Author response: Beyond Auditory Relay: Dissecting the Inferior Colliculus’s Role in Sensory Prediction, Reward Prediction and Cognitive Decision-Making

Xinyu Du, Haoxuan Xu, Peirun Song, Yuying Zhai, Hangting Ye, Xuehui Bao, Qianyue Huang, Hisashi Tanigawa, Zhiyi Tu, Pei Chen, Xuan Zhao, Josef P. Rauschecker, Xiongjie YuOpenalex Unknown 2025 · DOI · OpenAlex

Abstract

The Inferior Colliculus (IC) has traditionally been regarded as an important relay in the auditory pathway, primarily involved in relaying auditory information from the brainstem to the thalamus. However, this study uncovers the multifaceted role of the IC in bridging auditory processing, sensory prediction, and reward prediction. Through extracellular recordings in monkeys engaged in a sound duration-based deviation detection task, we observed a “climbing effect” in neuronal firing rates, indicative of an enhanced response over sound sequences linked to sensory prediction rather than reward anticipation. Moreover, our findings demonstrate reward prediction errors within the IC, highlighting its complex integration in auditory and reward processing. Further analysis revealed a direct correlation between IC neuronal activity and behavioral choices, suggesting its involvement in decision-making processes. This research highlights a more complex role for the IC than traditionally understood, showcasing its integral role in cognitive and sensory processing and emphasizing its importance in integrated brain functions.

Introduction

In the classical neuroscientific view, sensory processing is strictly hierarchical: lower-level structures like the midbrain handle raw data, while complex cognitive functions—such as prediction, reward evaluation, and decision-making—are reserved for the cerebral cortex. The Inferior Colliculus (IC), a major subcortical nucleus in the auditory pathway, has long been dismissed as a simple "relay station." However, emerging evidence suggests that subcortical structures may be more deeply involved in cognition than previously thought. This study investigates whether the primate IC contributes to predictive coding and decision-making during complex auditory behaviors.

Experimental Paradigm: Duration Deviation Detection

To explore these cognitive functions, researchers performed extracellular single-unit recordings from 104 neurons in two rhesus monkeys (Macaca mulatta). The monkeys were trained on a "duration deviation detection" task, a variation of the oddball paradigm designed to test sensory discrimination and anticipation.

In this task, monkeys listened to a sequence of 3 to 6 "standard" sounds (300ms white noise bursts). The sequence concluded with either another standard sound or a "deviant" sound of longer duration (up to 600ms). If the monkey correctly identified a deviant sound by pressing a button within a 600ms window, it received a water reward. Behavioral data from 69 sessions confirmed that the monkeys' performance followed a standard psychometric curve, with detection probability increasing as the deviant duration lengthened.

The experimental setup and behavioral performance show that monkeys successfully learned to detect duration deviants.

Sensory Prediction and the "Climbing Effect"

A central finding of the study is the "climbing effect": IC neurons did not merely respond to sound onset; their activity ramped up both within a single sound and across the sequence of standard sounds. This ramping activity was quantified using a Response Dynamic Index (RDI).

Crucially, this climbing effect was significantly more pronounced during the behavioral task than during passive listening ($p = 4.40e-19$). This suggests that the ramping activity is not a simple sensory adaptation but a signature of sensory prediction—the brain "gearing up" for the anticipated deviant sound. While the onset response remained stable across the sequence, the late-window activity increased significantly, reflecting an internal model of the expected stimulus timing.

Normalized firing rates demonstrate a significant increase in late-window activity across the sound sequence, indicative of sensory prediction.

Reward Prediction and Decision Signaling

Beyond sensory prediction, the IC appears to integrate reinforcement learning signals. The researchers observed Reward Prediction Error (RPE) signals similar to those found in dopaminergic neurons. IC neurons fired more intensely when a reward was unexpected (at the start of a block) and decreased their response as the reward became predictable ($p = 7.00e-3$).

Furthermore, the study established a direct link between IC activity and behavioral choice. Using Receiver Operating Characteristic (ROC) analysis, the authors found they could predict whether a monkey would press the button based on neuronal firing. The average detection probability (AUC) was 0.56 ($p = 2.57e-4$), with some individual neurons reaching an AUC of 0.86. This indicates that IC activity reflects the monkey's perception of the sound, rather than just the physical properties of the stimulus itself.

Conclusion

These findings challenge the traditional view of the Inferior Colliculus as a passive relay. Instead, the IC emerges as a sophisticated hub that integrates auditory data with predictive models and reward expectations to influence behavioral decisions. While these results are correlational, they provide a strong foundation for future causal studies using techniques like optogenetics to further dissect the subcortical circuits underlying primate cognition.

Summary updated

Abstract

The Inferior Colliculus (IC) has traditionally been regarded as an important relay in the auditory pathway, primarily involved in relaying auditory information from the brainstem to the thalamus. However, this study uncovers the multifaceted role of the IC in bridging auditory processing, sensory prediction, and reward prediction. Through extracellular recordings in monkeys engaged in a sound duration-based deviation detection task, we observed a “climbing effect” in neuronal firing rates, indicative of an enhanced response over sound sequences linked to sensory prediction rather than reward anticipation. Moreover, our findings demonstrate reward prediction errors within the IC, highlighting its complex integration in auditory and reward processing. Further analysis revealed a direct correlation between IC neuronal activity and behavioral choices, suggesting its involvement in decision-making processes. This research highlights a more complex role for the IC than traditionally understood, showcasing its integral role in cognitive and sensory processing and emphasizing its importance in integrated brain functions.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{du2025author,
  author = {Xinyu Du and Haoxuan Xu and Peirun Song and Yuying Zhai and Hangting Ye and Xuehui Bao and Qianyue Huang and Hisashi Tanigawa and Zhiyi Tu and Pei Chen and Xuan Zhao and Josef P. Rauschecker and Xiongjie Yu},
  title = {{Author response: Beyond Auditory Relay: Dissecting the Inferior Colliculus’s Role in Sensory Prediction, Reward Prediction and Cognitive Decision-Making}},
  booktitle = {Openalex Unknown},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.7554/elife.101142.2.sa0},
}
Figure