221 The Effect of Full Protective Gear on Intubation Performance by Hospital Medical Personnel

Israel Hendler, I. Ziv, Orit Nahtomi, Eran Segal, Amanda L. Robinson, Andy Haines, M Wiener, Joseph MeyerovitchPrehospital 1993 · DOI

Introduction

In the event of a chemical warfare attack or a major industrial accident involving nerve agents, respiratory arrest is the most lethal complication. The standard medical response is endotracheal intubation—inserting a tube into the airway to facilitate mechanical ventilation. However, in these "hot zone" scenarios, medical responders must wear bulky Nuclear, Biological, and Chemical (NBC) protective suits and gloves. This study quantifies the "performance penalty" imposed by this gear, providing vital data for disaster planning and medical equipment design.

Methodology

Researchers conducted a comparative study involving medical personnel, specifically anesthesiologists and nurses, performing intubations on simulation models (manikins). The study utilized a within-subjects design where participants performed serial intubations under two conditions:

  1. Standard Condition: Participants wore standard hospital attire.
  2. NBC Condition: Participants wore full NBC protective gear.

The team measured total procedure time, the time required for specific sub-steps (such as securing the tube), and the participants' subjective self-assessment of their performance quality.

Key Results and Analysis

The Time Penalty

The study found a statistically significant increase in the time required to complete the procedure. Total intubation time rose from an average of 47.3 seconds in standard attire to 69.2 seconds in full gear—a 46% increase ($p < .05$). While the procedure remained effective, this delay could have critical implications for patient outcomes in mass-casualty events.

The Fixation Bottleneck

The most significant finding was that the actual insertion of the tube was not the primary difficulty. Instead, the struggle centered on tube fixation (securing the tube in place).

  • The time required for fixation increased by 74% when wearing protective gear.
  • 81% of the medical personnel identified tube fixation as the most problematic stage of the entire procedure.

This suggests that while the cognitive steps of intubation remain intact, the fine motor skills required to handle adhesive tape or fixation devices through thick NBC gloves are severely compromised.

The Confidence Gap

There was a massive drop in perceived competence among the practitioners. While they were able to complete the task, their subjective confidence plummeted:

  • Standard Attire: 62.5% of participants felt they did a "very good" job.
  • NBC Gear: Only 6.25% of participants felt they did a "very good" job.

Discussion and Future Directions

The study highlights a critical need for medical hardware that is compatible with protective gear. The authors conclude that while intubation can still be performed effectively in NBC gear, the significant time penalty—driven largely by fixation difficulties—must be addressed.

Recommendations

The authors strongly recommend the development of new "appliances" for tube fixation. Current methods, which likely rely on adhesive tape or manual ties, are not designed for use with bulky gloves. A mechanical or "quick-clip" fixation device could potentially eliminate the 74% time penalty found in this study, streamlining life-saving care in contaminated environments.

Limitations

As this study was performed on simulation manikins, real-world factors such as poor lighting, patient secretions, or the psychological stress of a disaster zone were not accounted for. These factors would likely further degrade performance beyond the metrics observed in this controlled trial.

Summary updated

Abstract

Background: Large-scale disasters, such as accidental chemical spills or strategic use of nerve gas, may result in great numbers of casualties requiring mechanical ventilation. The number of ventilators required may exceed the supply. Objective: To develop improvised breathing circuits that extend the capability of a single ventilator to provide ventilation support to several patients during critical emergencies. Methods: Two types of circuits were assembled from readily available, inexpensive components. One delivers the tidal volume (V t ) directly to the patient and the other does so through a number of secondary circuits in parallel. Both types require an additional source of fresh gas flow (FGF) for each patient. An examination was made of the role of ventilator V t , inspiratory time, frequency, and FGF on delivered V t using mechanical lung simulators. Results: Each circuit type can provide individual patient V t , inspired oxygen concentration, and positive end-expiratory pressure (PEEP). The secondary circuit configuration is more efficient in terms of FGF usage, but is more complex with respect to mode of operation. Conclusions: A description is provided of two breathing circuits assembled from easily accessible components. Each can provide automatic ventilation to several patients with a single ventilator during emergencies.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{hendler1993effect,
  author = {Israel Hendler and I. Ziv and Orit Nahtomi and Eran Segal and Amanda L. Robinson and Andy Haines and M Wiener and Joseph Meyerovitch},
  title = {{221 The Effect of Full Protective Gear on Intubation Performance by Hospital Medical Personnel}},
  booktitle = {Prehospital},
  year = {1993},
  doi = {10.1017/s1049023x00048469},
}
Figure