In traditional battery-powered wireless networks, the "near-far problem" is a well-understood phenomenon: radio signals attenuate over distance, meaning a device located close to a base station will naturally enjoy a stronger, higher-throughput connection than a device located at the cell edge.
However, as networks transition toward self-sustaining ecosystems powered by Radio Frequency Energy Harvesting (RF-EH), this spatial disparity does not just increase linearly—it compounds quadratically. This phenomenon is known as the doubly near-far problem. Understanding why this problem occurs, why standard optimization frameworks fail to solve it, and how modern physical and algorithmic architectures mitigate it is essential for building the next generation of perpetual wireless networks.
The Physics of Compounded Path Loss
To understand why the doubly near-far problem is so severe, we must look at the two-way journey of wireless energy and data. In a Wireless Powered Communication Network (WPCN), a central Hybrid Access Point (HAP) or base station first broadcasts RF energy to downstream devices. The devices harvest this energy and immediately use it to power their uplink data transmissions back to the base station.
Consider a device at a distance $d$ from the access point. The power it can harvest from the downlink transmission is subject to path loss, scaling inversely with distance (roughly $\propto 1/d^\alpha$, where $\alpha$ is the path loss exponent). Consequently, a distant device harvests exponentially less energy than a nearby device.
When it comes time to transmit data back to the base station, the distant device faces a second penalty: its uplink signal is attenuated by that same factor of $1/d^\alpha$. As highlighted by Xiao Lu et al. in Wireless Charging Technologies: Fundamentals, Standards, and Network Applications, this creates a dual disadvantage. The edge device has the least amount of energy available for transmission, yet it requires the most power to overcome path loss and achieve a successful uplink connection.
[ Central HAP ] --- (Downlink Energy: 1/d^α) ---> [ Edge Device ]
[ Central HAP ] <--- (Uplink Data: 1/d^α) --- [ Edge Device ]
Total Penalty: 1/d^(2α)
In contrast, a nearby device harvests an abundance of energy and requires very little power to achieve high data rates. In their comprehensive survey, Xiao Lu et al. note that this compounded distance penalty creates severe connectivity and longevity imbalances that distinguish WPCNs from traditional battery-powered systems (Wireless Networks with RF Energy Harvesting: A Contemporary Survey).
The Sum-Throughput Maximization Trap
A naive approach to network optimization is to maximize the total aggregate data rate, or sum-throughput, of the system. However, in a WPCN, this approach exacerbates the doubly near-far effect to the point of total starvation for edge devices.
Because nearby nodes possess excellent channel conditions and high energy harvesting rates, a sum-throughput maximization algorithm will naturally allocate almost all transmission time and energy resources to them. Rui Zhang 0006 demonstrates that prioritizing aggregate throughput inherently neglects equitable resource distribution, leading to chronic energy and bandwidth starvation for any device located far from the power source (Cognitive Wireless Powered Network: Spectrum Sharing Models and Throughput Maximization).
To counteract this, network designers must explicitly embed fairness constraints into their optimization objectives. For instance, Hao Wu et al. utilize proportional fairness scheduling to balance total system throughput with the survival needs of edge nodes in industrial IoT environments (Online Optimization of Wireless Powered Mobile-Edge Computing for Heterogeneous Industrial Internet of Things). Similarly, Trung Q. Duong et al. develop specialized path-following algorithms to guarantee minimum data-rate requirements across full-duplex systems, ensuring that distant users are not silenced by the return-path attenuation (Spectral and Energy Efficiencies in Full-Duplex Wireless Information and Power Transfer).
Algorithmic Remedies: Cooperative Relaying
One elegant way to bypass the doubly near-far problem is to change the network topology through user cooperation. If edge devices cannot transmit directly to the base station due to the compounded path loss, nearby devices can act as intermediate relays.
Because nearby devices harvest a surplus of energy, they can dedicate a portion of their time and power to forwarding the data of distant nodes. The authors of Sum-Throughput Maximization With QoS Constraints for Cooperative WPCNs propose a divide-and-conquer algorithm that dynamically determines when and how users should cooperate. By leveraging the energy surplus of near nodes to satisfy the Quality of Service (QoS) constraints of far nodes, the network eliminates the systemic unfairness of the physical layout.
[ Central HAP ] === (High Power) ===> [ Near Node ] ---> [ Far Node ] (Energy)
[ Central HAP ] <--- (Strong Link) --- [ Near Node ] <--- (Short Link) --- [ Far Node ] (Data)
This cluster-based cooperation can be further enhanced using multi-antenna arrays. Lina Yuan et al. demonstrate that combining cluster cooperation with directional energy beamforming allows the access point to distribute data rates and energy far more equitably, flattening the performance gap between the center and the edge of the cell (Multi-Antenna Enabled Cluster-Based Cooperation in Wireless Powered Communication Networks).
Physical Layer Solutions: Beamforming and Intelligent Surfaces
While scheduling and cooperation mitigate the problem algorithmically, physical-layer innovations aim to reshape the wireless propagation environment itself to neutralize path loss.
Adaptive Beaconing and Massive MIMO
When the access point is equipped with a massive MIMO array, it can focus narrow beams of RF energy directly toward specific devices. However, to do this accurately, the access point needs channel state information, which devices typically provide by transmitting a "beacon" signal.
In a fixed-power system, near devices send strong beacons and receive even stronger energy beams, reinforcing the doubly near-far imbalance. To break this loop, Yong Zeng 0001 et al. propose an adaptive retrodirective beaconing mechanism (Retrodirective Multi-User Wireless Power Transfer with Massive MIMO). By forcing near-field devices to intentionally attenuate their beacon signals, the massive MIMO array is tricked into shifting its beamforming focus toward distant receivers, ensuring fair energy distribution across the network.
Joint Beamforming and Power Control
In applications like over-the-air computation (AirComp)—where data from multiple sensors must arrive at the base station simultaneously and with equal power to be aggregated—the doubly near-far problem can completely corrupt the computation. Siyao Zhang et al. address this by jointly optimizing the access point's energy beamforming and the devices' uplink power control (Optimized Joint Beamforming for Wireless Powered Over-the-Air Computation). This coordinated balancing act ensures that distant sensors receive just enough of an energy boost to overcome path loss, maintaining uniform signal power at the receiver.
Reconfigurable Intelligent Surfaces (RIS)
The latest frontier in combating this spatial imbalance involves the deployment of Simultaneously Transmitting and Reflecting Reconfigurable Intelligent Surfaces (STAR-RIS). Instead of relying solely on the direct, heavily attenuated path between the HAP and the cell edge, Guangyu Zhu et al. use STAR-RIS to split and redirect wireless signals dynamically (Enhancing User Fairness in Wireless Powered Communication Networks with STAR-RIS).
By optimizing the reflection and transmission coefficients of the surface, the system creates a secondary, highly focused path for both energy and data. This effectively bypasses the traditional constraints of distance-dependent path loss, boosting the performance of the weakest edge users and offering a physical solution to the energy-harvesting fairness bottleneck.
Key Foundational Work
Wireless Charging Technologies: Fundamentals, Standards, and Network Applications (2015) — contributed 3 concept elements to this direction.
Wireless Networks with RF Energy Harvesting: A Contemporary Survey (2014) — contributed 2 concept elements to this direction.
Cognitive Wireless Powered Network: Spectrum Sharing Models and Throughput Maximization (2015) — contributed 2 concept elements to this direction.