Selection Against Misfolding Shapes Protein Evolutionary Rates

16 concepts10 papers1 proposal

Why do some proteins remain virtually unchanged across hundreds of millions of years of evolution, while others mutate rapidly? For decades, evolutionary biologists hypothesized that a protein's "social life"—the number of physical interactions it maintains with other proteins—was the primary constraint on its evolution. The logic seemed intuitive: a protein with many interaction partners has more functional surfaces to maintain, meaning any mutation could disrupt multiple vital cellular pathways.

However, systematic proteome-wide analyses revealed a different reality. In Protein protein interactions, evolutionary rate, abundance and age, Ramazan Saeed demonstrated that cellular abundance—the sheer number of copies of a protein present in a cell—is a far more powerful predictor of sequence conservation than its network connectivity. This insight was expanded by Eric A. Franzosa et al. in Integrated Assessment of Genomic Correlates of Protein Evolutionary Rate, establishing that abundance is the single strongest genomic predictor of evolutionary conservation.

To understand why a protein's expression level dictates its evolutionary speed, we must look at the biophysics of how proteins behave inside a crowded cell.

Life on the Edge of Solubility

Proteins do not exist in a vacuum; they operate within a highly crowded cellular environment. A fundamental property of nearly all polypeptide chains is their generic propensity to misfold and aggregate into insoluble, toxic structures like amyloid fibrils.

In Protein Solubility and Protein Homeostasis: A Generic View of Protein Misfolding Disorders, Michele Vendruscolo et al. revealed that cells live "on the edge" of a proteostatic catastrophe. The natural abundance of most proteins is dangerously close to their inherent solubility limits. Crucially, the authors found a significant inverse correlation between a protein's natural abundance and its aggregation rate: proteins that the cell requires in high quantities have evolved to aggregate much more slowly than rare, low-abundance proteins.

Evolution, however, does not simply maximize solubility across the board. As Christopher M. Dobson explained in Quantitative approaches to defining normal and aberrant protein homeostasis, proteins are under selective pressure to possess just enough solubility for their specific functional concentration, but very little excess capacity. Using the CamSol prediction framework in Protein Solubility Predictions Using the CamSol Method in the Study of Protein Homeostasis, Pietro Sormanni detailed how this precise tuning balances the functional requirements of a protein against the metabolic costs of maintaining hyper-soluble sequences.

Translational Noise and the Cost of Misfolding

Because proteins are optimized to exist right at their solubility thresholds, any factor that destabilizes their structure poses a severe fitness risk. This risk is amplified by translational noise.

Every time a ribosome translates an mRNA into a protein, there is a baseline probability of error. If a protein is expressed at low levels, a mistranslation event produces only a few defective molecules, which the cell's quality-control machinery can easily degrade. But if a protein is expressed millions of times, even a low error rate generates a massive absolute volume of misfolded molecules.

This volume creates a profound evolutionary constraint. In Natural protein structures have evolved exceptional robustness to mutations, Samuel H. A. von der Dunk et al. explained that highly expressed proteins face intense selective pressure to maintain structural robustness against translational noise. If an abundant protein's sequence is fragile, mistranslated variants will easily cross the threshold into toxic aggregation, overwhelming the cell.

Consequently, evolution strictly limits the sequence variation allowed in abundant proteins. As Eric A. Franzosa et al. noted, this selection alters the underlying amino acid composition of highly expressed proteins, favoring robust amino acids that minimize structural disruption when mutations or mistranslations occur. Traditional evolutionary models that assume uniform abundance fail to capture these structural constraints, a limitation highlighted by Sungsam Gong in Structural and Functional Restraints on the Occurrence of Single Amino Acid Variations in Human Proteins.

The Tug-of-War Between Utility and Toxicity

This expression-mediated constraint creates an evolutionary tension between biological utility and cellular toxicity. A clear example of this tension appears in compositionally biased protein regions, such as domains rich in glutamine and asparagine (Q/N). These domains are highly useful for cellular regulation and forming functional aggregates, yet they carry an inherent risk of triggering pathological misfolding.

In A method to assess compositional bias in biological sequences and its application to prion-like glutamine/asparagine-rich domains in eukaryotic proteomes, Paul M. Harrison demonstrated that while budding yeast utilizes these prion-like domains extensively, they are remarkably rare in humans and fission yeast. This disparity suggests that different organisms experience varying degrees of selective pressure against these sequences, depending on how effectively their specific proteostasis networks can mitigate the associated toxicity.

Reconciling Abundance and Interaction Networks

Where does this leave the original hypothesis regarding protein-protein interaction networks? Physical and functional interactions do impose constraints on sequence evolution. The authors of Protein evolution on a human signaling network showed that interacting proteins exhibit clear patterns of co-evolution, with specific types of interactions (such as activating or inhibitory roles) placing distinct structural demands on sequences.

However, when looking at the proteome as a whole, network properties and abundance are deeply intertwined. In ProteomeVis: a web app for exploration of protein properties from structure to sequence evolution across organisms' proteomes, Rostam M. Razban et al. integrated structural, sequence, and network data to show that highly interactive "hub" proteins frequently occur at much higher cellular concentrations.

While having many interaction partners limits sequence variation at specific binding interfaces, it is the underlying cellular abundance that exerts the dominant, global pressure across the entire protein structure. The molecular clock ticks slowly for abundant proteins because the cell cannot afford the fitness cost of their misfolding; their sequences are locked in place to survive the hazardous physics of a crowded cell.

History & citationVersion 1 · 2026-10-04

Current · Permanent link

View frozen version 1

Cite this direction

Latest version (a living page):

@misc{lacuna_evolutionary_solubility_optimization_7be801df,
  title = {evolutionary solubility optimization},
  author = {{Lacuna}},
  howpublished = {Lacuna research direction},
  year = {2026},
  url = {https://lacuna.tiptreesystems.com/direction/evolutionary-solubility-optimization/rdr_7be801dff5d84aeeaa15629e6be01c1b},
  note = {Latest version of a living research direction; cite a version for a fixed text. Accessed 2026-11-20},
}

This exact version (version 1, frozen text):

@misc{lacuna_evolutionary_solubility_optimization_7be801df_v1,
  title = {evolutionary solubility optimization},
  author = {{Lacuna}},
  howpublished = {Lacuna research direction},
  year = {2026},
  url = {https://lacuna.tiptreesystems.com/direction/evolutionary-solubility-optimization/rdr_7be801dff5d84aeeaa15629e6be01c1b/v/1},
  note = {Version 1, frozen 2026-10-04. Accessed 2026-11-20},
}
About

These directions overlap with this one through shared papers.

See something wrong? Report a mistake