To understand the intrinsic energetics of distant active galactic nuclei (AGNs)—such as blazars—astronomers must determine their distance, typically quantified by cosmological redshift ($z$). For a specific class of blazars known as high-peaked BL Lacertae objects, traditional optical spectroscopy fails. The relativistic jets of these objects produce intense, non-thermal synchrotron radiation that completely overwhelms the emission from their host galaxies. The result is a featureless optical spectrum devoid of the emission or absorption lines needed to directly measure a redshift (J. Albert et al. 2008; M. L. Ahnen et al. 2018).
Without a known distance, it is impossible to calculate a blazar's intrinsic luminosity or properly model its jet physics. To overcome this, researchers use an indirect method: treating the intergalactic medium as an energy-dependent filter and analyzing the absorption of very-high-energy (VHE) gamma rays.
The Physics of Intergalactic Attenuation
When VHE gamma rays ($E > 100$ GeV) travel across cosmic distances, they pass through the Extragalactic Background Light (EBL)—the diffuse sea of photons emitted by all stars and galaxies throughout cosmic history. If a VHE gamma-ray photon ($\gamma_{\text{VHE}}$) collides with a low-energy EBL photon ($\gamma_{\text{EBL}}$), they can undergo electron-positron pair production:
$$\gamma_{\text{VHE}} + \gamma_{\text{EBL}} \rightarrow e^+ + e^-$$
This interaction absorbs the gamma ray, removing it from our line of sight. The probability of this interaction depends on two primary factors:
- Distance (Redshift): The further away a source is, the more EBL photons the gamma rays must traverse, increasing the likelihood of absorption (J. Albert et al. 2006).
- Photon Energy: Higher-energy gamma rays have a larger cross-section for interacting with the abundant EBL photons. This causes the observed VHE spectrum to appear significantly steeper or "softer" than it was at the source (J. Albert et al. 2008).
Because this attenuation is energy-dependent and scales with distance, the observed distortion in a blazar's gamma-ray spectrum carries an implicit measurement of its redshift.
Reconstructing the Intrinsic Spectrum
To extract the redshift, researchers compare two distinct bands of the gamma-ray spectrum: High-Energy (HE, $E < 100$ GeV) and Very-High-Energy (VHE, $E > 100$ GeV).
HE photons, typically measured by space-borne instruments like the Fermi Large Area Telescope, pass through intergalactic space largely unabsorbed because they lack the threshold energy to pair-produce with the bulk of the EBL. VHE photons, measured by ground-based Imaging Atmospheric Cherenkov Telescopes like MAGIC, are heavily absorbed.
The core intuition of the estimation technique relies on a physical boundary condition: the intrinsic VHE spectrum cannot be harder (flatter or more rising) than the unabsorbed HE spectrum. Standard particle acceleration models within relativistic jets dictate that the spectrum should naturally soften or remain stable at higher energies, but it cannot physically become harder (J. Aleksić et al. 2014; M. L. Ahnen et al. 2016).
Observed Spectrum (Attenuated at VHE)
Flux
^ /-- HE (Unabsorbed)
| /
| / \
| / \-- VHE (Absorbed by EBL)
+------------------------> Energy
Mathematical De-absorption (Testing Hypothesized Redshift z)
Flux
^ /-- Reconstructed Intrinsic VHE (If z is too high, this
| / violates the boundary condition)
| / /
| / /
+------------------------> Energy
To find the redshift, the authors mathematically "de-absorb" the observed VHE spectrum by multiplying the observed flux by $e^{\tau(E, z)}$, where $\tau$ is the optical depth predicted by an EBL density model for a hypothesized redshift $z$ (Jorge Otero-Santos et al. 2021).
Setting Limits and Estimating Distances
By testing a range of redshifts in the EBL models, researchers can establish strict constraints on the source's distance:
- Upper Limits: If a researcher assumes a redshift that is too high, the de-absorption calculation overcorrects for the EBL. This forces the reconstructed intrinsic VHE spectrum to slope upward unphysically, violating the HE boundary condition. The redshift at which the intrinsic spectrum becomes unphysically hard defines a strict upper bound. For example, J. Aleksić et al. 2011 used this approach to constrain the blazar 3C 66A to $z < 0.68$. Similar upper limits have been successfully placed on other prominent featureless sources like PG 1553+113 (J. Albert et al. 2006) and PKS 1424+240 (J. Aleksić et al. 2014).
- Lower Limits: Conversely, if a source is assumed to be too close, the EBL correction is insufficient to account for the observed spectral steepening, requiring an implausibly sharp break in the source's intrinsic emission mechanism. Combining long-term spectral stability with the absence of expected localized absorption features allows researchers to rule out nearby distances, establishing lower bounds (J. Aleksić et al. 2010).
When high-quality, simultaneous multi-wavelength data are available, empirical relationships between the HE and VHE spectral indices allow researchers to move beyond upper limits and converge on specific redshift estimates. This approach has successfully constrained the distances of elusive blazars like 1ES 0033+595 (J. Aleksić et al. 2014), H1722+119 (M. L. Ahnen et al. 2016), and 1ES 0647+250 (V. A. Acciari et al. 2022), providing a reliable alternative to optical spectroscopy.
Key Foundational Work
MAGIC observations of PG 1553+113 during a multiwavelength campaign in July 2006 (2008) — contributed 3 concept elements to this direction.
Detection of Very High Energy Radiation from the BL Lacertae Object PG 1553+113 with the MAGIC Telescope (2006) — contributed 1 concept elements to this direction.