Progressive collapse behavior of RC frames subjected to reinforcement corrosion

Ding Li, Yongbo Peng, Jianbing ChenOpenalex Unknown 2023 · DOI · OpenAlex

Abstract

Ageing reinforced concrete (RC) structures were observed to be much more vulnerable to progressive collapse than newly constructed ones. Deterioration due to severe reinforcement corrosion can significantly affect progressive collapse resistances of the RC structures. Hence, this contribution aims at numerically investigating the progressive collapse behavior of the deteriorated RC frame structures subjected to uniform reinforcement corrosion. Both static and dynamic progressive collapse analyses in relation to a deteriorated RC frame subjected to a middle column removal scenario are carried out. It is observed that both static and dynamic progressive collapse resistances significantly decrease with increasing corrosion level. The reinforcement corrosion is found to be the predominant cause to the deterioration of the progressive collapse resistances, while the effect of concrete deterioration has limited influence. Reinforcement corrosion in the beams in the bays directly above the removed column controls the structural progressive collapse performance, while the reinforcement corrosion in other locations has little influence. The dynamic resistances are found to decrease larger in percentage than the static resistances with increasing corrosion level.

Introduction

Progressive collapse occurs when a local failure—such as a column destroyed by an explosion or vehicle impact—leads to a chain reaction of failures that results in the collapse of the entire structure. While modern engineering codes provide guidelines for designing new buildings to resist such events, a significant knowledge gap exists regarding aging infrastructure.

As RC structures age, they suffer from reinforcement corrosion due to chloride penetration or carbonation. This process reduces the steel's cross-sectional area, saps its ductility, and causes the surrounding concrete to crack and spall. This study quantifies how these deterioration mechanisms reduce a building's "residual strength"—its ability to remain stable after a column is suddenly removed.

Methodology

The researchers employed a numerical approach using the OpenSees software framework to model a 5-story, 4-bay RC frame. The structure was modeled using fiber beam-column elements, representing the distinct properties of the steel rebar, the cover concrete (prone to spalling), and the core concrete (confined by stirrups).

Deterioration Integration

Unlike standard models, the simulation integrated empirical formulas for:

  • Steel: Reduction in cross-sectional area and an exponential model for loss of ductility.
  • Concrete: The modified Kent-Park model was used to account for how corroded transverse reinforcement (stirrups) provides less confinement to the concrete core.

The study performed both Nonlinear Static Pushdown and Incremental Dynamic Analysis (IDA) to compare structural behavior under different loading rates. The numerical model was validated against a 1/3-scale, 3-story, 4-bay RC frame from a landmark 2008 experimental study by Yi et al.

Key Insights and Ideas

The "Bottleneck" Beams

A critical finding is that corrosion is not equally dangerous everywhere. The researchers categorized the frame into the Directly Affected Part (DAP)—the beams in the bays directly above the removed column—and the Indirectly Affected Part (IAP).

Schematic of the RC frame showing the Directly Affected Part (DAP) and Indirectly Affected Part (IAP) relative to the removed column C.

Corrosion in the DAP almost entirely controls the collapse resistance. Conversely, corrosion in the IAP has a negligible impact on the collapse threshold. This suggests that maintenance and retrofitting efforts should prioritize these critical structural "bottlenecks."

Steel as the Primary Driver

While concrete cracking and spalling are visually dramatic, the reduction in the steel reinforcement's cross-sectional area is the predominant cause of the loss in collapse resistance. The study found that the contribution of concrete deterioration to the overall loss of resistance is relatively limited compared to the impact of rebar thinning.

Key Results

Resistance Drop and Sensitivity

Both static and dynamic collapse resistances significantly decrease as the corrosion level (percentage of area loss) increases from 0% to 60%. The sensitivity analysis confirmed that a scenario where only the beams in the DAP were corroded yielded nearly identical results to a scenario where the entire building was corroded.

Structural resistance vs. corrosion level, highlighting that rebar corrosion is the primary driver of strength loss compared to concrete deterioration.

Dynamic vs. Static Penalty

Sudden column loss creates dynamic oscillations. The study found that as corrosion levels increase, the dynamic resistance decreases faster (percentage-wise) than the static resistance. This suggests that static analysis—often used for simplicity in engineering—may dangerously overestimate the safety of aging buildings. Furthermore, corrosion makes the building more "brittle," with the ultimate displacement (the amount the building can sag before failure) dropping significantly as corrosion progresses.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several simplifications for future research:

  • Uniform vs. Pitting Corrosion: This study assumed uniform corrosion. Future work should incorporate "pitting" corrosion (localized deep holes), which is often more destructive.
  • Bond-Slip Behavior: The model assumes perfect bonding between steel and concrete. In reality, corrosion destroys this grip, likely further reducing structural strength.
  • Coupling Effects: More work is needed to understand the complex interaction between corrosion rates and the dynamic amplification factors used in engineering practice.

Summary updated

Abstract

Ageing reinforced concrete (RC) structures were observed to be much more vulnerable to progressive collapse than newly constructed ones. Deterioration due to severe reinforcement corrosion can significantly affect progressive collapse resistances of the RC structures. Hence, this contribution aims at numerically investigating the progressive collapse behavior of the deteriorated RC frame structures subjected to uniform reinforcement corrosion. Both static and dynamic progressive collapse analyses in relation to a deteriorated RC frame subjected to a middle column removal scenario are carried out. It is observed that both static and dynamic progressive collapse resistances significantly decrease with increasing corrosion level. The reinforcement corrosion is found to be the predominant cause to the deterioration of the progressive collapse resistances, while the effect of concrete deterioration has limited influence. Reinforcement corrosion in the beams in the bays directly above the removed column controls the structural progressive collapse performance, while the reinforcement corrosion in other locations has little influence. The dynamic resistances are found to decrease larger in percentage than the static resistances with increasing corrosion level.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2023progressive,
  author = {Ding Li and Yongbo Peng and Jianbing Chen},
  title = {{Progressive collapse behavior of RC frames subjected to reinforcement corrosion}},
  booktitle = {Openalex Unknown},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1201/9781003323020-463},
}
Figure