Beyond the Single-Fermion Paradigm
Early research in topological semimetals treated different electronic band crossings—such as Dirac nodes, Weyl nodes, or nodal lines—as isolated phenomena. A material was typically classified under a single banner, hosting just one kind of exotic, massless quasiparticle. This compartmentalization limited our understanding of how different topological phases might interact within the same crystalline environment.
Recently, a paradigm shift has occurred toward viewing crystals as multi-fermion platforms. In a solid-state crystal, the lattice acts as a customizable "material universe." Because the rules of relativity do not restrict these crystal lattices, they can host quasiparticle excitations that are physically impossible in empty space. As Baoliang Lv et al. demonstrated in Observation of three-component fermions in the topological semimetal molybdenum phosphide, a single material can simultaneously host entirely distinct classes of topological quasiparticles, such as triply degenerate fermions and Weyl fermions. This coexistence provides a unified arena to study the interplay, transitions, and interactions between different topological manifolds in a controlled environment.
How Symmetries Permit Coexistence
To understand why multiple distinct quasiparticles can live in the same crystal without destroying each other, we must look at how electronic bands are protected in momentum space (the Brillouin zone).
If a crystal possessed uniform, isotropic symmetry, different band crossings would likely hybridize, open a gap, and annihilate each other. However, crystal lattices are anisotropic. Different regions or directions in momentum space are governed by different subgroups of the crystal's overall symmetry.
[ Crystal Lattice Symmetries ]
/ \
[Direction A] [Direction B]
| |
(Mirror/Nonsymmorphic) (Inversion Broken)
| |
[Nodal Lines / Dirac] [Weyl Points]
\ /
[ Unified Multi-Fermion Platform ]
By utilizing or deliberately breaking specific symmetries, researchers can isolate different types of degeneracies in different parts of the Brillouin zone:
- Symmetry Breaking: In Noncentrosymmetric topological Dirac semimetals in three dimensions, Heng Gao et al. explored how moving away from high-symmetry configurations by removing inversion symmetry lifts constraints. This allows Dirac points to coexist alongside Weyl points and lines.
- Momentum Separation: This structural flexibility was experimentally verified by Xuhui Wang et al. in Effect of symmetry breaking on Dirac points in topological semimetal EuAgBi, proving that Dirac and Weyl points can stably persist along entirely different momentum directions within a single material.
- Inherent Crystalline Protection: Similarly, Hongming Weng et al. showed in Coexistence of Weyl fermion and massless triply degenerate nodal points that WC-type ZrTe naturally hosts both zero-dimensional Weyl nodes and triply degenerate points due to the protection of its specific space group symmetries.
The Menagerie of Coexisting States
The coexistence of topological phases manifests in several distinct configurations, spanning different dimensions, tilts, and even quantum statistics.
Dimensional Hybridization
Materials can simultaneously host topological manifolds of different dimensions. For example, Xinlei Zhao et al. identified a family of magnetic double perovskites in Coexistence of topological Weyl and nodal-ring states in ferromagnetic and ferrimagnetic double perovskites that exhibit a rare simultaneous presence of zero-dimensional Weyl points and one-dimensional nodal rings near the Fermi level.
When these one-dimensional lines multiply, they can form intricate networks. Jinling Lian et al. mapped out multi-loop states in Multi-loop node line states in ternary MgSrSi-type crystals, where different types of nodal lines intersect and interlock to form hybrid Hopf-links and nexus points. Furthermore, Long Chen et al. demonstrated in Multiple Dirac points including potential spin-orbit Dirac points in nonsymmorphic HfGe0.92Te that conventional nodal lines can coexist with symmetry-protected Dirac points in nonsymmorphic structures.
Kinematic and Tilt Variety
Even when hosting the same class of fermion, a material can exhibit variety in how those fermions disperse. Fermions are categorized into types based on the tilt of their Dirac or Weyl cones. Aikaterini Savvidou et al. synthesized the intermetallic compound $\text{Rh}_3\text{In}_{3.4}\text{Ge}_{3.6}$ in Complex Dirac-like Electronic Structure in Atomic Site-Ordered Rh3In3.4Ge3.6, revealing a rare trifecta where Type-I, Type-II, and Type-III Dirac nodes all coexist close to the Fermi level.
Type-I (Standard) Type-II (Over-tilted) Type-III (Critically Tilted)
\ / \ / | /
\ / \ / |/
X X X
/ \ / \ /|
/ \ / \ / |
This dispersion landscape can be shaped by internal electron-electron interactions. In Reshaped Weyl fermionic dispersions driven by Coulomb interactions in MoTe2, Seoung‐Hun Kang et al. demonstrated that Coulomb interactions fundamentally reshape the energy-momentum landscape, allowing Type-I, II, and III Weyl fermions to coexist. This variation can even occur continuously along a single topological feature: Yan Gao et al. showed in <mml:math xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML"><mml:mrow><mml:mi>R</mml:mi><mml:mi>Ru</mml:mi><mml:msub><mml:mi mathvariant="normal">B</mml:mi><mml:mn>2</mml:mn></mml:msub></mml:mrow></mml:math>... that hybrid nodal rings can transition smoothly between Type-I and Type-II Dirac fermion characteristics depending on their exact position along the ring in momentum space.
Beyond Fermions and Bulk Dimensions
This coexistence principle is not restricted to electrons, nor is it limited to purely three-dimensional features.
- Bosonic Systems: H. Miao et al. extended this framework to lattice vibrations in Observation of Double Weyl Phonons in Parity-Breaking FeSi, showing that bosonic systems can host complex topological intersections, including coexisting three-band and four-band crossings.
- Spatial Dimensionality: In layered heavy-fermion systems, the electronic structure itself can exhibit a split personality. Bing Shen et al. showed in Electronic structure of heavy fermion system CePt 2 In 7 from angle-resolved photoemission spectroscopy that the material displays a dual dimensionality, where two-dimensional electron pockets and three-dimensional central features coexist and dictate charge carrier behavior.
Hybrid Surface States and Higher-Order Topology
When multiple bulk topological phases coexist, their corresponding boundary states project onto the material's physical boundaries, creating unique surface signatures.
In d Orbital Topological Insulator and Semimetal in the Antifluorite Cu2S Family: Contrasting Spin Helicities, Nodal Box, and Hybrid Surface States, Xian‐Lei Sheng et al. demonstrated that $d$-orbital driven materials can host hybrid surface states. On the exact same crystal surface, open Fermi arcs (the hallmark of a Weyl semimetal) and closed Dirac cones (the hallmark of a topological insulator) coexist. This hybrid boundary landscape serves as a direct, measurable fingerprint of the underlying multi-phase bulk topology.
Bulk Phase Coexistence Surface Projection
---------------------- ------------------
[ Strong Topological Order ] --> [ Dirac Cones ] \ Hybrid Surface
> States Coexist
[ Higher-Order Top. Order ] --> [ Step-Edge Ch. ] / on Same Crystal
This coexistence can also bridge different classes of topological order entirely. Md Shafayat Hossain et al. discovered a hybrid topological quantum state in A hybrid topological quantum state in an elemental solid, proving that elemental arsenic ($\alpha$-As) simultaneously hosts both strong and higher-order topological orders. This bulk coexistence manifests as unique, robust conducting channels localized specifically along the crystal's step edges. This finding demonstrates that complex hybrid states do not require engineered heterostructures; they can emerge natively within elemental materials.
Tuning the Multi-Fermion Landscape
Because coexisting phases rely on delicate balances of crystal symmetry and orbital energies, they are highly sensitive to external perturbations. This sensitivity makes them highly tunable.
Internal parameters, such as spin-orbit coupling (SOC), can act as a primary switch. As detailed by Rui Yu et al. in From Nodal Chain Semimetal to Weyl Semimetal in HfC, introducing SOC can cause an interconnected network of nodal chains to evolve into a complex Weyl semimetal phase populated by 30 pairs of distinct Weyl points.
External parameters provide an even more direct method of control. In High-pressure opens new windows for topological materials, Hongming Weng demonstrated that high pressure is an effective tool for manipulating these states. By compressing materials up to 100 GPa, researchers can induce new structural phases where exotic Weyl fermions and triply degenerate fermions are forced to coexist at the exact same energy level. Under ambient conditions, these nodes are often separated in energy, meaning one type dominates the material's transport properties while the other remains hidden. Aligning them in energy allows both types of quasiparticles to participate equally in conduction, opening up new possibilities for designing highly tunable quantum electronics and spintronic devices.
Key Foundational Work
Coexistence of Weyl fermion and massless triply degenerate nodal points (2016) — contributed 2 concept elements to this direction.
Electronic structure of<mml:math xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML" display="inline"><mml:mrow><mml:msub><mml:mrow><mml:mtext>Fe</mml:mtext></mml:mrow><mml:mrow><mml:mn>1.04</mml:mn></mml:mrow></mml:msub><mml:mrow><mml:mrow><mml:msub><mml:mrow><mml:mtext>Te</mml:mtext></mml:mrow><mml:mrow><mml:mn>0.66</mml:mn></mml:mrow></mml:msub><mml:msub><mml:mrow><mml:mtext>Se</mml:mtext></mml:mrow><mml:mrow><mml:mn>0.34</mml:mn></mml:mrow></mml:msub></mml:mrow></mml:mrow></mml:mrow></mml:math> (2010) — contributed 1 concept elements to this direction.