Author Correction: Mobilise-D insights to estimate real-world walking speed in multiple conditions with a wearable device
Cameron Kirk, Arne Küderle, M. Encarna Micó-Amigo, Tecla Bonci, Anisoara Paraschiv-Ionescu, Martin Ullrich, Abolfazl Soltani, Eran Gazit, Francesca Salis, Lisa Alcock, Kamiar Aminian, Clemens Becker, Stefano Bertuletti, Philip Brown, Ellen Buckley, Alma Cantu, Anne‐Elie Carsin, Marco Caruso, Brian Caulfield, Andrea Cereatti, Lorenzo Chiari, Ilaria D’Ascanio, Judith García‐Aymerich, Clint Hansen, Jeffrey M. Hausdorff, Hugo Hiden, Emily Hume, Alison Keogh, Felix Kluge, Sarah Koch, Walter Maetzler, Dimitrios Megaritis, Arne Mueller, Martijn Niessen, Luca Palmerini, Lars Schwickert, Kirsty Scott, Basil Sharrack, Henrik Sillén, David Singleton, Beatrix Vereijken, Ioannis Vogiatzis, Alison J. Yarnall, Lynn Rochester, C. Mazzà, Bjoern M. Eskofier, Silvia Del Din, Francesca Bottin, Cristina Curreli, Giorgio Davico, Roberta De Michele, Giuliano Galimberti, Saverio Ranciati, Luca Reggi, Marco Viceconti, Lucia D’Apote, Jules Desmond, Megan Doyle, Mary Elliot-Davey, Gilles Gnacadja, Anja Kassner, Beat Knüsel, Monika Pocrzepa, Nicolas Pourbaix, Hoi-Shen Radcliffe, Lening Shen, Jennifer Simon, Jesper Havsol, Diana Jarretta, Magnus Jörntén‐Karlsson, Pierre Mugnier, Solange Corriol Rohou, Gabriela Luporini Saraiva, Michael Karl Boettger, Igor Knezevic, Frank Kramer, Paolo Piraino, H Trübel, Hajar Ahachad, Hubert Blain, Sylvie Broussous, François Canovas, Florent Cerret, Louis Dagneaux, Valérie Driss, Florence Galtier, Charlote Kaan, Stéphanie Miot, Eva Murauer, Anne-Sophie Vérissimo, Daniela Berg, Kirsten Emmert, Hanna Hildesheim, Jennifer KudelkaScientific2024 · DOI · OpenAlex
The Mobilise-D project represents a significant effort to validate digital biomarkers for health and mobility. Specifically, the project focuses on estimating real-world walking speed across diverse clinical populations using a single waist-worn wearable device. This document serves as an author correction for the original study published in Scientific Reports, addressing specific errors in the reporting of analytical pipelines and statistical reliability metrics.
The Mobilise-D Analytical Pipeline
Accurately measuring gait in "real-world" settings—outside the controlled environment of a laboratory—is a complex task. Patients with conditions such as Parkinson’s Disease (PD) or Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease (COPD) exhibit varied gait patterns that require robust, multi-stage processing.
The Mobilise-D initiative developed a modular analytical pipeline to transform raw accelerometer data into high-level walking metrics. The process involves several discrete algorithmic blocks, as illustrated in Figure 7:
Gait Sequence Detection (GSD): Identifying periods of walking within the signal.
Turning Detection: Identifying the start, end, and degree of turns.
Initial Contact Detection (ICD): Pinpointing the exact moment a foot hits the ground.
Cadence (CAD) & Stride Length (SL) Estimation: Calculating the frequency and average distance of steps.
Walking Speed Calculation: Derived from cadence and stride length.
Walking Bout Assembly: Grouping individual strides into continuous walking events while filtering out physiological or algorithmic outliers.
Figure 7: Overview of the modular algorithmic steps in the Mobilise-D analytical pipeline.
A key insight from the Mobilise-D research is that gait analysis is not "one-size-fits-all." The study utilized two distinct pipelines, P1 and P2, optimized for different movement characteristics:
P1: Tailored for Healthy Adults (HA), Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease (COPD), and Chronic Heart Failure (CHF).
P2: Optimized for Multiple Sclerosis (MS), Parkinson’s Disease (PD), and Proximal Femoral Fracture (PFF).
This modular approach ensures that the algorithms remain sensitive to the specific gait pathologies of different clinical cohorts.
Correction Details
The primary purpose of this correction is to rectify two main issues in the original publication:
Citation Error: A citation error in the analytical pipeline diagram (Figure 7) has been corrected to accurately reflect the source algorithms.
Statistical Reporting: The reporting of Intraclass Correlation Coefficients (ICCs) in the supplementary materials was found to be incorrect. In the original version, ICC values for walking speed were mistakenly reported in place of the correct values for stride length and cadence.
This correction is vital for researchers utilizing the Mobilise-D framework, as it ensures the reliability data for each individual component of the gait model—stride length and cadence—is accurately represented. Reliability for aggregate walking speed is distinct from the reliability of its underlying parameters, and this distinction is now correctly reflected in the updated supplementary tables.
Conclusion
The Mobilise-D project continues to provide a validated framework for digital mobility assessment. By correcting these technical details, the authors ensure the integrity of the analytical pipeline and the statistical benchmarks used to evaluate gait in real-world clinical settings.
Summary updated
BibTeX
@inproceedings{kirk2024author,
author = {Cameron Kirk and Arne Küderle and M. Encarna Micó-Amigo and Tecla Bonci and Anisoara Paraschiv-Ionescu and Martin Ullrich and Abolfazl Soltani and Eran Gazit and Francesca Salis and Lisa Alcock and Kamiar Aminian and Clemens Becker and Stefano Bertuletti and Philip Brown and Ellen Buckley and Alma Cantu and Anne‐Elie Carsin and Marco Caruso and Brian Caulfield and Andrea Cereatti and Lorenzo Chiari and Ilaria D’Ascanio and Judith García‐Aymerich and Clint Hansen and Jeffrey M. Hausdorff and Hugo Hiden and Emily Hume and Alison Keogh and Felix Kluge and Sarah Koch and Walter Maetzler and Dimitrios Megaritis and Arne Mueller and Martijn Niessen and Luca Palmerini and Lars Schwickert and Kirsty Scott and Basil Sharrack and Henrik Sillén and David Singleton and Beatrix Vereijken and Ioannis Vogiatzis and Alison J. Yarnall and Lynn Rochester and C. Mazzà and Bjoern M. Eskofier and Silvia Del Din and Francesca Bottin and Lorenzo Chiari and Cristina Curreli and Ilaria D’Ascanio and Giorgio Davico and Roberta De Michele and Giuliano Galimberti and Luca Palmerini and Saverio Ranciati and Luca Reggi and Marco Viceconti and Lucia D’Apote and Jules Desmond and Megan Doyle and Mary Elliot-Davey and Gilles Gnacadja and Anja Kassner and Beat Knüsel and Monika Pocrzepa and Nicolas Pourbaix and Hoi-Shen Radcliffe and Lening Shen and Jennifer Simon and Jesper Havsol and Diana Jarretta and Magnus Jörntén‐Karlsson and Pierre Mugnier and Solange Corriol Rohou and Gabriela Luporini Saraiva and Henrik Sillén and Michael Karl Boettger and Igor Knezevic and Frank Kramer and Paolo Piraino and H Trübel and Hajar Ahachad and Hubert Blain and Sylvie Broussous and François Canovas and Florent Cerret and Louis Dagneaux and Valérie Driss and Florence Galtier and Charlote Kaan and Stéphanie Miot and Eva Murauer and Anne-Sophie Vérissimo and Daniela Berg and Kirsten Emmert and Clint Hansen and Hanna Hildesheim and Jennifer Kudelka and Walter Maetzler and Bjoern Eskofier},
title = {{Author Correction: Mobilise-D insights to estimate real-world walking speed in multiple conditions with a wearable device}},
booktitle = {Scientific},
year = {2024},
doi = {10.1038/s41598-024-79454-4},
}