The Consistency Between Sustainable Development Ability and Comprehensive Quality of Higher Vocational Students Based on Survey Research

Bin Yang, Yan Zhao, Zhimei WangAtlantis 2022 · DOI · OpenAlex

Abstract

Traditional metrics like initial employment rates often fail to capture the long-term career viability of higher vocational students. This study investigates the "sustainable development ability" of graduates through surveys of 71 HR managers and 25 teachers, alongside a longitudinal study of 46 engineering interns. Findings reveal a significant mismatch: while students possess technical skills, a lack of "comprehensive quality"—including communication and learning ability—leads to high turnover. Nearly 39% of interns changed jobs within four months, primarily due to unmet expectations. The research advocates for a "whole person" educational model that balances technical training with soft skill development.

The Illusion of Initial Employment

In higher vocational education, success is frequently measured by how quickly graduates find their first job. However, this "initial employment rate" is a shallow metric. It ignores whether students have the resilience and professional loyalty to sustain a career. This paper addresses the gap between technical proficiency and "sustainable development ability"—the capacity for long-term growth and stability in the modern workplace.

High Turnover and the Expectation Gap

A critical finding of the study is the high rate of "career transfer" during internships. In a tracking study of 46 construction engineering students, nearly 39% changed their internship units within just 120 days.

Distribution of internship turnover timing, showing a peak in the third month.

The primary driver for this turnover is an expectation gap: 88% of students who left did so because the job did not meet their initial expectations. This suggests that vocational training lacks sufficient career counseling and realistic previews of workplace demands.

The Employer’s Perspective: A Call for Soft Skills

Enterprises are increasingly dissatisfied with the "sustainable development ability" of vocational graduates. Survey data indicates that 81% of enterprises find these abilities weak, specifically citing deficits in learning ability, communication, and language expression.

Survey results indicating a strong consensus (83.87%) on the lack of sustainable development readiness among graduates.

Furthermore, 68% of enterprises believe there is a direct link between a student's sustainable development and the cultivation of "comprehensive quality" (soft skills) during their schooling. Strikingly, 40% of employers suggest that the curriculum should prioritize these soft skills over technical theory in a 6:4 ratio.

Conclusion: Shaping the "Whole Person"

The current "technician factory" model of vocational education is insufficient for the needs of modern industry. To improve the matching degree between student ability and enterprise needs, colleges must shift toward a "complete personality" or "whole person" philosophy. This involves integrating humanistic quality, career planning, and communication skills into the core technical curriculum, ensuring graduates are not just ready for their first day, but for their entire career.

Limitations

The study's primary limitation is its specific scope, focusing on 46 students in a single major at one college. Additionally, "comprehensive quality" remains a broad concept that requires more granular definition in future research to create standardized measurement metrics.

Summary updated

Abstract

The initial employment of students in higher vocational colleges is good, but the short-term employment situation and employment data can not fully characterize the employment quality and students' sustainable development ability.Through the investigation and research based on the current situation of Higher Vocational Students' sustainable development ability among 71 enterprise human resource managers and 25 professional teachers, the results show that the post change rate of higher vocational students is high during the internship, and 88% of students change their internship units based on the fact that the post expectation value can not meet their own expectations, nearly 68% of enterprises believe that there is a direct and close relationship between the sustainable development ability of higher vocational students and the cultivation of comprehensive quality in school.81% of enterprises believe that the sustainable development ability of higher vocational students is weak and their comprehensive quality, such as learning ability, communication ability and language expression ability, is poor, Nearly 72% of enterprises believe that higher vocational colleges should improve the comprehensive quality of college students during school, of which 40% believe that the proportion of comprehensive quality improvement and professional knowledge learning should be at least 6:4.The matching degree between the current situation of sustainable development of higher vocational students and the employment needs of enterprises is low.It is urgent for higher vocational colleges to start from multiple dimensions and take the cultivation of students' "complete personality" and the shaping of "whole person" as the work guide of education, so as to further improve students' sustainable development ability to meet the needs of enterprises.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{yang2022consistency,
  author = {Bin Yang and Yan Zhao and Zhimei Wang},
  title = {{The Consistency Between Sustainable Development Ability and Comprehensive Quality of Higher Vocational Students Based on Survey Research}},
  booktitle = {Atlantis},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.2991/978-94-6463-044-2\_121},
}
Figure