In classical algebraic topology, cobordism is a way to classify manifolds by studying how they can be the boundaries of higher-dimensional shapes. When Vladimir Voevodsky brought these ideas into algebraic geometry through motivic homotopy theory, he relied on a crucial assumption: $\mathbb{A}^1$-homotopy invariance. This principle suggests that an algebraic variety $X$ and its product with the affine line $X \times \mathbb{A}^1$ should be viewed as "the same" space, much like how a space and its product with a unit interval are homotopy equivalent in topology.
However, this assumption is a double-edged sword. While it simplifies the math for smooth varieties over fields of characteristic zero, it is fundamentally incompatible with many modern tools in arithmetic geometry. Theories like prismatic cohomology, de Rham cohomology, and the K-theory of singular schemes do not treat the affine line as contractible. Recent research led by Toni Annala, Ryomei Iwasa, and Marc Hoyois has developed a new framework for algebraic cobordism that functions without $\mathbb{A}^1$-invariance, extending the reach of motivic homotopy theory to singular varieties and $p$-adic settings.
The Failure of the Affine Line
The core problem is that $\mathbb{A}^1$-invariance is too "blunt" for arithmetic geometry. As noted in Motivic spectra and universality of $K$-theory, many vital invariants fail to satisfy this property. For example, if you have a singular variety, its K-theory changes when you multiply it by a line. Similarly, in characteristic $p$, the Frobenius map creates structures that $\mathbb{A}^1$-homotopy theory simply ignores.
To fix this, researchers have moved toward a "non-$\mathbb{A}^1$-invariant" motivic homotopy theory. Instead of forcing the affine line to be contractible, they look for a different foundation that still allows for the construction of universal geometric invariants.
The Projective Bundle Formula as a New Foundation
If we can't rely on the affine line being contractible, what holds the theory together? The answer lies in the projective bundle formula.
In Algebraic cobordism and a Conner-Floyd isomorphism for algebraic K-theory, Toni Annala, Marc Hoyois, and Ryomei Iwasa demonstrate that the projective bundle formula is a sufficient "engine" for the theory. This formula describes the cohomology of a projective space bundle over a variety. If a cohomology theory satisfies this formula, you can still define universal Chern classes and orientations—the essential "measuring sticks" of geometry—even if the theory is not $\mathbb{A}^1$-invariant.
This shift allows for the calculation of the Cohomology of the moduli stack of algebraic vector bundles, showing that even in these broader settings, the cohomology ring behaves like a power series ring generated by Chern classes, mirroring classic results from topology.
Leveraging Derived Algebraic Geometry
To make this theory work over general bases like the integers or finite fields, researchers have turned to derived algebraic geometry. Traditional algebraic cobordism often requires "resolution of singularities," a process that isn't always possible in characteristic $p$.
In Derived Algebraic Cobordism, Toni Annala uses derived blowups to construct a bivariant theory. Bivariant theories are powerful because they unify homology (the study of cycles) and cohomology (the study of functions) into a single framework. By working in the derived setting, Annala and Shoji Yokura can handle singular schemes and non-smooth maps that would break traditional theories.
This approach leads to a "base independent" version of cobordism. As shown in Base independent algebraic cobordism, the theory no longer depends on being defined over a specific field of characteristic zero, making it applicable to the integers ($\mathbb{Z}$) and arithmetic schemes.
New Tools for Arithmetic Geometry
This new framework is already yielding results in areas where traditional motivic theory struggled:
- Atiyah Duality: Marc Hoyois and Ryomei Iwasa extended Atiyah duality for motivic spectra to non-$\mathbb{A}^1$-invariant settings. This provides a fundamental symmetry between cohomology and homology for smooth projective schemes over arbitrary derived bases.
- Steenrod Operations: In Motivic Steenrod operations at the characteristic via infinite ramification, Elden Elmanto tackles the "characteristic $p$" problem. By moving beyond standard motivic constraints, it becomes possible to define cohomology operations even when the field characteristic matches the prime of the coefficients.
- Hasse Principle: The broader perspective on cohomology also aids in proving deep arithmetic conjectures, such as Patrick Forré’s work on the Cohomological Hasse principle for higher-dimensional local fields.
By abandoning the requirement that the affine line must be contractible, these researchers have created a more flexible and robust version of algebraic cobordism. This "non-invariant" theory doesn't just fix the gaps for singular and $p$-adic schemes; it suggests that the true heart of motivic homotopy theory lies in the structure of projective bundles rather than the contractibility of the line.