Author Correction: Comprehensive molecular characterization of mitochondrial genomes in human cancers
Yuan Yuan, Young Seok Ju, Young-Wook Kim, Jun Li, Yumeng Wang, Christopher J. Yoon, Yang Yang, Iñigo Martincorena, Chad J. Creighton, John N. Weinstein, Yanxun Xu, Leng Han, Hyung‐Lae Kim, Hidewaki Nakagawa, Keunchil Park, Peter J. Campbell, Han Liang, Lauri A. Aaltonen, Federico Abascal, Adam Abeshouse, Hiroyuki Aburatani, David J. Adams, Nishant Agrawal, Keun Soo Ahn, Sung‐Min Ahn, Hiroshi Aikata, Rehan Akbani, Kadir C. Akdemir, Hikmat Al‐Ahmadie, Sultan T. Al‐Sedairy, Fátima Al‐Shahrour, Malik Alawi, Monique Albert, Kenneth Aldape, Ludmil B. Alexandrov, Adrian Ally, Kathryn Alsop, Eva G. Álvarez, Fernanda Amary, Samirkumar B. Amin, Brice Aminou, Ole Ammerpohl, Matthew J. Anderson, Yeng Ang, Davide Antonello, Pavana Anur, Samuel Aparício, Elizabeth L. Appelbaum, Yasuhito Arai, Axel Aretz, Koji Arihiro, Shun‐ichi Ariizumi, Joshua Armenia, Laurent Arnould, L. Sylvia, Yassen Assenov, Gurnit Atwal, Sietse Aukema, J. Todd Auman, Miriam R. R. Aure, Philip Awadalla, Marta Aymerich, Gary D. Bader, Adrian Baez‐Ortega, Matthew H. Bailey, Peter J. Bailey, Miruna Balasundaram, Saianand Balu, Pratiti Bandopadhayay, Rosamonde E. Banks, Stefano Barbi, Andrew P. Barbour, Jonathan Barenboim, Jill S. Barnholtz‐Sloan, Hugh Barr, Elisabet Barrera, John Bartlett, Javier Bartolomé, Claudio Bassi, Oliver F. Bathe, Daniel Baumhoer, Prashant Bavi, Stephen B. Baylin, Wojciech Bażant, Duncan Beardsmore, Timothy A. Beck, Sam Behjati, Andreas Behren, Beifang Niu, Cindy Bell, Sergi Beltrán, Christopher C. Benz, Andrew Berchuck, Anke K. Bergmann, Erik N. Bergstrom, Benjamin P. Berman, Daniel M. Berney, Stephan Wolf, Rameen Beroukhim, Mario Berríos, Andreas von DeimlingNature Genetics2023 · DOI · OpenAlex
In February 2020, the study "Comprehensive molecular characterization of mitochondrial genomes in human cancers" was published in Nature Genetics, representing a significant milestone in our understanding of the role mitochondrial DNA plays in oncology. However, as is common in the era of "Big Science," the complexity of managing contributions from hundreds of researchers led to a necessary administrative correction. This document outlines the formal Author Correction issued to rectify attribution oversights regarding the Pan-Cancer Analysis of Whole Genomes (PCAWG) Consortium.
The Problem: Attribution in the Era of "Big Science"
The primary issue addressed by this correction is bibliographic rather than biological. Large-scale projects like PCAWG involve massive collaborative efforts across dozens of international institutions. In the original publication, the individual members of the PCAWG Consortium were listed only within the Supplementary Information.
In academic publishing, this placement is a significant hurdle for contributing scientists. Supplementary mentions are frequently not indexed by major citation databases such as PubMed or Web of Science. Consequently, the researchers who performed the foundational work may not receive formal credit in their professional records. The correction ensures that the consortium members are recognized as part of the main authorship list, elevating their visibility and ensuring proper indexing.
Scope of the Correction
As this is an editorial correction, it does not introduce new genomic sequencing data or computational pipelines. Instead, it details the administrative actions taken to synchronize the public record:
Consortium Visibility: The HTML version of the article has been updated to include the full list of PCAWG Consortium members and their affiliations directly in the main body of the paper.
Affiliation Alignment: The correction addresses discrepancies in institutional affiliations between the main author list and the consortium list. This reflects the logistical challenge of tracking hundreds of researchers as they transition between institutions during a multi-year project.
Format Discrepancies: Interestingly, the notice highlights a technical limitation in modern publishing: while the HTML version was fully updated with the member list, the PDF version was corrected for affiliation consistency but did not include the full member list in the same manner. This underscores the difficulty of updating "fixed" legacy formats compared to dynamic web-based versions.
Key Insights into Scientific Credit
The "aha moment" of this correction lies in its reflection of the evolving standards for scientific credit. By moving these names to the main paper, the publishers acknowledge that large consortia are primary authorial bodies, not merely secondary contributors. It also highlights the ongoing struggle to manage "hyper-authorship"—papers with hundreds or even thousands of authors—and the technical infrastructure required to support such collaborations.
Conclusion
The primary result of this notice is a corrected and more equitable public record. The update ensures that the massive collaborative effort behind the PCAWG dataset is accurately reflected in the primary literature. Furthermore, the notice reaffirms that the article remains under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 license, ensuring that the corrected information and the underlying research remain freely accessible to the global scientific community. This correction serves as a reminder that in modern genomics, the management of human metadata is as critical to the scientific record as the management of the genomic data itself.
Summary updated
Abstract
Correction to: Nature Genetics, published online 05 February 2020. In the published version of this paper, the members of the Pan-Cancer Analysis of Whole Genomes (PCAWG) Consortium were listed in the Supplementary Information; however, these members should have been included in the main paper. The original Article has been corrected to include the members and affiliations of the PCAWG Consortium in the main paper; the corrections have been made to the HTML version of the Article but not the PDF version. Additional corrections to affiliations have been made to the PDF and HTML versions of the original Article for consistency of information between the PCAWG list and the main paper.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{yuan2023author,
author = {Yuan Yuan and Young Seok Ju and Young-Wook Kim and Jun Li and Yumeng Wang and Christopher J. Yoon and Yang Yang and Iñigo Martincorena and Chad J. Creighton and John N. Weinstein and Yanxun Xu and Leng Han and Hyung‐Lae Kim and Hidewaki Nakagawa and Keunchil Park and Peter J. Campbell and Han Liang and Lauri A. Aaltonen and Federico Abascal and Adam Abeshouse and Hiroyuki Aburatani and David J. Adams and Nishant Agrawal and Keun Soo Ahn and Sung‐Min Ahn and Hiroshi Aikata and Rehan Akbani and Kadir C. Akdemir and Hikmat Al‐Ahmadie and Sultan T. Al‐Sedairy and Fátima Al‐Shahrour and Malik Alawi and Monique Albert and Kenneth Aldape and Ludmil B. Alexandrov and Adrian Ally and Kathryn Alsop and Eva G. Álvarez and Fernanda Amary and Samirkumar B. Amin and Brice Aminou and Ole Ammerpohl and Matthew J. Anderson and Yeng Ang and Davide Antonello and Pavana Anur and Samuel Aparício and Elizabeth L. Appelbaum and Yasuhito Arai and Axel Aretz and Koji Arihiro and Shun‐ichi Ariizumi and Joshua Armenia and Laurent Arnould and L. Sylvia and Yassen Assenov and Gurnit Atwal and Sietse Aukema and J. Todd Auman and Miriam R. R. Aure and Philip Awadalla and Marta Aymerich and Gary D. Bader and Adrian Baez‐Ortega and Matthew H. Bailey and Peter J. Bailey and Miruna Balasundaram and Saianand Balu and Pratiti Bandopadhayay and Rosamonde E. Banks and Stefano Barbi and Andrew P. Barbour and Jonathan Barenboim and Jill S. Barnholtz‐Sloan and Hugh Barr and Elisabet Barrera and John Bartlett and Javier Bartolomé and Claudio Bassi and Oliver F. Bathe and Daniel Baumhoer and Prashant Bavi and Stephen B. Baylin and Wojciech Bażant and Duncan Beardsmore and Timothy A. Beck and Sam Behjati and Andreas Behren and Beifang Niu and Cindy Bell and Sergi Beltrán and Christopher C. Benz and Andrew Berchuck and Anke K. Bergmann and Erik N. Bergstrom and Benjamin P. Berman and Daniel M. Berney and Stephan Wolf and Rameen Beroukhim and Mario Berríos and Youngwook KIM and Andreas von Deimling},
title = {{Author Correction: Comprehensive molecular characterization of mitochondrial genomes in human cancers}},
booktitle = {Nature Genetics},
year = {2023},
doi = {10.1038/s41588-023-01317-x},
}