Abstract
As China is the largest developing country in the world and is still in the primary stage of socialism, electricity pricing reform should take into account that electricity should be affordable and that it brings economic and social benefits. Electricity prices should therefore be controlled within a reasonable range, preventing prices that are too low from hindering the use of new energy and avoiding prices that are too high from negatively impacting public services and the competitiveness of the economy.
Introduction
China's power sector is currently undergoing a massive transformation to accommodate a surge in renewable energy sources like wind and solar. However, the existing electricity pricing mechanisms, largely inherited from a coal-dominant era, are fundamentally misaligned with the requirements of a modern green grid. To achieve its "dual-carbon" goals, China must overhaul its pricing structures to properly value energy storage, eliminate market-distorting cross-subsidies, and implement dynamic market-based signals.
Historical Evolution of Pricing Mechanisms
The transition of China's electricity pricing reflects the broader economic shifts of the nation. The system has evolved through several distinct phases, moving from a fully regulated state-controlled model toward the current push for market liberalization.
As illustrated in the timeline above, the early periods (1949–1985) focused on stabilization and supply security. Subsequent reforms in the late 20th century aimed to encourage investment to meet growing demand. By the early 2000s, benchmark pricing was introduced to support the development of renewable energy. Since 2016, the focus has shifted toward a comprehensive market reform intended to transition from grid delivery pricing to a fully market-based system.
Core Challenges in the Green Transition
The current pricing framework faces four primary challenges that complicate the integration of intermittent renewables:
- The Zero Marginal Cost Dilemma: Wind and solar projects have high upfront capital costs but near-zero marginal operating costs. Traditional pricing models fail to ensure investment recovery for these assets without unsustainable government subsidies.
- The Changing Role of Thermal Power: As renewables take priority, coal-fired plants are transitioning from baseload providers to flexible peak-load backups. Current pricing does not adequately compensate them for providing this standby capacity, leading to financial instability as their operating hours decline.
- Valuing Grid Stability: The intermittency of renewables necessitates massive energy storage and ancillary services (such as frequency regulation). Currently, there is no clear market mechanism to pay storage providers for these essential stability services.
- The Cross-Subsidy Anomaly: In China, industrial and commercial users heavily subsidize residential and agricultural electricity. Globally, residential prices are typically 1.5 times higher than industrial prices; in China, they are only 85%. This distorts market signals and impacts industrial competitiveness.
Strategic Policy Recommendations
To address these misalignments, the authors propose several key structural reforms:
- Implementation of Two-Part Tariffs: The paper advocates for a combination of capacity-based and energy-based pricing for pumped storage, gas-fired peaking plants, and industrial users. This ensures fixed costs are recovered even when energy generation is low.
- Dynamic Time-of-Use (ToU) Pricing: Current peak/off-peak price differences are often too small to incentivize load shifting. Widening this gap and using data-driven clustering to define peak hours can better reflect real-time grid conditions.
- Decoupling Transmission from Generation: A vital step is treating grid companies strictly as transmission and distribution service providers, charging a "wheeling fee" based on voltage and distance rather than profiting from the spread between generation and retail prices.
- Refined Tiered Residential Pricing: To protect vulnerable populations while encouraging conservation, a 3-tier system is recommended: Tier 1 as a subsidized "lifeline," Tier 2 covering actual costs, and Tier 3 at a premium to reflect resource scarcity.
Conclusion and Future Directions
The transition to a market-oriented electricity system is essential for China's sustainable energy future. Future work must focus on accelerating the rollout of electricity spot markets, linking green electricity certificates directly with carbon trading systems, and developing pricing models to incentivize virtual power plants (VPPs) and microgrids. While technical and social hurdles remain, particularly regarding the valuation of storage and the unwinding of cross-subsidies, these reforms are critical for a resilient and efficient power system.
Summary updated