100 Gbps Quantum-safe IPsec VPN Tunnels over 46 km Deployed Fiber

Obada Alia, Albert S. Huang, Huan Luo, Omar Amer, Marco Pistoia, Charles Ci Wen LimarXiv 2024 · DOI · arXiv

TL;DR

Researchers from JPMorgan Chase have demonstrated the first 100 Gbps quantum-safe IPsec VPN tunnels over 46 km of real-world deployed fiber. By integrating Quantum Key Distribution (QKD) with next-generation firewalls, they achieved near-line-rate encryption that is resilient against both current classical threats and future quantum computer attacks.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The looming "Quantum Apocalypse" isn't just a future concern; it’s a present-day risk known as Harvest Now, Decrypt Later (HNDL). Attackers can capture encrypted sensitive data today and store it until large-scale quantum computers are powerful enough to break the underlying RSA or Diffie-Hellman math.

While Post-Quantum Cryptography (PQC) offers algorithmic defenses, Quantum Key Distribution (QKD) provides a hardware-based solution rooted in the laws of physics. However, QKD has historically been confined to laboratory settings or low-speed links. This paper addresses the challenge of scaling QKD-secured infrastructure to meet the high-bandwidth demands (100 Gbps) of modern enterprise data centers using existing, "dirty" telecom fiber.

Methods

The team deployed a field trial across Singapore, connecting two data centers via 46 km of underground fiber. The architecture utilized three distinct layers:

  1. Quantum Layer: Used the ID Quantique Clavis XGR system implementing the decoy-state four-state BB84 protocol. This layer generates the raw quantum keys.
  2. Control and Management Layer: Utilized the ETSI-QKD-014 REST API, a standardized interface that allows the Key Management System (KMS) to deliver keys to classical network devices.
  3. Data Layer: Featured Fortinet FortiGate 4201F next-generation firewalls (NGFWs) and a FortiTester 4000E traffic generator.

The technical "secret sauce" was a modified IKEv2 (Internet Key Exchange) implementation. Instead of relying solely on a Diffie-Hellman exchange to generate session keys, the researchers injected QKD-generated keys as a fresh source of high-quality entropy into the key derivation process for IPsec Child Security Associations (SAs). This ensures that even if the initial handshake is compromised, the session keys remain quantum-secure.

Datasets

As an experimental field trial, the "dataset" consists of performance metrics gathered over 45 days of continuous operation, involving over 290,000 data points. The researchers monitored:

  • Secret Key Rate (SKR): The speed of key generation.
  • Quantum Bit Error Rate (QBER): A measure of noise and potential eavesdropping.
  • Throughput: Real-world data transfer speeds across the VPN tunnels.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Standardization is Key: By using the ETSI-QKD-014 API, the researchers proved that QKD can be integrated into vendor-agnostic, "off-the-shelf" networking hardware rather than requiring bespoke, proprietary systems.
  • Entropy Injection vs. Replacement: Rather than throwing away the entire IPsec protocol, they modified the key derivation function. This allows for a "defense-in-depth" approach where QKD adds a layer of quantum resistance to established classical security protocols.
  • Aggregation for Speed: To hit the 100 Gbps milestone, the team found that a multi-tunnel configuration (12 tunnels) was more efficient than a single massive tunnel, achieving an aggregate throughput of 99.62 Gbps.
  • Abundance of Keys: A common misconception is that QKD is too slow. The trial achieved an average SKR of 7.4 kbps (roughly 29 AES-256 keys per second). With a key refresh rate of 120 seconds, the system only consumed 0.03% to 0.3% of the available keys, leaving massive overhead for even more frequent re-keying.

Key Results

  • Throughput: Achieved a maximum of 80 Gbps for a single VPN tunnel and 99.62 Gbps aggregate for a 12-tunnel configuration.
  • Stability: Maintained continuous operation for 45 days with an average QBER of 0.8% and optical visibility of 98.6%, proving the system can handle the environmental noise of deployed metropolitan fiber.
  • Reliability: During a 24-hour stress test, the system moved 15 Petabits (Pb) of data with a packet drop rate of less than $2 \times 10^{-7}$.
  • Performance Impact: The 120-second key refresh cycle had zero measurable impact on tunnel connectivity or data throughput.

Limitations and Future Work

While successful, the authors note several areas for further development:

  • Fiber Efficiency: The current setup used multiple dedicated fiber pairs for quantum, service, and data channels. Future work will explore DWDM (Dense Wavelength Division Multiplexing) to multiplex all these channels onto a single fiber pair.
  • Distance: The trial covered 46 km. While the hardware is rated for up to 120 km, real-world signal loss in complex metropolitan networks remains a challenge for longer-distance links without trusted nodes.
  • Hybrid Approaches: The paper suggests exploring the combination of QKD with Post-Quantum Cryptography (PQC) algorithms to provide a "belt and braces" approach to quantum security.

Summary updated

Abstract

We demonstrated for the first time quantum-safe high-speed 100 Gbps site-to-site IPsec tunnels secured using Quantum Key Distribution (QKD) technology. The demonstration was conducted between two JPMorgan Chase Data Centers (DCs) in an air-gapped environment over 46 km of deployed telecom fiber across Singapore achieving 45 days of continuous operation. Two different Virtual Private Network (VPN) tunnel configurations were tested: (1) a QKD-secured VPN tunnel configuration with a maximum throughput of 80 Gbps and (2) a multi-VPN tunnel configuration exhibiting 12 QKD-secured VPN tunnels with a throughput of 8.39 Gbps per tunnel resulting in an aggregated throughput of 99.62 Gbps for all tunnels. For the QKD system performance, we achieved an average Secret Key Rate (SKR) of 7.4 kbps (about 29 AES-256 keys per second), an average Quantum Bit Error Rate (QBER) of 0.8% and an average visibility of 98.6%. We utilized the ETSI-QKD-014 REST-based Application Programming Interface (API) to exchange the QKD generated keys between the key management server in the QKD system and the next-generation firewalls in order to encrypt and decrypt the data. The data was encrypted by the quantum-safe keys using the AES-256-GCM cipher suite with a key refresh rate of 120 seconds without affecting the VPN tunnel connectivity and performance
BibTeX
@misc{alia2024gbps,
  author = {Obada Alia and Albert S. Huang and Huan Luo and Omar Amer and Marco Pistoia and Charles Ci Wen Lim},
  title = {{100 Gbps Quantum-safe IPsec VPN Tunnels over 46 km Deployed Fiber}},
  year = {2024},
  eprint = {2405.04415},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2405.04415},
}
Figure