Author Correction: Validation of the Sleep Regularity Index in Older Adults and Associations with Cardiometabolic Risk

Jessica R. Lunsford‐Avery, Matthew Engelhard, Ann Marie Návar, Scott H. KollinsScientific 2021 · DOI · OpenAlex

Overview

This article serves as a formal correction to a study originally published in Scientific Reports regarding the Sleep Regularity Index (SRI) in older adults. The correction addresses technical errors in data processing that affected the reported values for sleep timing, physical activity, and light exposure. While the core conclusions of the original research remain valid, these updates provide a more precise quantification of the behavioral differences between regular and irregular sleepers.

The Problem: Data Processing and Unit Errors

The original publication contained systematic errors in the aggregation of actigraphy data. Specifically, two main issues were identified:

  1. Unit Mismatches: "Total Sleep Time" was incorrectly reported in 30-second epochs rather than minutes.
  2. Omitted Data Points: During the calculation of "Sleep in Clock Day," "Sleep in Clock Night," and "Daily Light Exposure," the first 30-second epoch of every hour was inadvertently omitted.

These errors necessitated a re-analysis of the dataset to ensure the scientific record accurately reflects the magnitude of differences in sleep-wake patterns.

Corrected Methodology

The study utilized actigraphy—clinical-grade wearable sensors—to monitor rest and activity cycles. The correction involved re-processing the raw data to:

  • Ensure 30-second epochs were correctly converted into minute-based metrics.
  • Re-integrate the missing first epoch of each hour into the total daily and nightly sums.

Participants were categorized into Irregular and Regular sleepers based on their SRI scores, allowing for a comparative analysis of their physiological and behavioral profiles.

Key Insights: Timing vs. Duration

The corrected data reinforces a critical distinction in sleep research: the difference between sleep quantity and sleep regularity.

  • Total Sleep Duration: There is no statistically significant difference in total sleep time between the two groups (p = 0.604). The primary issue is not how much they sleep, but the consistency of their schedule.
  • The "Shifted" Day: The primary differentiator is when sleep occurs. Irregular sleepers exhibit a significantly higher volume of sleep during the "clock day" and less during the "clock night."
  • Light Exposure: Irregular sleepers receive substantially less bright light (>250 lux). As light is the primary zeitgeber (time-giver) for the human circadian clock, this suggests a feedback loop where reduced light exposure may reinforce irregular sleep patterns.

Quantitative Results

The re-analysis shows that the behavioral gap between irregular and regular sleepers is even more pronounced than initially reported.

Table 2: Corrected Actigraphy and Self-Report Measures for Irregular vs. Regular Sleepers.

Key corrected findings include:

  • Daytime Sleep: Irregular sleepers sleep 66.5 minutes more during the day than regular sleepers (on average).
  • Nighttime Sleep: Irregular sleepers sleep 60.4 minutes less during the night.
  • Light Exposure: Irregular sleepers are exposed to 48.4 fewer minutes of bright light per day.
  • Sleep Midpoint: The midpoint of sleep for irregular sleepers is significantly later (03:36 am) compared to regular sleepers (02:59 am), with a highly significant p-value (< 10⁻⁹).
  • Effect Sizes: The Cohen’s d for "Sleep in Clock Day" is 1.543, indicating a massive effect size and confirming that daytime sleep is a primary differentiator for sleep irregularity.

Conclusion

This correction highlights the importance of data pipeline integrity in high-resolution wearable research. Small errors in epoch aggregation can lead to systematic reporting discrepancies. Despite these numerical adjustments, the fundamental finding remains: irregular sleep patterns in older adults are associated with significant shifts in sleep timing, reduced physical activity, and lower light exposure, all of which are critical factors in cardiometabolic health.

Summary updated

Abstract

As a result, the minute values in the Results' sub-section "Group differences in sleep timing and light exposure" have been corrected. "Specifically, on average, irregular sleepers slept for 65 minutes more during the clock day and 59 minutes less during the clock night compared to regular sleepers. In addition, irregular sleepers tend to be exposed to fewer minutes of light (>250 lux). On average, irregular sleepers were exposed to 48.2 fewer minutes of light per day than regular sleepers. " now reads: "Specifically, on average, irregular sleepers slept for 66.5 minutes more during the clock day and 60.4 minutes less during the clock night compared to regular sleepers. In addition, irregular sleepers tend to be exposed to fewer minutes of light (>250 lux). On average, irregular sleepers were exposed to 48.4 fewer minutes of light per day than regular sleepers.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{lunsfordavery2021author,
  author = {Jessica R. Lunsford‐Avery and Matthew Engelhard and Ann Marie Návar and Scott H. Kollins and Matthew M. Engelhard},
  title = {{Author Correction: Validation of the Sleep Regularity Index in Older Adults and Associations with Cardiometabolic Risk}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-021-03253-4},
}
Figure