Imagine trying to describe a circle using only straight lines. You can approximate its shape by drawing a polygon with dozens of sides, but you will never capture its true, elegant essence. No matter how close your approximation gets, the fundamental concept of a radius remains entirely absent from your vocabulary.
This is the core challenge facing data-driven scientific discovery today. Frameworks like symbolic regression aim to uncover the exact mathematical equations governing physical systems directly from experimental data. However, a fundamental bottleneck limits their success: basis function dependency. Almost all traditional equation discovery methods rely on a predefined library of candidate mathematical terms. If the true physical law contains an operator, transcendental function, or fractional exponent that is missing from this initial dictionary, the system cannot discover it.
The Mechanics of the Dictionary Constraint
To understand why this limitation occurs, consider how classic equation discovery frameworks operate. Methods like sparse identification—exemplified by the PySINDy toolbox developed by Brian M. de Silva et al.—construct a massive matrix of candidate terms (such as $x, x^2, \sin(x), \cos(x)$) based on user assumptions. The algorithm then uses sparse regression to select the fewest terms that best reconstruct the observed dynamics.
As noted by Samuel Rudy et al., this approach assumes the library is complete. If the underlying physical mechanism involves complex non-polynomial interactions or domain-specific primitives, the algorithm is structurally blind to them. As Souvik Chakraborty et al. point out, when a governing principle relies on a functional form absent from this library, the discovery process fails to reconstruct the true physical law, forcing the system to output a flawed numerical approximation.
Predefined Library: [ x, x², x³, sin(x), cos(x) ]
True Physical Law: f(x) = x^1.5 + exp(-x)
Result: The model is forced to build a complex, suboptimal Taylor series
approximation using polynomial terms, missing the true physical structure.
Why Approximations Fail Physical Reality
In traditional machine learning, achieving a low mean-squared error on a test set is often considered a victory. In scientific discovery, however, a close numerical approximation is a liability.
When a model uses a combination of incorrect basis functions to mimic a missing operator, it sacrifices physical truth for curve-fitting. This trade-off has severe consequences:
- Loss of Out-of-Distribution Generalization: The framework MetaPhysiCa demonstrates that when a model fails to recover the exact mathematical terms, it cannot capture the true causal structure of the system. Consequently, its predictions degrade rapidly when faced with unfamiliar initial conditions or system parameters.
- Violation of Physical Invariants: As Daniel M. DiPietro et al. observe, suboptimal approximations typically fail to conserve fundamental physical properties, such as energy or momentum, over long time horizons.
- Interpretability Breakdown: A massive, multi-term polynomial expansion offers no scientific insight to a researcher trying to understand the underlying mechanics of a system, such as biological neural activity or material degradation (Manuel Brenner et al.).
The Search Space Dilemma
A naive solution might be to simply expand the library to include every conceivable mathematical operator. However, this strategy introduces a severe optimization trade-off.
As the single-author paper by N. Makke explains, including irrelevant or overly complex functions in the operator library dramatically increases sensitivity to noise. It causes the search space to explode combinatorially, leading the algorithm to discover physically meaningless expressions that overfit the data.
Furthermore, Wenqing Zheng et al. emphasize that relying on human-defined operator sets inherently biases the discovery process. It restricts the AI to human heuristics and prevents the identification of entirely novel mathematical structures that fall outside our current scientific assumptions.
Evolving Beyond Fixed Libraries
To overcome the constraints of predefined dictionaries, researchers are shifting from static libraries to flexible, generative, and continuous operator spaces.
Spectral and Continuous Parameterization
Instead of forcing a choice from a discrete set of terms, some frameworks parameterize operators continuously. Ravi G. Patel et al. developed a framework that parameterizes differential operators in spectral (modal) space while handling nonlinearities in physical space. This allows the model to learn complex, non-local, and fractional operators without requiring researchers to anticipate their exact functional forms beforehand.
Generative Token Vocabularies
Another prominent direction treats mathematical operators as tokens in a language, utilizing deep generative architectures to construct equations dynamically. Wenqiang Li et al. and Haohan Zou et al. employ Transformer-based models to generate symbolic expressions sequentially. Rather than selecting from a fixed matrix of pre-computed terms, these models learn to synthesize complex transcendental functions and algebraic structures from a primitive vocabulary of basic mathematical building blocks.
Formal Grammars
To ensure that these generative models produce physically valid equations without being constrained by a rigid list, authors have turned to structural rules. Georgios Kissas et al. utilize formal grammars combined with deep generative models to define a mathematical "language" for physical systems. This allows the system to autonomously explore an infinite space of valid constitutive laws, breaking free from the boundaries of traditional, human-curated dictionaries.