Correction: Genome-wide gene-environment analyses of major depressive disorder and reported lifetime traumatic experiences in UK Biobank

Jonathan R. I. Coleman, Wouter J. Peyrot, Kirstin L. Purves, Katrina A. S. Davis, Christopher Rayner, Shing Wan Choi, Christopher Hübel, Héléna A. Gaspar, Carol Kan, Sandra Van der Auwera, Mark J. Adams, Donald M. Lyall, Karmel W. Choi, Naomi R. Wray, Stephan Ripke, Manuel Mattheisen, Maciej Trzaskowski, Enda M. Byrne, Abdel Abdellaoui, Esben Agerbo, Tracy Air, Till F. M. Andlauer, Silviu‐Alin Bacanu, Marie Bækvad‐Hansen, Aartjan T.f. Beekman, Tim B. Bigdeli, Elisabeth B. Binder, Julien Bryois, Henriette N. Buttenschøn, Jonas Bybjerg‐Grauholm, Na Cai, Enrique Castelao, Jane Christensen, Toni‐Kim Clarke, Lucía Colodro‐Conde, Baptiste Couvy‐Duchesne, Nick Craddock, Gregory E. Crawford, Gail Davies, Ian J. Deary, Franziska Degenhardt, Eske M. Derks, Neşe Direk, Conor V. Dolan, Erin C. Dunn, Thalia C. Eley, Valentina Escott‐Price, Farnush Farhadi Hassan Kiadeh, Hilary K. Finucane, Jerome C. Foo, Andreas J. Forstner, Josef Frank, Michael Gill, Fernando S. Goes, Scott D. Gordon, Jakob Grove, Lynsey S. Hall, Christine Søholm Hansen, Thomas Folkmann Hansen, Stefan Herms, Ian B. Hickie, Per Hoffmann, Georg Homuth, Carsten Horn, Jouke‐Jan Hottenga, David M. Hougaard, David M. Howard, Marcus Ising, Philip R. Jansen, Ian Jones, Lisa Jones, Eric Jorgenson, James A. Knowles, Isaac S. Kohane, Julia Kraft, Warren W. Kretzschmar, Zoltán Kutalik, Yihan Li, Penelope A. Lind, Donald J. MacIntyre, Dean F. MacKinnon, Robert Maier, Wolfgang Maier, Jonathan Marchini, Hamdi Mbarek, Patrick J. McGrath, Peter McGuffin, Sarah E. Medland, Divya Mehta, Christel M. Middeldorp, Evelin Mihailov, Yuri Milaneschi, Lili Milani, Francis M. Mondimore, Grant W. Montgomery, Sara Mostafavi, Niamh MullinsMolecular 2020 · DOI · OpenAlex

Introduction

In early 2020, a high-impact study was published in Molecular Psychiatry investigating the complex interplay between genetic predispositions and environmental stressors—specifically lifetime trauma—in the development of Major Depressive Disorder (MDD). Utilizing the massive UK Biobank dataset, the research aimed to identify how specific genetic variants might influence an individual's resilience or vulnerability to psychological trauma. Recently, the authors issued a formal correction to address a reporting error in the study's supplementary materials regarding the classification of the control group.

The Nature of the Correction

The correction pertains to the phenotyping criteria described in Supplementary Table 1 of the original paper. The study employed a summed response scale to assess recent depressive symptoms among participants, where individual items were scored from 1 ("Not at all") to 4 ("Nearly every day").

The original text incorrectly stated that participants were included in the control group if their summed response score was less than 14. The corrected text clarifies that the actual, more stringent threshold used during the analysis was a summed response score of less than 5.

Phenotypic Stringency in Control Selection

In large-scale Genome-Wide Association Studies (GWAS) and Gene-Environment (GxE) analyses, the "cleanliness" of the control group is paramount. To isolate the genetic signals associated with a disorder like MDD, researchers must compare affected individuals against a control group that is truly asymptomatic.

  • The Threshold Shift: A threshold of 14 on the summed scale would have allowed for the inclusion of individuals with a significant accumulation of "mild" symptoms or several "severe" symptoms.
  • Why it Matters: By using a threshold of 5, the researchers ensured that the control group consisted only of individuals reporting almost no recent depressive symptoms. This restrictive criterion creates a much sharper contrast between MDD cases and healthy controls, which is necessary to detect the subtle interactions between polygenic risk and environmental factors.

Impact on Study Findings

The authors have confirmed that this reporting error was limited to the description in the supplementary materials and does not alter the primary findings or the statistical significance of the genome-wide analyses reported in the original paper. The correction serves to align the published methodology with the actual computational steps taken during the study, ensuring the integrity of the research record.

Conclusion

While the scientific conclusions of the study remain unchanged, this correction highlights the critical importance of precise phenotyping in psychiatric genetics. Defining what constitutes a "control" is often as complex as defining a "case." Future researchers utilizing the UK Biobank for depression studies should note this stricter threshold (<5) as a benchmark for defining highly asymptomatic control groups in genetic association studies.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{coleman2020correction,
  author = {Jonathan R. I. Coleman and Wouter J. Peyrot and Kirstin L. Purves and Katrina A. S. Davis and Christopher Rayner and Shing Wan Choi and Christopher Hübel and Héléna A. Gaspar and Carol Kan and Sandra Van der Auwera and Mark J. Adams and Donald M. Lyall and Karmel W. Choi and Naomi R. Wray and Stephan Ripke and Manuel Mattheisen and Maciej Trzaskowski and Enda M. Byrne and Abdel Abdellaoui and Mark J. Adams and Esben Agerbo and Tracy Air and Till F. M. Andlauer and Silviu‐Alin Bacanu and Marie Bækvad‐Hansen and Aartjan T.F. Beekman and Tim B. Bigdeli and Elisabeth B. Binder and Julien Bryois and Henriette N. Buttenschøn and Jonas Bybjerg‐Grauholm and Na Cai and Enrique Castelao and Jane Christensen and Toni‐Kim Clarke and Jonathan R. I. Coleman and Lucía Colodro‐Conde and Baptiste Couvy‐Duchesne and Nick Craddock and Gregory E. Crawford and Gail Davies and Ian J. Deary and Franziska Degenhardt and Eske M. Derks and Neşe Direk and Conor V. Dolan and Erin C. Dunn and Thalia C. Eley and Valentina Escott‐Price and Farnush Farhadi Hassan Kiadeh and Hilary K. Finucane and Jerome C. Foo and Andreas J. Forstner and Josef Frank and Héléna A. Gaspar and Michael Gill and Fernando S. Goes and Scott D. Gordon and Jakob Grove and Lynsey S. Hall and Christine Søholm Hansen and Thomas Folkmann Hansen and Stefan Herms and Ian B. Hickie and Per Hoffmann and Georg Homuth and Carsten Horn and Jouke‐Jan Hottenga and David M. Hougaard and David M. Howard and Marcus Ising and Philip R. Jansen and Ian Jones and Lisa Jones and Eric Jorgenson and James A. Knowles and Isaac S. Kohane and Julia Kraft and Warren W. Kretzschmar and Zoltán Kutalik and Yihan Li and Penelope A. Lind and Donald J. MacIntyre and Dean F. MacKinnon and Robert Maier and Wolfgang Maier and Jonathan Marchini and Hamdi Mbarek and Patrick J. McGrath and Peter McGuffin and Sarah E. Medland and Divya Mehta and Christel M. Middeldorp and Evelin Mihailov and Yuri Milaneschi and Lili Milani and Francis M. Mondimore and Grant W. Montgomery and Sara Mostafavi and Niamh Mullins},
  title = {{Correction: Genome-wide gene-environment analyses of major depressive disorder and reported lifetime traumatic experiences in UK Biobank}},
  booktitle = {Molecular},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1038/s41380-020-0779-4},
}
Figure