Author’s Response to Letter to the Editor: Noninvasive Intracranial Pressure Assessment in Acute Liver Failure

Venkatakrishna Rajajee, Craig A. Williamson, Robert J. Fontana, Anthony J. Courey, Parag G. PatilNeurocritical 2019 · DOI · OpenAlex

Introduction

Monitoring intracranial pressure (ICP) is a critical component of managing patients with Acute Liver Failure (ALF), where cerebral edema can lead to life-threatening neurological complications. However, the "gold standard" for ICP monitoring—invasive intracranial probes—carries a significant risk of hemorrhage in ALF patients due to underlying coagulopathy. This clinical dilemma has spurred interest in non-invasive alternatives, most notably the measurement of Optic Nerve Sheath Diameter (ONSD) via ocular ultrasound. In a recent correspondence, Venkatakrishna Rajajee and colleagues address critiques of their previous work, specifically regarding the comparative utility of different ultrasound modalities in this high-stakes environment.

The Challenge of Non-Invasive ICP Monitoring in ALF

The theoretical basis for ONSD measurement lies in the anatomical continuity between the optic nerve sheath and the intracranial subarachnoid space. As ICP rises, cerebrospinal fluid is forced into the sheath, causing it to dilate. While this correlation has been observed in various neurological conditions, Rajajee’s research indicated that ONSD may be an unreliable proxy for ICP specifically within the ALF population.

The debate centers on whether the perceived inaccuracy is a result of the measurement technique or a fundamental physiological difference in how the optic nerve sheath responds to pressure in the setting of systemic liver failure.

Methodological Critique: A-scan vs. B-scan

In response to suggestions that A-scan (Amplitude mode) ultrasound might offer superior precision over the standard B-scan (Brightness mode), the authors highlight several practical and methodological hurdles.

  • B-scan: Provides a two-dimensional cross-sectional image, allowing clinicians to visualize the anatomy of the eye and orbit to ensure correct placement.
  • A-scan: A one-dimensional representation of ultrasound echoes. While potentially more precise for distance measurements in a controlled ophthalmological setting, it lacks the visual "map" provided by B-scans.

The authors argue that ALF patients often present with hepatic encephalopathy, characterized by agitation, confusion, or coma. In such uncooperative patients, the technical demands of obtaining accurate A-scan measurements without visual guidance are substantial.

Clinical Realities and the Necessity of Validation

The authors maintain a rigorous stance on the adoption of new diagnostic techniques. They propose that for any non-invasive method—including A-scan ONSD—to be clinically validated, it must meet a specific research standard:

  1. Simultaneous Measurement: A-scan and B-scan measurements must be taken at the same time.
  2. Gold Standard Comparison: Both ultrasound modalities must be compared directly against concomitant invasive ICP monitoring in the same patient.
  3. Contextual Relevance: Studies must be conducted specifically within the ALF population to account for unique physiological variables.

Without such head-to-head validation, the authors caution that relying on "interesting proposals" or theoretical advantages could lead to dangerous clinical misjudgments.

Conclusion

The quest for a reliable, non-invasive "holy grail" of ICP monitoring continues. However, Rajajee and colleagues emphasize that clinical adoption must follow rigorous scientific proof. Until ocular sonography is validated against invasive probes in the specific context of Acute Liver Failure, it should not be routinely utilized to guide treatment decisions in these critically ill patients. The priority remains patient safety and the avoidance of interventions based on unproven diagnostic proxies.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{rajajee2019authors,
  author = {Venkatakrishna Rajajee and Craig A. Williamson and Robert J. Fontana and Anthony J. Courey and Parag G. Patil},
  title = {{Author’s Response to Letter to the Editor: Noninvasive Intracranial Pressure Assessment in Acute Liver Failure}},
  booktitle = {Neurocritical},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1007/s12028-019-00681-z},
}
Figure