RETRACTED ARTICLE: Innovation performance of listed companies based on machine computing and data envelopment analysis

Xuan SongJournal of Ambient Intelligence and Humanized Computing 2021 · DOI · OpenAlex

Overview

The article titled "Innovation performance of listed companies based on machine computing and data envelopment analysis," originally published in the Journal of Ambient Intelligence and Humanized Computing, has been formally retracted. This case serves as a significant example of the systemic vulnerabilities within the academic publishing pipeline, particularly regarding guest-edited special issues.

The Original Research Scope

The retracted study aimed to evaluate the innovation performance of publicly listed companies. Measuring innovation is a complex task in economics and management due to the significant time lag between research and development (R&D) investments and measurable outcomes.

The paper proposed a hybrid methodology:

  • Data Envelopment Analysis (DEA): A non-parametric operations research method used to estimate production frontiers and measure the efficiency of decision-making units.
  • Machine Computing: Algorithmic data processing intended to enhance the traditional DEA model.

While the title suggests a robust framework for quantifying corporate efficiency, the retraction has rendered the specific findings and model architectures scientifically void.

Circumstances of the Retraction

Following an investigation by the publisher, the Editor-in-Chief retracted the article due to a fundamental breakdown in the editorial process. The investigation revealed several critical issues:

  1. Manipulated Peer Review: The peer-review process was found to be compromised, suggesting that the evaluations were not conducted by independent, qualified experts.
  2. Third-Party Interference: The editorial integrity of the guest-edited issue was compromised by a third party, a phenomenon often associated with "paper mills" that exploit special issues to publish unverified content.
  3. Loss of Confidence: Due to these procedural failures, the publisher stated they no longer have confidence in the results and conclusions of the work.

Implications for Scholarly Publishing

This retraction highlights the "Guest-Editor Vulnerability." While special issues allow for focused exploration of niche topics, they can also provide a point of entry for bad actors if oversight is insufficient. The manipulation of peer review undermines the foundation of scientific trust.

For the research community, this case emphasizes the need for increased transparency and rigorous auditing of guest-edited content. Although the original text remains available as "Supplementary Information" for the public record, it is no longer considered a valid contribution to the field of innovation metrics or machine computing. Future research in this domain must ensure that the intersection of DEA and machine learning is explored through verified, high-integrity channels.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{song2021retracted,
  author = {Xuan Song},
  title = {{RETRACTED ARTICLE: Innovation performance of listed companies based on machine computing and data envelopment analysis}},
  journal = {Journal of Ambient Intelligence and Humanized Computing},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1007/s12652-021-03056-5},
}
Figure