SPHERE for ~40 asteroids covering the main compositional classes, thus providing an unprecedented dataset to investigate the origin and collisional evolution of the asteroid belt.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{marsset2017d,
  author = {Michaël Marsset and B. Carry and Christophe Dumas and J. Hanuš and M. Viikinkoski and Pierre Vernazza and T. G. Müller and Marco Delbó and Emmanuël Jehin and M. Gillon and J. Grice and Bin Yang and Thierry Fusco and J. Berthier and S. Sonnett and F. Kugel and J. Caron and R. Behrend},
  title = {{3D shape of asteroid (6) Hebe from VLT/SPHERE imaging: Implications for the origin of ordinary H chondrites}},
  booktitle = {Springer Link (Chiba Institute of Technology)},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.1051/0004-6361/201731021/pdf},
}

Loading related content...

Figure