University Internationalization Trajectories in China and Spain: A Comparative Case Study Based on the Triple Helix Model

Xiaotong Zhang, Isabel Gómez BarretoIntechOpen 2025 · DOI · OpenAlex

TL;DR

This paper compares the centralized, state-led internationalization of Chinese universities with the horizontal, autonomous model used in Spain. By analyzing these through the "Triple Helix" lens, the authors identify how China’s massive resource allocation and Spain’s deep European integration can complement each other to move beyond simple student exchanges toward global knowledge co-creation.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In the era of globalization, university internationalization has shifted from a secondary concern to a core strategic pillar for national soft power. However, the "how" varies wildly between regions.

The authors address the gap in understanding how different institutional logics—specifically the "top-down" approach in China versus the "networked" approach in Spain—impact the effectiveness of internationalization. They explore how Chinese universities can transition from being mere "international participants" (sending/receiving students) to "global co-creators of knowledge" by learning from the European multilateral governance model.

Methods

The study employs a Comparative Case Study (CCS) method, which goes beyond simple side-by-side comparisons by using three analytical dimensions:

  • Horizontal: Comparing internationalization strategies and governance across different sites.
  • Vertical: Analyzing how national policies (like China’s "Double First-Class" initiative) are implemented at the local and institutional levels.
  • Trans-scalar: Investigating how policies adapt as they move across national, regional, and institutional boundaries (e.g., the rollout of the Erasmus Programme).

The analysis is grounded in three theoretical frameworks:

  1. Triple Helix Model: Examining the synergy between universities, government, and industry.
  2. Social Capital Theory: Understanding how faculty networks and trust enable international action.
  3. Mode 2 Knowledge Production: Focusing on interdisciplinary, socially-embedded, and problem-solving knowledge.

Datasets

The researchers analyzed a mix of qualitative and quantitative data sources:

  • Policy Documents: Official regulatory texts from the Chinese Ministry of Education and the Spanish Government (e.g., the Organic Law of the University System).
  • Institutional Data: Strategic internationalization plans and language policies from specific "Units of Analysis."
    • China: Peking University, Zhejiang Normal University, and Huazhong Normal University.
  • Spain: University of Barcelona and the Autonomous University of Barcelona.
  • Statistics: International databases and government statistics on student mobility (e.g., 2021–2022 enrollment data).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Centralization vs. Autonomy: China’s model is characterized by vertical governance and concentrated resource allocation. Spain’s model, shaped by the European Higher Education Area (EHEA), relies on horizontal cooperation and high institutional autonomy.
  • The "Synergistic Impulse": While China uses the Triple Helix model to align innovation with state-led logic, Spain uses it to foster more balanced, reciprocal relationships between universities and external actors.
  • Complementary Strengths: China possesses strong implementation capacity and massive financial backing. Spain offers consolidated experience in regional governance, intercultural education, and faculty social capital.
  • Axiological Convergence: Despite different political structures, both systems share fundamental values: educational equity, student-centered learning, and a commitment to "social responsibility" and Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs).

Key Results

  • Mobility Trends: China remains a leading sender of students (over 1 million in 2021), but struggles with host-side integration. Spain has successfully leveraged its linguistic ties to Latin America and the Erasmus program to attract a diverse student body (10.2% of total enrollment), with a significant 28.1% of those in doctoral programs.
  • Standardization: Spain’s integration into the EHEA has created a highly standardized system with mutual degree recognition (ECTS), a level of "soft internationalization" that Chinese universities are still striving to achieve.
  • Faculty Impact: The study finds that Spanish faculty's international experience is a major asset, whereas Chinese universities often face "disparities in faculty language proficiency" that hinder the quality of English-taught programs.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several structural tensions:

  • Academic Inbreeding: In Spain, endogamous recruitment practices can limit the expansion of institutional social capital.
  • Contextual Adaptation: In China, the "top-down" adoption of foreign educational models sometimes lacks the contextual adaptation needed for substantive quality.
  • Future Directions: The paper proposes the creation of a Sino-Spanish bilateral cooperation fund to move from project-based cooperation to institutionalized collaboration. They also suggest developing "China-Spain-Third Country" partnerships in regions like Africa and Southeast Asia to build broader regional alliances.

Summary updated

Abstract

This study conducts a comparative analysis of the internationalization trajectories of universities in China and Spain from institutional, policy, and multilevel governance perspectives. Drawing on the Triple Helix model as a theoretical framework, it examines structural differences among universities, governments, and enterprises, explores the construction of scientific cooperation networks, and analyzes the divergent and convergent logics of knowledge production. The findings show that China’s internationalization model is characterized by centralized planning, vertical governance, and concentrated resource allocation. In contrast, Spain’s model, shaped by European governance structures, is based on horizontal and multilateral cooperation. In areas such as educational quality, value-based education, and transnational cooperation mechanisms, the two systems demonstrate notable complementarity. To support the transformation of Chinese universities from “international participants” to “global co-creators of knowledge,” the study proposes several policy recommendations. These include strengthening quality assurance systems, establishing multilateral Sino-European cooperation platforms, enhancing faculty international competence, and developing mechanisms to support cultural adaptation. The study aims to provide both practical guidance and theoretical foundations to promote high-quality internationalization in Chinese higher education.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2025university,
  author = {Xiaotong Zhang and Isabel Gómez Barreto},
  title = {{University Internationalization Trajectories in China and Spain: A Comparative Case Study Based on the Triple Helix Model}},
  booktitle = {IntechOpen},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.5772/intechopen.1012400},
}
Figure