Abstract
Historically, cognitive processing has been thought to rely on cortical areas such as prefrontal cortex (PFC), with the outputs of these areas modulating activity in lower, putatively simpler spatiomotor regions, such as the midbrain superior colliculus (SC). Using a rat task in which subjects switch rapidly between task contexts that demand changes in sensorimotor mappings, we report a surprising role for the SC in non-spatial cognitive processes. Before spatial response choices could be formed, neurons in SC encoded task context more strongly than neurons in PFC, and bilateral SC silencing impaired behavioral performance. Once spatial choices could begin to be formed, SC neurons encoded the choice faster than PFC, while bilateral SC silencing no longer impaired choices. A set of dynamical models of the SC replicates our findings. Our results challenge cortically-focused views of cognition, and suggest that ostensibly spatiomotor structures can play central roles in non-spatiomotor cognitive processes.
Introduction
In neuroscience, a "cortical-centric" bias often assumes that complex cognitive processing—such as executive function and flexible decision-making—is the exclusive domain of the prefrontal cortex (PFC). In this traditional hierarchy, the PFC acts as a "CEO," sending commands to subcortical structures like the superior colliculus (SC) for motor execution. This study investigates whether the SC is merely a spatiomotor relay or if it actively participates in high-level cognitive flexibility, specifically in the context of sensorimotor routing.
Methods
The researchers trained 19 adult male Long-Evans rats on a Pro/Anti task designed to test flexible sensorimotor routing. Each trial began with an auditory Task Cue signaling the rule: "Pro" (orient toward a subsequent light stimulus) or "Anti" (orient away from the light). A Delay period followed, requiring the rat to maintain the rule in memory before the Stimulus (a light on the left or right) appeared, triggering a Choice.
Neural activity was recorded from 215 SC neurons and 331 PFC neurons. To establish causality, the researchers used optogenetic silencing (eNpHR3.0) to inhibit the SC during specific windows: the task cue, the delay, or the choice phase. Finally, dynamical models were constructed to test if local collicular circuitry could explain the observed neural and behavioral patterns.
Results
The SC as a Rule-Encoder
During the delay period, before any spatial stimulus was presented, SC neurons held significantly more information about the task rule (Pro vs. Anti) than PFC neurons. Decoding accuracy for task context was higher in SC populations than in PFC populations of equivalent size. This indicates that the SC is actively involved in the cognitive planning phase.
Temporal Lead of the SC
Upon stimulus onset, choice-related information (left vs. right) emerged in the SC approximately 200ms faster than in the PFC. Specifically, choice signals were detectable in the SC at ~84ms post-stimulus, compared to ~290ms in the PFC.
Causal Role and Double Dissociation
Optogenetic silencing revealed a critical temporal dissociation. Silencing the SC during the delay period—the non-spatial, cognitive phase—significantly increased error rates on the demanding Anti-task by 10-15%. Conversely, silencing the SC during the choice phase did not impair accuracy, even though the SC contained the earliest choice signals. This suggests the SC's primary contribution is to the cognitive routing of the rule rather than the final motor execution of the choice.
Discussion
These results challenge the traditional view of the brain's hierarchy. The finding that the SC encodes rules more strongly and choices faster than the PFC suggests a distributed model of cognition where "lower" brain regions are central to executive function. Computational modeling further supports this, showing that local SC circuits can implement the logic required to suppress reflexive responses in favor of rule-based actions. Future work is needed to determine if these signals are generated within the SC or inherited from other regions, but the SC's role as a cognitive hub is now firmly established.
Summary updated