Most modern music AI systems are trained on datasets that are disproportionately "WEIRD"—Western, Educated, Industrialized, Rich, and Democratic. This reliance on narrow data sources creates a fundamental "black box" problem where models do not just learn to generate music, but specifically learn to enforce a Western aesthetic. As Xingjian Du and colleagues note in Foundation Models for Music: A Survey, this geographic and cultural imbalance risks the erasure of non-Western musical systems and the institutionalization of a singular cultural perspective.
The Structural Mismatch of Music Theory
The failure of AI in global contexts is often structural rather than just a lack of data. Many Music Information Retrieval (MIR) algorithms are built on Western-centric assumptions, such as 12-tone equal temperament and standard 4/4 rhythmic structures.
Gopala K. Koduri demonstrates this in Computational Approaches for the Understanding of Melody in Carnatic Music. In South Indian classical music, melody is defined by gamakas (complex pitch ornamentations) that do not fit into the discrete "note" boxes of Western notation. When models trained on Western folk or pop encounter these traditions, they often simplify or "correct" these complex scales into Western intervals, leading to a loss of cultural authenticity.
The Risk of Cultural Homogenization
When generative models like MusicGen (Jade Copet et al., Simple and Controllable Music Generation) or MeLoDy (Max W. Y. Lam et al., Efficient Neural Music Generation) are optimized for mainstream performance, they tend to produce a homogenized output. Yifei Zhang argues in Utilizing Computational Music Analysis and AI for Enhanced Music Composition that this lack of representational variety marginalizes diverse global traditions, reducing the breadth of the available musical vocabulary for future creators.
This homogenization is not just an aesthetic concern but a technical one. Jongpil Lee and Ji Young Park have shown that representations learned from Western-centric datasets exhibit significant performance degradation when applied to regional genres. The acoustic features and metadata hierarchies that work for Rock or Pop simply do not translate to the unique stylistic nuances of global musical traditions.
Benchmarking for Cultural Diversity
To address these biases, researchers are developing more inclusive evaluation frameworks. Traditional metrics often exhibit a "Western-centric" bias because they are trained on English speech and Western scales.
- ZIQI-Eval: Introduced by Jiajia Li in The Music Maestro or The Musically Challenged, this benchmark specifically incorporates non-Western ethnic music and works by female composers to measure how well Large Language Models (LLMs) understand global musical heritage.
- VERSA: Developed by Jiatong Shi and others, VERSA: A Versatile Evaluation Toolkit for Speech, Audio, and Music aims to standardize metrics while highlighting the lack of tools capable of accounting for regional audio diversity.
Expanding the Training Horizon
The path forward involves the deliberate curation of diverse datasets that move beyond the "MusicNet" (John Thickstun et al., Learning Features of Music From Scratch) classical canon.
For example, the Melon Playlist Dataset (Andres Ferraro et al., Melon Playlist Dataset: A Public Dataset for Audio-Based Playlist Generation and Music Tagging) provides a massive resource for the Korean music market, revealing unique cultural patterns and tag associations absent in Western datasets. Similarly, Fajilatun Nahar and Kat Agres have developed pipelines specifically for Malay, Hindi, Tamil, and Chinese music to bridge the gap in contemporary Asian music analysis.
By shifting toward "situated" AI—as advocated by Giovanni Bindi and the researchers in AI (r)evolution—the field is moving away from universal models toward tools that respect and amplify the specific cultural contexts of the artists using them.