Abstract
The ovoid object suspended in Piero della Francesca’s Montefeltro Altarpiece has been the subject of controversial debate for decades. This paper argues that the object is an ostrich egg (or imitation) serving as an "admonitory example" (exempel). This identification is supported by contemporary visual evidence and interpretations found in the Rationale Divinorum Officorum and late versions of the Physiologus. The allegorical significance of ostrich eggs was widely recognized across the Mediterranean—among Coptic, Armenian, Greek Orthodox, and Latin Christians, as well as in Islamic contexts. Often associated with lamps, these eggs served as a visual metaphor for the relationship between the believer and God, reminding the faithful to remain vigilant in their devotion.
Introduction
For over a century, art historians have grappled with the identity and meaning of the white ovoid object suspended from a shell-shaped apse in Piero della Francesca’s 15th-century masterpiece, the Montefeltro Altarpiece. Speculative theories have identified it as everything from a giant pearl to the mythological egg of Leda or a symbol of the Virgin Birth. However, by situating the work within its broader Mediterranean and medieval context, we can identify the object as an ostrich egg serving a specific spiritual function.
Comparative Iconography and Methodology
To decode the symbol, this study employs iconographic analysis and comparative historical research. Rather than viewing the painting in isolation, we must examine contemporary visual evidence where similar suspended ovoids appear in sacred spaces. This practice was not unique to Piero; it was a widespread Mediterranean custom found in Coptic, Armenian, and Greek Orthodox traditions, often integrated into church lighting fixtures.
By analyzing primary literary sources—such as Giulielmus Durantis’s 13th-century Rationale Divinorum Officorum and the Physiologus—we find that the ostrich egg carried a specific allegorical "language" that had become obscured by the modern era.
The "Forgetful Ostrich" Metaphor
Medieval lore, popularized by the Physiologus, claimed that the ostrich would forget its eggs in the sand, only remembering to return to them when it saw a specific star. This narrative served as a powerful allegory for humanity: just as the ostrich returns to its offspring when illuminated by a star, the sinner—forsaken by God due to sin—returns to the faith when illuminated by divine grace.
The egg functioned as a mirabilia (a rare wonder) intended to draw the viewer’s attention and then serve as a visual "wake-up call." In the Montefeltro Altarpiece, the egg acts as a pointed analogy to the congregation of saints and the donor, Federico da Montefeltro. Just as these figures are frozen in prayerful attention toward the Christ child, the egg serves as a perpetual call to the viewer to "always heed God."
Conclusion
The evidence strongly suggests that the object is definitively an ostrich egg (or a high-quality marble imitation). Piero della Francesca intentionally simplified the depiction, stripping away the metal mountings usually seen in real-world examples to emphasize the pure symbolic form. This "admonitory" meaning is more historically supported than the popular "symbol of virginity" theory, as contemporary 15th-century evidence linking ostrich eggs specifically to Mary’s purity is lacking. Instead, the egg remains a universal Mediterranean symbol of spiritual vigilance and divine grace.
Summary updated