Angle-Resolved Photoemission Spectroscopy (ARPES) is the premier tool for visualizing the electronic structure of crystalline solids. By shining monochromatic light onto a sample and measuring the kinetic energy and emission angles of the ejected photoelectrons, researchers can map out the material's band structure—the energy-momentum landscape that dictates its electrical, magnetic, and topological properties.
However, standard ARPES faces a fundamental geometric limitation: it is inherently optimized for two dimensions. While the in-plane momentum components ($k_x$ and $k_y$) are strictly conserved as electrons cross the crystal boundary into the vacuum, the out-of-plane momentum ($k_z$) is not. The sudden termination of the crystal lattice breaks translational symmetry perpendicular to the surface, leaving the vertical component of the electron's momentum poorly defined.
Furthermore, this surface termination creates a distinct electronic environment. Materials frequently host two-dimensional surface states—such as topological surface states, Rashba spin-split bands, or space-charge layers—that spatially overlap with the three-dimensional bulk electronic structure. Without a way to resolve the third dimension, these signals blur together, making it difficult to isolate intrinsic bulk properties from surface-specific phenomena.
The Physics of Out-of-Plane Momentum Mapping
To recover the missing out-of-plane momentum ($k_z$), researchers exploit a simple but powerful lever: varying the energy of the incident photons ($h\nu$).
When an electron inside the crystal absorbs a photon, it is excited to a high-energy final state before escaping into the vacuum. By modeling this final state as a free-electron-like parabola shifted by an internal crystal potential ($V_0$), the out-of-plane momentum inside the material can be expressed as:
$$k_z = \frac{\sqrt{2m}}{\hbar} \sqrt{E_{\text{kin}}\cos^2\theta + V_0}$$
Here, $E_{\text{kin}}$ is the kinetic energy of the detected photoelectron and $\theta$ is its emission angle relative to the surface normal. Crucially, the kinetic energy is directly dictated by the incident photon energy ($E_{\text{kin}} = h\nu - \Phi - E_B$, where $\Phi$ is the work function and $E_B$ is the binding energy).
By systematically sweeping the photon energy, researchers can continuously tune $E_{\text{kin}}$, which effectively allows them to scan along the $k_z$ axis in momentum space. As demonstrated by Q. Wang et al. in Dimensionality-controlled Mott transition and correlation effects in single-layer and bilayer perovskite iridates and Guang Bian et al. in Direct transition resonance in atomically uniform topological Sb(111) thin films, this variable-energy approach makes it possible to reconstruct the full three-dimensional Brillouin zone, providing a complete picture of how electronic states vary along the vertical axis of a crystal lattice.
Disentangling Bulk and Surface States
The ability to scan through $k_z$ provides an elegant, geometric criterion for separating bulk electronic states from surface-localized states based on their dimensionality:
- Surface states are two-dimensional. Because they are physically confined to the topmost atomic layers, they lack any meaningful extension or variation along the perpendicular $z$-axis. In momentum space, this means their electronic structure is completely independent of $k_z$. When researchers sweep the incident photon energy, a true surface state will remain entirely stationary in the photoemission spectra.
- Bulk states are three-dimensional. They depend heavily on the out-of-plane momentum. As the photon energy changes, the bulk bands will shift, distort, and repeat periodically, tracing out the true three-dimensional dispersion of the crystal interior.
This operational distinction allows researchers to cleanly decouple overlapping signals. For example, G. Landolt et al. utilized this technique in Disentanglement of Surface and Bulk Rashba Spin Splittings in Noncentrosymmetric BiTeI to separate surface and bulk Rashba spin splittings. Similarly, Tay‐Rong Chang et al. identified intrinsic topological surface states in the superconductor $\text{PbTaSe}_2$ in Topological Dirac surface states and superconducting pairing correlations in PbTaSe2 by isolating the bands that remained invariant across different photon energies, while Rui Lou et al. applied the same logic in Evidence of topological insulator state in the semimetal LaBi to confirm a non-trivial electronic topology. In earlier work, See‐Hun Yang et al. demonstrated in High-resolution Ce 3d−edge resonant photoemission study of CeNi that comparing data across different energy thresholds could isolate surface-specific electronic states to ensure theoretical models are evaluated against representative bulk data.
Controlling Probing Depth with Light Sources
Tuning the photon energy does more than map out $k_z$; it also alters the physical depth that the measurement probes. The distance an electron can travel through a solid without undergoing an inelastic collision—known as the inelastic mean free path—follows a "universal curve" governed by its kinetic energy.
When researchers use low-energy Vacuum Ultraviolet (VUV) light (typically 10–100 eV), the escaping photoelectrons possess kinetic energies that sit right at the minimum of this universal curve. Their mean free path is exceptionally short—often only a few Angstroms—meaning the resulting signal is dominated by the topmost atomic layers. This makes VUV light ideal for capturing sharp, high-resolution signatures of surface-confined states.
Conversely, switching to high-energy Soft X-rays (SX) (typically several hundred to thousands of electron volts) generates photoelectrons with much higher kinetic energies. At these energies, the mean free path increases significantly, allowing electrons originating deep within the bulk to escape without losing their initial energy information.
By pairing these two regimes, researchers can perform depth-selective electronic profiling to isolate intrinsic bulk properties. Zhicheng Rao et al. in Observation of unconventional chiral fermions with long Fermi arcs in CoSi and Hang Li et al. in Chiral fermion reversal in chiral crystals leveraged this dual-energy strategy to decouple overlapping surface Fermi arcs from bulk chiral fermion nodes in crystals like CoSi and RhSn. Similarly, Su‐Yang Xu et al. in Experimental discovery of a topological Weyl semimetal state in TaP and Hongming Weng et al. in Observation of Weyl nodes and Fermi arcs in tantalum phosphide mapped the internal three-dimensional Weyl nodes of tantalum phosphide (TaP) using soft X-rays while independently verifying their external projections using ultraviolet light.
Applications to Quantum Materials
This multi-energy spectroscopic approach has become foundational for discovering and characterizing exotic quantum phases where the three-dimensional nature of the bulk is paramount:
- Topological Semimetals: Probing whether a material is a true three-dimensional Dirac or Weyl semimetal requires verifying that its linear band crossings extend into all three spatial dimensions. Z. K. Liu et al. used variable photon energies in Discovery of a Three-Dimensional Topological Dirac Semimetal, Na 3 Bi to confirm the 3D bulk Dirac cones in $\text{Na}_3\text{Bi}$, while Su-Yang Xu et al. mapped the 3D bulk Weyl cones in niobium arsenide (NbAs) in Discovery of a Weyl fermion state with Fermi arcs in niobium arsenide. Yang‐Hao Chan et al. similarly reconstructed the full 3D band structure of strain-engineered elemental $\alpha$-Sn in Elemental Topological Dirac Semimetal: α-Sn on InSb(111).
- Isolating Intrinsic Bulk Phenomena: In materials with complex phase transitions or surface defects, surface signals can easily mask bulk behavior. Yichen Zhang et al. used depth-resolved photoemission in Charge order induced Dirac pockets in the nonsymmorphic crystal TaTe_4 to distinguish surface states from bulk properties in $\text{TaTe}_4$, revealing how bulk charge ordering induces new Dirac pockets. To understand complex surface space charge layers and band bending on materials like undoped $\text{SrTiO}_3$, Hojoon Lim et al. used energy-tunable depth profiling in Nature of the surface space charge layer on undoped SrTiO3(001) to map the vertical distribution of chemical species across the top few nanometers.
- Disentangling Measurement Artifacts: Sometimes, varying the photon energy helps separate true electronic structures from experimental artifacts. Yang Liu et al. systematically varied photon energy and film thickness in Photoemission Circular Dichroism and Spin Polarization of the Topological Surface States in Ultrathin Bi2Te3 Films to separate intrinsic spin polarization from extrinsic final-state interference effects. Meanwhile, C. E. Matt et al. mapped electronic bands across the third momentum dimension in cuprate superconductors in Direct observation of orbital hybridisation in a cuprate superconductor, directly observing orbital hybridization along the vertical axis to challenge long-standing single-band models.
By treating photon energy not as a fixed experimental constant but as a tunable parameter, variable-energy spectroscopy transforms photoemission from a surface-bound probe into a true three-dimensional tomographic tool for electrons.
Key Foundational Work
Surface and bulk electronic structures of LaFeAsO studied by angle-resolved photoemission spectroscopy (2010) — contributed 1 concept elements to this direction.
High-resolution Ce<mml:math xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML" display="inline"><mml:mn>3</mml:mn><mml:mi>d</mml:mi><mml:mo>−</mml:mo><mml:mi mathvariant="normal">edge</mml:mi></mml:math>resonant photoemission study of<mml:math xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML" display="inline"><mml:mrow><mml:msub><mml:mrow><mml:mi mathvariant="normal">CeNi</mml:mi></mml:mrow><mml:mrow><mml:mn>2</mml:mn></mml:mrow></mml:msub></mml:mrow></mml:math> (2000) — contributed 1 concept elements to this direction.