Author Correction: Differential chromatin accessibility in peripheral blood mononuclear cells underlies COVID-19 disease severity prior to seroconversion

Nicholas Giroux, Shengli Ding, Micah T. McClain, Thomas W. Burke, Elizabeth Petzold, Hong A. Chung, Grecia O. Rivera, Ergang Wang, Rui Xi, Shree Bose, Tomer Rotstein, Bradly P. Nicholson, Tianyi Chen, Ricardo Henao, Gregory D. Sempowski, Thomas N. Denny, Maria Iglesias De Ussel, Lisa L. Satterwhite, Emily R. Ko, Geoffrey S. Ginsburg, Bryan Kraft, Ephraim L. Tsalik, Xiling Shen, Christopher W. WoodsScientific 2023 · DOI · OpenAlex

Introduction

In July 2022, a study published in Scientific Reports investigated the epigenetic signatures of COVID-19, specifically how chromatin accessibility in immune cells could predict disease severity before the development of a detectable antibody response. Recently, the authors issued a formal correction to address a data omission in the "mild" disease cohort. This update ensures the integrity of the published record and reinforces the original study's findings.

The Correction: Addressing Data Integrity

The primary focus of this correction is the accidental exclusion of one participant (Alias ID: 7085CA) from the bulk analysis of the mild COVID-19 group. In clinical research with small cohort sizes, the inclusion of every data point is vital for statistical accuracy. The participant, a White, Non-Hispanic individual, has now been integrated into the primary analysis and Supplementary Table S1.

Methods and Cohort Categorization

The study utilized two primary approaches to examine immune cells: Bulk PBMC Assays, which analyze the collective chromatin state of the entire mononuclear cell population, and Single-Cell PBMC Assays, which provide a granular view of individual cell responses.

Participants were categorized into three groups based on the World Health Organization (WHO) Ordinal 8-point scale:

  1. Close Contacts: Individuals exposed to the virus but not necessarily infected, serving as the control group.
  2. Mild COVID-19: Subjects with minor symptoms, primarily ambulatory patients with no limitation of activities (WHO OS1).
  3. Moderate COVID-19: Subjects with more pronounced clinical symptoms requiring medical attention.

Updated Clinical Metrics and Results

The inclusion of the eighth participant in the mild disease cohort led to minor adjustments in the group's descriptive statistics:

  • Cohort Size: The "Mild disease" group for bulk analysis increased from 7 to 8 subjects.
  • Demographics: The sex distribution adjusted from 4 male / 3 female to 5 male / 3 female.
  • Severity Scores: The mean maximum severity score shifted slightly from 12.9 ± 2.1 to 12.8 ± 1.9.
Updated clinical data showing participant distribution by symptom severity sum (A, C) and individual symptom severity scores (B, D) for the study cohorts.

As shown in the updated figures, the distribution of symptom severity remains consistent across the groups. The shift in the mean severity score was minimal (0.1), suggesting that the original study's conclusions regarding the link between chromatin accessibility in peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMCs) and disease severity are robust and not overly sensitive to individual outliers.

Stability of the Findings

Despite the clerical error in data entry, the core biological insights of the research remain unchanged. The "openness" of DNA in immune cells continues to serve as a reliable marker for predicting how severely a patient will experience COVID-19. This correction highlights the self-correcting nature of science and the importance of precise clinical phenotyping in longitudinal studies.

Conclusion

By transparently updating the clinical data and figures, the authors maintain the reproducibility and reliability of the scientific record. The stability of the results following the inclusion of the omitted data point further validates the epigenetic patterns identified as key indicators of COVID-19 disease progression.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{giroux2023author,
  author = {Nicholas Giroux and Shengli Ding and Micah T. McClain and Thomas W. Burke and Elizabeth Petzold and Hong A. Chung and Grecia O. Rivera and Ergang Wang and Rui Xi and Shree Bose and Tomer Rotstein and Bradly P. Nicholson and Tianyi Chen and Ricardo Henao and Gregory D. Sempowski and Thomas N. Denny and Maria Iglesias De Ussel and Lisa L. Satterwhite and Emily R. Ko and Geoffrey S. Ginsburg and Bryan Kraft and Ephraim L. Tsalik and Xiling Shen and Christopher W. Woods},
  title = {{Author Correction: Differential chromatin accessibility in peripheral blood mononuclear cells underlies COVID-19 disease severity prior to seroconversion}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-023-33323-8},
}
Figure